10 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sister Bay

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay Pizza • $
10677 N Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay

Customers` Favorites

Green and Gold Pizza
Large Deluxe Pizza
Fried Cheese Curds
The Green and Gold
Donation Creation
Old School Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Chicken Tenders
Parmesan Knots
Cherry Walnut

“We tried to eat WT in Fish Creek but the wait was long, ended up taking a carry out and beer to the park, we weren't sure what to expect, place looked lovely, bar outside was great especially the bartender from St. Charles ( hey girl! we made it back to Chicago and possibly see You this Fall! ) ... pizza was TO DIE FOR!!! We got the FUN-GUY and wow wow wow, great job guys😍 we'll be back!“

4.6 Superb540 Reviews
Thyme Restaurant & Catering New American • $$
10339 WI-57, Sister Bay

Customers` Favorites

Nut Crusted Salmon w Basmati Rice
Cherry Bomb Chicken Sandwich
Spicy Thai Cauliflower Bites
Pear and Goat Cheese Salad
Vanilla Bean Creme Brulee
Mushroom Risotto w Shrimp
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Grilled Romaine Caesar
Coconut Curry Chicken
General TSO's Chicken

“I am always happy with what I purchase from Thyme. Great cheeses and grab n go options too.“

4.7 Superb171 Reviews
Door County Ice Cream Factory & Sandwich Shoppe Dessert • $
11051 WI-42, Sister Bay

Customers` Favorites

Death's Door Fudge Door County Cherry and Housemade Waffle Cone
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
Island Coconut Ice Cream
Chambers Island Fudge
Strawberry Ice Cream
Mint Chocolate Chip
Strawberry Sorbet
Sundaes
Turtle
Cookie

“The best ice cream in Door County. Great place for a good sandwich as well.“

4.6 Superb326 Reviews
Northern Grill & Pub Pizza • $$
10573 Country Walk Dr, Sister Bay

Customers` Favorites

Friday's White Fish Fry
Chicken Parmesan
Pepperoni Pizza
Fish and Chips
Perch Fish Fry
Cheese Burger
Beef Burger
Meat Pizza

“Sunday night dinner in the Sister Bay area- we are new to the area, so went to the closest restaurant we could find. Atmosphere is a typical north woods vibe (large bar area, dark wood), but the food is a mix of American/Italian.
Companion had the spaghetti pomodoro, which came with soup or salad- the Caesar salad was very good, with homemade garlic croutons. The pasta was confusing as it contained sausage- something usually not found in pomodoro. She ate it anyway as she didnt want to make a fuss. Said it was good despite the protein.
I ordered a gluten free GOAT pizza. Dried cherries, chevre, bacon, topped with arugula and a balsamic drizzle. Not bad, but needed a little something. It could have been because GF crust isnt as flavorful as regular.
Both ordered the NA cherry fizz- delightfully flavored with tart cherry juice(when in Door county...).
Ended the meal by sharing the Gluten Free chocolate torte- delicious!
Bill came and although pricey for some pasta, pizza and no alcohol, on par for the touristy DC area.“

4 Good211 Reviews
SubExpress & Pizza Primo Sandwich Shop • $
2579 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay

Customers` Favorites

Italian

“Wow, this place is incredible. The best subs around!! Also incredible pizza And quick breakfast sandwiches!! I got some salsa today with the mini tacos. Incredible salsa, gotta be homemade! Friendliest staff and just all around great!! Gotta stop in!!“

3.9 Good30 Reviews
Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Fish Creek Pizza • $
4023 WI-42, Fish Creek - 7.08 miles

Customers` Favorites

Southern Smoke BBQ Pork Pizza
Old School Wood Fired Pizza
Roasted Tomato & Burrata
Sausage and Pesto Pizza
Donation Creation Pizza
Wood-Fired Bread Basket
The Green & Gold Pizza
Sausage & Pesto Pizza
Cherry Walnut Salad
Mediterranean Pizza

“Always amazing! Drive 4 hours just for the pizza!� �. Don’t forget the bread basket! Today’s pizza was Mediterranean. Thank you!!“

4.3 Superb327 Reviews
Della Porta Italian • $$
12029 WI-42, Ellison Bay - 5.18 miles

Customers` Favorites

Paccheri Alla Genovese
GF Pizza Margherita
Rigatoni Bolognese
Whitefish Special
Torta Siciliana
Burrata Salad
Fritto Misto
Bruschetta
Tiramisu
Arancini

“I've never had a gluten free pizza crust as good as this. we ordered an Americano pizza. sausage, pepperoni and mushroom. paired with a beet and goat cheese salad. I highly recommend this restaurant. I love the Blue Bear too for lunch.“

4.4 Superb237 Reviews
Bad Moravian Beer Gardens • $$
3055 Church St, Ephraim - 3.22 miles

Customers` Favorites

Kalamata Olives
Pilsner
Sausage

“The pizza is totally legit. It is totally awesome, authentic Detroit-style pizza (slightly-charred, buttery crust) that includes an awesome Chicago-style topping (fresh tomato)...best of both worlds! Loved the selection of craft beers (in cans), including some N/A choices. Nicely done! Special shout out to Ryan who efficiently ran the entire front room the night we were there. Finally, the price. No, seriously, it is impossible to find better pizza at a better price...anywhere. SO glad we found you, Bad Moravian. We'll be back!“

4.7 Superb40 Reviews
BaySide Tavern Bar & Grill • $
4160 Main St, Fish Creek - 7.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Curds Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes
Bayside Bloody Mary Beer Chaser
Smilen' Bob's Chili Pizza
Cheese Curds with Ranch
Bayside Deluxe Pizza
Sweet Potato Fries
Bacon Cheeseburger
Grilled Cheese
Fish and Fries
Fish and Chips

“Great atmosphere! Get the chili! Cheese curds also always on point. Fun energy, fun decor. Great place to catch a game.“

3.9 Good323 Reviews
Stone's Throw Winery Wineries • $$
3382 County Rd E, Baileys Harbor - 9.8 miles

“My husband and I had the best experience today visiting and trying their wonderful assortment of wines. Got to pick out a few for us and a couple for my Florida family. Daniel was very knowledgeable and fun to talk to! Thanks for a great time!!!“

3.6 Good124 Reviews

You May Also Like