37 Best Bakeries near Middleton

“When I was a four year old wee little sprout I learned if I didn’t like something I just didn’t go back. Instead of childishly trying to ruin their business online. Miggy’s is a hard working and professional business that makes delightful desserts! It pleases me to see a business willing to stand up to bullying :)“

“We came across your bread at a local thrift shop they had fresh bread they brought in from your bakery it it's absolutely fantastic. We frequent Wisconsin often and will be in to see the bakery itself. 10 out of 10“

“C’s Restaurant and Bakery is your friendly neighborhood breakfast, lunch and bakery diner. The food is great, fairly priced and the bakery is to die for! The Wait Staff is just a pleasure to be around. If you haven’t been here yet, don’t wait any longer. Go now!“

“It was my first time stopping by this Crumbl shop, and everything was so delicious. The display looked incredibly clean and beautiful — I’ve never seen such a stunning presentation anywhere else. Even the cookie cut was just wow! The entire staff was very polite, and everything was spotless. Just wow. I already know I’ll be coming back again and again🤤.“

“We were looking for Brownies for our wedding dessert and thank goodness we found The Baled Lab. They were wonderful and so easy to work with! The brownies… to die for!!! It was so hard narrowing down which ones to choose for the wedding. We also got a small Salted Carmel cake which was delicious and exactly what we wanted. We can’t wait to find another reason to work with them and get more delicious desserts.“

“I eat keto when possible, and Paleo Mama Bakery has amazing keto-friendly goods. They are as beautiful as baked goods from traditional bakeries, and they taste delicious! A lot of the time, I find keto-friendly frosted goods to be really heavy, but these are not as heavy as others I've tried. I've even gone out of my way to get a birthday cake from here (I live almost 150 miles away) because they are perfect for special occasions when people are eating low-carb/keto. I've attached a photo of a slice of the keto carrot cake, which was delicious!“

“Our Christmas variety cookies just arrived today from Yummee Treats! The dough was so rich and dense, and the fillings, chocolate, smores, oatmeal, and pecan were soooo good! They ship internationally to your doorsteps within a day or two! 😋“

“This cafe has many delicious options for food. It however does not have celiac safe options. The cross contamination is too high. They do note this if you call them by stating that they can't guarantee there isn't. But I would not eat here if you have celiacs because I did twice and it made me incredibly sick. Again the food in my opinion is delicious, it just isn't celiacs safe.“

“Craig's is amazing! From birthdays to weddings they can make it happen! As a father and a weddding planner I cannot reccomend them enough!“

“Finally stopped in after watching people rave about them online for almost a year. I ordered a chocolate orange croissant thing and let me tell you when I say that thing blew my mind like wow. I knew it was good from people raving about it but I was so impressed dropped the last bite on the floor and about died I was so sad 😅 the lovely lady also gave me a free shortie I was eyein up 10/10 recommend so good I will be back“

“I love El Hornito. I love all flavors of the Mexican tacos they offer. Me encanta el hornito. Me encantan igualmente todos los sabores de tacos mexicanos que ofrecen.“

“We were on vacation and we were not leaving Wisconsin without mapping and getting to Stella’s! Seriously the best breads and pastries we have ever had… The cheese bread is the absolute best!!! The customer service was exceptional and very helpful! Now we just need to get one in Indiana!“

“Fresh, delicious and new to me flavors. Thank you for opening my world to your baked goods!“

“Madison Sourdough doesn't really need another 5-star rating. However, I just want to make a comment on this amazing establishment. This is a special bakery. The bread made here is some the best we have had. The Miche is out of this world, get one if you can. The other sourdough bread options (batards) are great too, especially the one with pepitas/polenta. Their other bakery items and pastries are wonderful. Their croissants are perfectly browned, buttery and flaky. Their elevated food options are worth planning for if you are hungry for breakfast or lunch. If in Madison...put this place on your intinerary!“

