26 Best American Restaurants near Sister Bay

“Great sandwiches, love the outdoor seating!“

“I've been there a few times, everything has been wonderful. Turkey sandwich was delicious, and the "adult" grilled cheese was amazing. I was a bit skeptical about the fig jam, but wow, it was great. Also, the music playlist that is in the background just happened to hit one favorite after another. Go there. Everyone's super welcoming and the service is efficient but not hovering.“

“We tried to eat WT in Fish Creek but the wait was long, ended up taking a carry out and beer to the park, we weren't sure what to expect, place looked lovely, bar outside was great especially the bartender from St. Charles ( hey girl! we made it back to Chicago and possibly see You this Fall! ) ... pizza was TO DIE FOR!!! We got the FUN-GUY and wow wow wow, great job guys😍 we'll be back!“

“There are several Italian restaurants in Door County. And yet, once again, there I was...in the land of whitefish and walleye. Eating pasta from my very favorite place to eat pasta. I swear these people have an Italian chef being held hostage in a cooler full of perch....Creating absolutely insane pasta dishes. Like the current special which involves Green goddess sauce with pistachio and I'm pretty sure... fairy dust. Oh, and have I mentioned the cocktail creations? My latest was made with gin infused with baobob. (Oh ... and the seafood is awesome too)“

“Love the food, the environment and Alex and Nick made our visit so much fun!! We came back 3 times in our 4 day stay!!“

“food, atmosphere, staff are all incredible“

“Sunday night dinner in the Sister Bay area- we are new to the area, so went to the closest restaurant we could find. Atmosphere is a typical north woods vibe (large bar area, dark wood), but the food is a mix of American/Italian.
Companion had the spaghetti pomodoro, which came with soup or salad- the Caesar salad was very good, with homemade garlic croutons. The pasta was confusing as it contained sausage- something usually not found in pomodoro. She ate it anyway as she didnt want to make a fuss. Said it was good despite the protein.
I ordered a gluten free GOAT pizza. Dried cherries, chevre, bacon, topped with arugula and a balsamic drizzle. Not bad, but needed a little something. It could have been because GF crust isnt as flavorful as regular.
Both ordered the NA cherry fizz- delightfully flavored with tart cherry juice(when in Door county...).
Ended the meal by sharing the Gluten Free chocolate torte- delicious!
Bill came and although pricey for some pasta, pizza and no alcohol, on par for the touristy DC area.“

“Sara who answered the phone to take our reservation was so friendly, helpful and so sweet! We ate inside and it was so good. We had the salmon and steak and both were amazing! The bread was so good as well as the side salad. It was our 1st time trying LURE and it was 10/10 and we will be back!! Can’t wait to try everything on the menu as it looked top notch… keep doing an amazing job LURE! Even with it being such a busy weekend- service was quick and top notch!!“

“We were looking for a place to eat on a Tuesday evening and we picked an excellent place, Sister Bay Bowl! Our entire crew loved everything we ordered! There were a variety of kids menu options, the blackened salmon was mouth-watering good, ribeyes were cooked and seasoned to perfection, and the Tuesday night Perch was plentiful and delicious! Excellent service and amazing meal mean we will be back on our next DC visit.“

“The food was wonderful. You get plenty of food for the price that's for sure. Our waitress was Debbie and she is so wonderful. We will definitely be coming back and definitely be asking for Debbie.“

“Yummy food! Cool atmosphere. No wait on a Friday at 6pm! Small menu and NO SUBSTITUTIONS! They don’t have ketchup. But it’s their thing! The food is fast and yummy and a relaxed atmosphere for kids. I’d come again, but hard with food allergies! The burger was delicious! My kids liked the grilled cheese.“

