Bayside Supper Club
$$ •About Bayside Supper Club
Customers' Favorites
French Fries and Salad Bar
BBQ Ribs & Chicken Tenders
Salad Bar Ala Carte
Lake Perch Platter
Broasted Chicken
Shrimp Cocktail
Seafood Platter
Sunday Buffet
Bayside Supper Club Reviews
176 ratings
Share your opinion about Bayside Supper Club
Super friendly spot. Went there for a fish fry and my husband was delighted that they had something in addition to cod. Highly recommended
We were staying nearby and wanted something close to eat. Happy we stopped here! Saturday night is prime rib and seafood buffet, $29.99. Best deal on the menu and she had us go look at the buffet first to ensure we were happy with our choice. Kids are $1/year old. It isn’t a huge buffet but honestly all the food you need. Prime rib, short ribs, haddock, pasta, the best roasted potatoes, and some fried options like shrimp, chicken tenders and fries. The salad bar also had...read full review
We came here for the Friday night fish buffet. It did NOT disappoint! Very nice salad bar. Not only could you make a lettuce salad, but they had coleslaw slaw, potato salad, cucumber salad, a few pasta salads which was a nice selection. The buffet has deep fried cod that is outstanding! A nice beer batter on it. I also was impressed thst they had crab and shrimp alfredo. That was very delicious! We got a table by the window looking out at the lake. It was beautiful! Prices were...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 5 - 8PM |
| Friday | 4 - 8:30PM |
| Saturday | 5 - 8:30PM |
| Sunday | 10:30AM - 1:30PM |
.jpg)
Bayside Supper Club offers a delightful dining experience, featuring a "lovely Easter Brunch" and a "very nice banquet hall for weddings." The restaurant impresses visitors with its "ability to get that much good food out to a fairly large group," and the "nice bar" adds to its charm. Guests enjoy a great view of the lake from the dining room, and the space is perfect for large parties.
Many customers appreciate the buffet, which includes a selection of "really good entrées" like prime rib, shrimp, and scallops, all for a reasonable price. The prime rib is particularly praised as "the best prime rib" many have ever had. The salad bar is also highlighted as delicious, making it a great addition to the meals. While some have experienced less favorable quality with the fish fry buffet, overall feedback on the food is positive.
With friendly owners and staff, Bayside Supper Club provides a welcoming atmosphere for all visitors, making it a place many are eager to return to.