Pizza Restaurants near Ellison Bay

“I can’t say enough about La Cocina!!! We have a family cottage in Ellison Bay and are from Chicago - so we take pizza probably a little TOO seriously! La Cocina tastes like home.One day over this summer we called to place an order and their oven was broken. They were so sorry they couldn’t help us and even called the next day to say they were up and running once again. Customer Service like that is almost impossible to find nowadays. We were shocked. Let’s just say they have customers for life in us! They are the kindest group of people that take such pride in their work and their ingredients are of the highest quality.I want to keep them our little secret, but that’s unfair - give them a try, you won’t be disappointed!“

“Food is always great, and last evening was no exception. Absolutely delicious every time, hands down the best food in Door County. The Arancini are to die for and my wife loves the Bolognese which she said was superb as always. We have been hesitant to make the trip all the way from Fish Creek lately due to the short hostess/manager. I always told my employees to leave their egos at the door when they walked in for a reason, and she was a prime example of putting oneself in front of the business. As other reviews noted, the wound up and short with customers style is a huge turn off. Always micro-managing and creating confusion amongst the staff, jumping from the front door to behind the bar into the kitchen, and working over the top of the staff just to leave and talk to friends when they arrive, leaving the staff without the “help” she forced onto them, resulting in a breakdown in the flow and visible frustration from the staff. I’ve seen staff try to step up but are undermined by the furious micromanaging, almost as if she’s afraid that she won’t be perceived as the star of the show when the food itself should be (and clearly is). However, we have been there a few times the past few weeks and have not seen her, so either we have been lucky with their schedules or they are reorganizing now that the tourists are gone. Either way, the dynamic has visibly changed and the staff seems to be working better together, complimenting each other’s roles. Last evening, instead of the usual headache, the bartender last evening that greeted us was warm and welcoming, spending time interacting with returning customers like us and new customers like my friends and giving support when needed to our server Mary, who was absolutely charming, making everyone at our table and those around us feel special and welcome like a guest in her home and not simply a “customer”. If last night is indicative of the operation now, my wife and I will be back often and these guys don’t deserve the reputation as the drive up is well worth it.“

“As the menu states, the pizza takes 30 minutes but well worth it! The beer and wine selection seems carefully and intelligently curated, and the gentleman behind the bar manages the entire place with ease, even though he is the only one there. Will definitely return again soon!“

“Mike is the very friendly owner who not only made us a great supreme pizza, but went out of his way to suggest local attractions I would be interested in.Vegetarian options: Pizza toppings could be customized for veggie only eaters, and the pizza is freshly made.Parking: Ample parking out front.“

“Im working not far from your amazing sub kitchen, and your Italian sub is the best of its kind that I've ever had! It starts with the amazing bread!!!! It's absolutely amazing all the way around, and I can't wait to eat ANY other sub that you guys make! DELICIOUS IS AN UNDERSTATEMENT!!!“

“Consistantly good pies, fun venue and good-natured staff. Beautiful views of the bay a great area to walk after taking in a meal. Right on the main strip in Door Co so it is usually a struggle to find a parking spot. Always enjoy our visit here and we will return!“