“Honestly, this place was better than my initial thoughts. Food was amazing. I got the cheese curd flight and their (I think) sesame blackened salmon. It was well prepared and it's presentation was amazing. The others in my group fortitude different dishes and the general consensus was that it was all great. When we got there we didn't have any reservations. At first it sounded like they only took reservations but then they told us we could sit outside. We thought that would have been the preferred seating over being inside. The wait staff was cheerful and bubbly. She was chatty abs eager to help with whatever we needed. The price for the food, I can say it was well worth it. For four people, I think our bill was $175. A bit pricey for me but glad I went. Will definitely stop again if I'm in the area.“

“There’s something special about this place. ❤️ our family has enjoyed this lodge for the past 10 years, including the most magical day- our wedding day. 9.28.19 We try to return at least really with our 3 kids, so they can share in the memories of our little piece of heaven. 🫶🏻“

“What a great little break on our drive up and TK was an amazing host 😀“

“My boyfriend and I went there for dinner. He had the meatloaf and I had the chicken and broccoli Alfredo. Both VERY delicious 😋. Will definitely be back. Highly recommend“

“We tried the bone marrow and tuna appetizers. We moved on to crab cakes with lemon aioli and ribeye for our dinners. Thank you to the staff, chef and bartender (I wish we had asked his name). We had a wonderful, peaceful meal here to celebrate our anniversary. The bartender introduced my husband to a new Bourbon and even gave us spot on advice on where to purchase a bottle. Top shelf liquor options galore! The food was amazing! 5 stars and we will visit again!“

“Had amazing pizza today at Chives Food Trucks! So great watching them make the pizza in a real wood fired oven. Fresh dough and great toppings. The mushroom, sun dried tomato, truffle, arugula pizza was wonderful. I really really hope that we get to stop by for another lunch tomorrow and here is why. They have the biggest Big Green Egg that I have ever seen. Today the bar b q master was smoking a huge beef roast which will be ready for his famous sandwiches tomorrow!!! I can hardly wait. This quy was so friendly and welcoming! My kind of place🤗👍💕“

“We love the White Gull Inn! The restaurant has been one of our favorite places for 50+ years! We’ve also enjoyed staying there.“

“This golf course is a gem, and not just for golfers! Their pub serves some of the best food in the area, and the cod fish fry is hands-down the BEST in Door County. The service is always friendly and attentive, and Kevin, the owner, truly cares about providing a great experience to his guests - it’s evident by the constant upgrades he’s making to the pub and grounds. It’s the kind of place you want to tell everyone about… but also secretly keep to yourself. A true best-kept secret in the area!“

“Amazing dinner amazing atmosphere great service. Great people recommend anybody who comes into town.“

“Visited from out of town this weekend and were so glad we stopped! The food was delicious. We loved the onion rings. The bartenders were attentive and friendly. Very cool’s place!“

“The quote “small but mighty” suits PC Junction. It was such an adorable place, my 2 year old grandson absolutely loved this yummy diner. The train delivery for the food…genius! He ate the best while being entertained by watching the train and never knowing what characters were going to be riding next. The burgers were so good and lots of flavor. The Bloody Mary…delish! The outside play area…so fun, the adults enjoyed the peddle cars more than the kids!! Can’t forget to mention the resident pig, so sweet and loves belly rubs.“

“We were on the trolley and stop here for lunch. Service was outstanding and food was excellent! I even got a bandage for my thumb! Thx again!“

“Excellent food. We loved the French Onion Soup, Ribeye, Fries and the incredible desserts. Most of all, we loved Carlton. He took great care of us and made it fun. Megan was super helpful as well. Great experience.“

“This place was so amazing!! My husband and I stopped Wednesday night for a drink. The best old fashioned I’ve had. It was so good I had to go back for another. We were staying a few doors down and decided to eat here on our last night in town last night. I ordered the shrimp pasta and my husband got the steak. Both of ours meals were amazing!! We also got the crab Rangoon dip and wow!!! 🤩 10/10. Can’t forget the best dessert ever. We got the creme brûlée mango 🥭 flavor and that was amazing!! The staff is the best! We had a great time chatting with everyone. Everyone was so friendly and welcoming! We definitely plan to return when we get back that way!“

“Great atmosphere and good food! Would definitely recommend!!“