“Rolling Pin did an absolutely amazing job for my daughter’s Golden Birthday. While ordering the cake, I spoke with Faith, who would be making the cake and I gave her very limited wants/needs for the design and basically said “all I want, is for my daughter to see the cake and be shocked”. I was completely blown away when I picked the cake up and when my daughter saw it, she couldn’t believe how absolutely amazingly beautiful it was. A+++ for Rolling Pin and the entire staff that I interacted with, oh and the cake itself, delicious.“

“Our company brought a variety of cupcakes in for our annual awards ceremony and they were fabulous! Highly recommend these delicious treats 🧁“

“The pinnacle of Sourdough baking that I have found in the Midwest. Amazing! Great Job!“

“Quick and fast service definitely recommended“

“They really outdid themselves, cake looks way better than the inspiration picture I sent them! Gorgeous work! Will always be back for any sweet needs from now on.“

“Great ambiance, and delicious pastries! If you aren’t a coffee person, like me, Alice has a variety of teas for us tea lovers. The staff is very kind. I also love to support local businesses! Give Alice Good Coffee a try! You won’t want to leave ☺️“

“So good!! we got two things from them at the farmers market. my girls loved the treats!!“

“One of my favorite foods is pastys, I was excited to learn about this place, otherwise you would find them normal in the u.p area of Wisconsin. All of the varieties are great! Had the chicken tikka masala one today, was awesome! I do like they wrap it in foil, because my 40min drive home it's still warm!“

“We stopped in before a concert and was greeted by a friendly staff member. Went in for a water came out with donuts and a fritter. The donuts and fritter were fresh and delicious. We stopped after the concert to take some home. The staff were amazing, friendly and selection was great even though it was late. Best donuts we’ve.had in a long time. Thanks for the great service🍩“

“I came back to town and visited two days in a row. I’d forgotten how much I love this place!“

“Melissa made all of the desserts for my wedding on 5/21/22 and they were all AMAZING. I was actually a bit disappointed that there were no leftovers! I have Celiacs disease, and Melissa was even able to make everything gluten free - cake, cake pops, Oreo balls, and pie bars...wow! The dessert displays and the cake decorations were also beautiful. We got so many compliments on the desserts, and Melissa was so easy to work with. Thank you, Melissa!“

“beautiful location, great service and wonderfully cozy atmosphere!“

“Good Auntie Annes
Friendly employees
Good pretzels
I also noticed that this auntie Anne’s sells pretzels about $1 cheaper then Auntie Anne locations inside malls
The seating area here is small but it’s clean.
Conveniently located on state street,near UW
Madison and near downtown Madison.
Heads up no Public restroom available here.“

“We love getting food here. We have never had a disappointing dish. Every item is thoughtfully made and delicious. My kids are big fans of the seasonal pancakes.“

“That was the most luxurious semi-sweet pastry I have had in a very long time. It was very reasonably priced, and I had a wonderful experience:

1. Use the tongs
2. Put it on the tray
3. Walk to the front counter“

“The Miel iced latte is fantastic & refreshing !
We are in from out of town and stayed at the Grandstay just a few minutes down the road. Coffee shops are the first thing I googled & this did not disappoint! The charm of the old mill mixed with current day interior design. What a joy to find this gem. Recommend as a visitor for sure!“

“Very quaint! Yummy food! Highly recommend the hot cocoa bombs!“

“Wow Taste so Good! We will back again next time :)“

“Delicious gluten free scones and breakfast sandwiches.“

“Excellent soup and salad bar“

“Jane's is a funky little cafe & bakery. Surrounded by art from local artists. Open only till 3 in the after noon it's mostly breakfast and lunch. Counter served multi-cuisine fare that's fresh and family friendly. Their signature scones and pasteries are to die for with flavors you won't see anywhere else. Also great for Vegans and Vegetarians.“

“Driftless is one of my favorite coffees. So much so that I ordered some to be delivered to me in North Carolina. If you want a really good tasting coffee, look no further. Wish I was closer to a location, but will be in heavy rotation for delivery.“