22 Best American Restaurants in Sturgeon Bay

“Lov Valmy Excellent food great service Friday nite is first come. Especially if your a local Otherwise we waited Not bad but obviously such“

“Great up scale dinner restaurant. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Old school flavor to the dining room. Beautiful lake views. Stunning. Not inexpensive, it's a steak and seafood house. Wonderful meal. I had the house special tenderloin and my wife had the pan fried walleye. Excellent.“

“The cherry pie is the best in Door County!“

“Delicious food, helpful staff, and beautiful ambiance!“

“Homey atmosphere with friendly personnel! AND our very favorite breakfast restaurant in all of Sturgeon Bay. ❤️“

“I love Sunrise Food & Drinks! It needs a sign that says Mexican Food though! "Sunrise" doesn't get that across. Their Mexican food is incredible. Everything is great, but wow, what a treat to get a super Mexican breakfast in Sturgeon Bay.💛“

“Phenomenal lunch . Quality and taste outstanding- will definitely be back!“

“Admittedly our #1 spot for lunch in Sturgeon Bay was already closed, so we decided to try Kitty O'Reilly's for our late lunch during the Packers game yesterday. We all enjoyed the food, service, and reasonable prices. We plan to come back next time we're in Door County.“

“What an incredible dive bar! The bartender Brad was so friendly and welcoming! A definite must stop ❤️“

“Everything from the food to the rum to the service is top notch.“

“Prime rib was phenomenal!“

“If you’re heading up to Door County and pass the Culver's, just know this: it’s basically the last civilized outpost before you enter the land of fish boils and charmingly limited WiFi. 🧀🌲
We told ourselves we didn’t need to stop. We were wrong.
The butter burgers? Flawless. The cheese curds? Crispy little gifts from Wisconsin heaven. The concrete mixer? So thick it could patch potholes on Highway 42. And somehow the staff is always cheerful, efficient, and moving like they’re training for the Dairy Olympics.
It’s the perfect “one last taste of chain food” before you fully commit to supper clubs and cherry everything. Honestly, it’s not just a stop — it’s a strategic refueling station. 10/10, would absolutely plan my bladder schedule around it again. 🚗🍦“

“It's one of our favorite places to eat!“

“Overall I really like the place. It's a sports bar so don't expect high-end cuisine. It's all good but not like eating at a top-notch restaurant. I always get good service and the food is very good“

“The picture of our food says it all!! We came up from Appleton just to come to this place !!“

“ordered last night and picked up to go. I had the local fire fighter, turkey sandwich. Delicious. I also recommend their Cobb salads, best in town“

“I took myself a little me vacation and stayed here for two nights I'm very simple person and it was awesome stay I enjoyed myself very much enjoyed some good food at the bar and enjoyed going to Potawatomi state park for hiking the weather was beautiful and I was able to sit on the lawn chairs by the water thank you so much and I will see you in July“

“The whole dinner was wonderful! would highly recommend.“

“Excellent food and service for our group on a busy Sat., Oct 25th-2025. We had 2 long tables and our server did a great job, food was delicious. Thank you Cory! Your server needs a thank you!!“

“Excellent dinner, loved my strawberry margaritas, beautiful view of the boats and harbor. Will be returning in the future.“

“We stopped here on Saturday after spending the day in the upper peninsula with our family. The staff was extremely friendly, and the food was phenomenal!!!! The burgers were the best ever!!!! This will be our new destination stop for food when we visit Door county!!!“

“burgers and drinks are awesome. great service“