14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sister Bay

“Wild Tomato never disappoints! We usually visit in the off-season, but even in the busy season this place is amazing. Best. Pizza. Ever. �“

“They were so nice and turned the back TV to Sunday Night Football for us. We’ve been coming up for many years and always try and hit the Northern Grill. One year we discovered all you can eat spaghetti night. They no longer do that but we still get the spaghetti. Prices have gone up and they have reduced their portion size and nights they are open. But we still recommend it.“

“Absolutely hands down the best meal I've ever had at a restaurant!! The food was so amazing. The restaurant is small and quaint, staff is attentive and so kind. Recommend this place to everyone we met over our 3 day stay in Door County. We ate here 2 nights in a row. Cheese curds, Cubano, Braised short ribs and the burger were PERFECTION, not to mentionthe creme brulee!! Hats off to the chef. Waitresses were so good also (Jessica and Taylor). Thank you for a great experience.

Parking: Parking lot was very dark, could use more lighting. Only negative.“

“The best ice cream in Door County. Great place for a good sandwich as well.“

“Im working not far from your amazing sub kitchen, and your Italian sub is the best of its kind that I've ever had! It starts with the amazing bread!!!! It's absolutely amazing all the way around, and I can't wait to eat ANY other sub that you guys make! DELICIOUS IS AN UNDERSTATEMENT!!!“

“Always order the deep dish pizza- only available in one size as per the menu 11 inch. As with any pizza place- tell them the crust you would like- think, hand tossed , deep dish they always accommodate. The pizza is always fresh and delicious! Delivered hot to my door! Awesome, friendly people to work with!“

“I do like the crispy crust !“

“Very enjoyable inn. Was only there for 1 night, but I will return. Great location and friendly, welcoming host. Also, try the pizza from Sunset Pizza on location. Great pizza and the person making it was a delight to talk with. Will be back soon!“

“We love Wild Tomato! Great food, tremendous service and wonderful vibe. Cannot recommend them enough?“

“The pizza is totally legit. It is totally awesome, authentic Detroit-style pizza (slightly-charred, buttery crust) that includes an awesome Chicago-style topping (fresh tomato)...best of both worlds! Loved the selection of craft beers (in cans), including some N/A choices. Nicely done! Special shout out to Ryan who efficiently ran the entire front room the night we were there. Finally, the price. No, seriously, it is impossible to find better pizza at a better price...anywhere. SO glad we found you, Bad Moravian. We'll be back!“

“Russell is a true gem! Love the wines and the attention to detail for his patrons!“

“Absolutely fantastic place to eat. The inside is modern. The staff is incredibly friendly. Everything we ate here was delicious. The one star of the meal was the arancini. This was the best arancini my wife or I have had anywhere.

The one other thing we really appreciated was the cook on the pizza. Many places that cook neopolitan pizza leave the center a soft soupy mess. They intentionally cook the pizza slightly longer so the pizza dough firms up a little and I personally really appreciated this. Limoncello mule and Aperol spritz were the winners for us drink wise.

This was a random stop for us on our first night in Door County and it ended up being our new favorite place in Door County and the highlight of our trip. Will definitely be back.

Vegetarian options: Multiple pasta and pizza options that are vegetarian friendly. Vegetable lasagna and pistachio pesto pasta dish.

Dietary restrictions: Multiple vegetarian options. Have a gluten free options as well.

Parking: If lot is full there is street parking. Free lot.

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a wheelchair ramp into building.“

“A favorite stop for great dining in Fish Creek!“

“Russell is a true gem! Love the wines and the attention to detail for his patrons!“