New American Restaurants near Elkhart Lake, WI

Paddock Club American • $$
61 S Lake St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Panacotta with Fresh Berries
Mushroom Risotto Fritters
Eggplant Caprese Salad
Rock Shrimp Linguine
Roasted Duck Breast
Spaghetti Bolognese
Grilled Hanger Steak
Spaghetti Carbonara
Grilled Broccoli
Potato Gnocchi

“Any and every thing tastes excellent here! Love this place and the staff especially! Jim and Ann“

4.7 Superb68 Reviews
Brown Baer Bar • $
181 E Rhine St, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Baer Burger and Kettle Chips
Giant Pretzel

“I have been a regular for years and have always ordered to go. Tonight I called to place an order and you're not doing to go's. by no means am I saying people shouldn't go there they absolutely should your food is great. I've just never had this happen before in years of ordering and I definitely think it's a flaw to the business. yall missed out on a good $100 order. lol the reason for no to go's was on busy weekends you dont do togos. totally fine. but could you maybe include that in a post in the future? I'm honestly so bummed I'm missing your dinner. I'm just super autistic when it comes to eating. lbvs so I'm struggling now to figure out how to feed myself and my dad who I care for 😭😭😭 food is always awesome, workers are always great. a heads up of no to go orders would make you perfect 💜 also love your non alcoholic options for people who don't drink.“

4.5 Superb31 Reviews
The Social American • $$
283 Victorian Village Dr, Elkhart Lake

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Mushroom Pizza
Eggs Benedict

“The food that we got (hummus plate and salad) was really good! I was disappointed, though, that the online menu didn’t match the menu in restaurant. As a vegetarian, I was really counting on the mushroom flatbread being available and it was not so we skipped entrees and stuck to appetizers.

Good service, though, and they were running a 25 cent beer deal!“

2.5 Average11 Reviews
Korner Kitchen American • $
1305 Milwaukee Dr, New Holstein - 8.38 miles

Customers` Favorites

Four Piece Broasted Chicken Dinner
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Hamburger with Fries
Meat Lovers Skillet
Roasted Pork
Perch
Soup

“Home made soups, fresh, crispy salads, amazing burgers, wraps and fish fries. And on top of that...great, friendly service. This place ia s favorite for sure“

4.9 Superb44 Reviews
Schwarz's Supper Club Steak House • $$
W1688 Sheboygan Rd, New Holstein - 6.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Desperate Housewife After Dinner Drink
Tenderloin with Boasted Potatoes
Tenedeloin and Lobster Tail
Prime Rib Dinner for 2 Rare
Brandy Old Fashioned Sweet
Tenderloin with Scallops
Old Fashion Brandy Sweet
Tenderloin with Shrimp
Large T-Bone Dinner
Onion Ring Haystack

“Excellent food and service.“

4.6 Superb123 Reviews
City Club Tavern & Grill Bar • $
228 E Mill St, Plymouth - 6.25 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cod Dinner with Fries and Slaw
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Shrimp and Perch Dinner
Chicken Tenders Dinner
Double Cheese Burger
Beer Battered Cod
Broasted Potatoes
Fried Chicken
Cheeseburger
Cheese Curds

“New to area, first time visit to City Club was awesome. We had steak sandwich and gyro. Both excellent. Sat at bar and Sean was so pleasant. definitely going back. Thanks much for a good experience. They even had a wine I could enjoy which is rare in the local pubs that focus on beer.“

4.5 Superb41 Reviews
Riverview Family Restaurant American • $
128 Fremont St, Kiel - 5.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Country Fried Steak w Scrambled Eggs
Beef Vegetable Soup Du Jour
Crispy Chicken Salad
Grilled Chicken Salad
Pancake Combo
Fish Sandwich
Raider Special
blt Sandwich
Fish Sampler
Perch Dinner

“Food & service was great will be back there again“

4.4 Superb31 Reviews