Italian Restaurants near Castleton

“We went in on a busy Friday night. The staff was working so hard to keep everything moving, but the kitchen had gotten backed up. We witnessed a young young man absolutely lose his mind because he had been waiting. He literally threw a temper tantrum! So embarrassing….for him. Despite his behavior the servers were top notch and we didn’t wait long at all for our dinners. I had the Mediterranean Pasta and it was delicious and big enough for two meals. Thank you for your hard work and we will be back!“

“We stopped by Fair Haven House of Pizza during our weekend trip, and it was an absolutely wonderful experience! 🍕

The garlic bread and pizza are hands-down the best we’ve ever had full of flavor, fresh, and perfectly made. The restaurant itself has such a warm and welcoming atmosphere, and you can immediately tell why it’s been loved in the community for over 42 years.

The owner is truly a wonderful lady who takes pride in her work. She has created her own little Hall of Fame wall filled with customer pictures and memories from the past four decades such a unique and heartwarming touch that makes the place even more special. It’s not just a pizza place; it’s a part of local history and tradition.

The staff is friendly, the service is quick, and you feel right at home the moment you walk in. It’s rare to find a place that combines delicious food, genuine hospitality, and such a rich story behind it.

Highly recommend this spot if you’re ever in Fair Haven it’s a true gem worth visiting again and again!“