Sgambati's New York Pizza

CLOSED
$$ •

Sgambati's New York Pizza Reviews

Write a review

July 2023

I have always enjoyed their food and was really craving it last weekend. My girlfriend and I went and about 1/3 of the tables were full and a couple more people waiting for takeout. We ordered water and got the garlic knots right away. They were delicious like always. An hour passes and as we were waiting patiently we were told that our order was mistakenly deleted so we had to reorder (Chicken parm and a grilled chix sandwich). The waitress was very apologetic so we reordered...read full review

January 2024

Bartender was really nice and accomodating. The last time I was here the wings were great. This time I sent them back after 1.5 wings. Dry and chewy. Flavor was good though. Bartender was completely understanding. I'll try again in a month or two. Hope they can dial it in. Great location, great food concept. Good beer selection too.

November 2023

I wish Ray still owned the restaurant. I just ate there recently and found that so many things have changed. The garlic knots were undercooked and had very little garlic. The pizza crust was subpar. Normally I eat every bite of the pizza slice but I left the outside crust on all of my slices. It was flat, dry and flavorless. Above all, they changed the spicy New York style sausage slices to balls of sausage. It tastes about the same but it's completely different when the sausage...read full review

More Reviews(268)