24 Best Italian Restaurants near Poquoson

“awsome place to eat staff is friendly and efficient“

“pretty yummy! great prices. fast service. we will be back“

“Indoor dining with romantic atmosphere. Excellent staff and very attentive.“

“As of yesterday, I was a first timer....we ordered the baked lasagna and a steak n' cheese sub. The food was DELICIOUS, and arrived in a timely manner, still warm,, and packaged nicely....we are ordering the baked lasagna again tonight, and trying the pizza....I highly recommend this restaurant, and have started spreading the word....also, warm and friendly customer service, which can be truly hard to find.“

“The stuffed peppers are my favorite. with a fresh salad and a bottle of red. lasagna is second, always fresh and healthy portions. Pizzas are true Sicilian, don't forget the ancovies. Home made bread for the table, for the calzone and, pizzas made inda house, you can taste the difference from any other Italia resturant in town. Prices are extremely reasonable! Chicken parm, Meatball , Lasagna all made fresh inda house. Great choice of wines by the bottle (take home what you dont finish or the glass. Fresh home made desserts like Caramel apple bourbon bread puddin and NewYork deli style carrot and Cheese cakes too. Reminds me of my Mom's cooking. I've tried them all, my family and friends all love this place. Nicest staff in Yorktown. Call for Rita and book the back room for big family parties. Andrea has it all.“

“I have to give the biggest shoutout to Mama Rosa’s Italian Family Restaurant They deserve 100 stars. We held a private gathering there on March 9, 2026, after a funeral, and they treated our entire family with so much love and care. Anthony was amazing from start to finish, staying in contact, checking in, and making sure everything went smoothly. The whole family and staff were just as kind, welcoming, and attentive. We had over 75 people, and everyone raved about the food (which was delicious!) and the service. They truly went above and beyond for us. After the event, a few of us stayed and talked with their Nona (Mima). She is one of the warmest, sweetest souls I’ve ever met. We shared stories and hugs, and it meant so much. Mama Rosa’s is a treasure. If you’re thinking about going — GO! Don’t think twice.“

“I needed to find a caterer for my classes 50th reunion. Mose worked with me to select a menu that was perfect and met our every need. Classmates are still telling me how much they enjoyed the food. Thank you to the entire Vinny’s staff for doing an exceptional job for us!“

“Our ladies group is returning again tomorrow for another delicious, hot fresh excellent choice of varied, authentic Italian food. The service is great. each of the dishes anyone had were excellent!“

“We had a great dinner at Joe and Mimma’s. The atmosphere is quiet, family-style, and old-school Italian in the best way. It is easy to see why they have been in business for more than 50 years.

Service was friendly and attentive from start to finish.

Everything we ordered was delicious, including Caesar salads, garlic knots, baked ziti, and especially the penne alla vodka with chicken, which was the standout of the meal. Portions were generous and the quality of the food was excellent.

Pricing felt fair and realistic for both the quality and quantity of food we received.

A great local restaurant with good food and good service. We will definitely be back.“

“My mother and I went almost as soon as they opened and the waitress was very pleasant and I would hands down say that this is the best service I have ever had an olive garden. Big shout out to our server Tristan!!! Amazing 10/10 for her service. Very quick and helpful!!“

“Perfect venue for gathering, birthday parties for 20! The service was excellent, the food was delicious. You won’t be disappointed. I highly recommend. Our server was comical and sweet. Thank you.“

“Always love coming here. Went recently and the bartenders were phenomenal.“

“Best food ever! Thanks for keeping the great food coming during covid19“

“Five Stars ⭐️ -Small storefront location but has Wonderful food and very pleasant staff. Plenty of seating inside.“

“They really have good food options and my favourite is the lamb over rice“

“Carry out today not the best. Went through a spell a while back and stopped going for a while. Hope today was just off. Will try again best week“

“Great customer service and pizza. Been going there since they opened that location. Love their Roma crust topping!“

“Wonderful service and great food! Today was our first visit but we will definitely be back.“

“Family restaurant, the best service you can get and the food is delicious. You get an amazing experience for a really good price. I totally recommend this place, the best Italian restaurant I tried in Hampton.“

“First time, husband got spaghetti w/ meatballs. I got pastrami hoagie. Took a house salad, cheesecake and canolli home. Food is fantastic, good service. Wish they had booths and the place felt warmer. Single tables all around felt out of place for an Italian Restaurant with good food. We will be back though“

“Eating at a Vinny’s is like eating with family. Always delicious! Always fast! Always a friendly wait staff! Always so clean! Just like eating with family. We love Vinny’s!“

“This place has some seriously great food. The pizzas are the bomb 💣 😍. The sandwiches are awesome and im obsessed with their salad 🥗. There is so much variety on the menu, and everything I have tried is delicious 😋 so its hard to pick. I certainly wouldn't complain about that cause I know whatever I choose, will be good. This review is coming from a serious picky eater. I only eat at 6 different places in this state, and this is one of them. Im glad its right down the street.“

“My husband grew up in hampton we went there Saturday. The tuna sub i had was very delicious and my husband ,and mother in law and my youngest had a large pizza with pepperoni, sausage ,and onions and they loved it . I recommend it i am sure whenever we are in hampton we will be stopping in for something good off their variety of a menu ...“

“Been coming here since the early 2000's. Travelled to a lot of different places and this is still one of the best pizza places I've been. Highly recommend the stromboli price is right and taste is amazing. Everytime I stop back by Hampton this place is always a must go.“