29 Best American Restaurants near Fish Creek

“We had our wedding reception at Barringer’s Restaurant and couldn’t have better, more positive things to say. We planned our entire wedding from Arizona, and Hannah from Barringers was an absolute dream to work with. Hannah went above and beyond in assisting with nearly every aspect of planning. Aside from the absolutely gorgeous setting throughout the restaurant, the bar was really fantastic and our guests were incredibly complimentary. The food was also an absolute star of the show. Not only were the menu options incredible, but the food itself was absolutely delicious. Hats off to the chef! Everyone who attended our reception raved about their meal, and left full and totally satisfied. Thank you to Barringers, Hannah and the rest of the staff for making our wedding day perfect!! We HIGHLY HIGHLY recommend!!“

“Our last stop in Door County was here. We took over 3 booths and ordered their famous hamburger. Plenty to eat and messy good.

Since some of our group had not had an Old Fashioned we ordered.

Delightful staff, and loved there attitude of let us be us.

Fun place.“

“Best fish fry in Wisconson is totally agreed upon! I've also had the Prime Rib (King Cut) and it was amazing! Most tender piece of meet I've ever had! Loved that it came with a salad and a choice of side and not ala carte! Must stop here if visting the county! Very historical and rare place!“

“The people are all kind, helpful, friendly, and polite.

Our room combined the old-fashioned style (like antique furniture) that we love with all modern comforts, which we also love. Everything, plumbing, lights, fixtures, furniture, worked and was very clean.

The restaurant has some of the best food I've had. Quick service, too. And our wait person shared some local sightseeing knowledge.

Location was great, centrally located within 10 or 15 minutes of everything.“

“Best Fish boil! Enjoy it every year“

“We were on the trolley and stop here for lunch. Service was outstanding and food was excellent! I even got a bandage for my thumb! Thx again!“

“Great sandwiches, love the outdoor seating!“

“I've been there a few times, everything has been wonderful. Turkey sandwich was delicious, and the "adult" grilled cheese was amazing. I was a bit skeptical about the fig jam, but wow, it was great. Also, the music playlist that is in the background just happened to hit one favorite after another. Go there. Everyone's super welcoming and the service is efficient but not hovering.“

“My family ate lunch here while on vacation in Door County, and we really enjoyed our meal! My father-in-law loved his blackened fish tacos, and I really enjoyed the summer wrap with turkey, cranberries, walnuts, blue cheese and raspberry vinaigrette! Debbie was an excellent server and met all of our needs. We will definitely be back!“

“The service and food were AMAZING!! The chef accommodated our food allergies. Everything was delicious! I strongly recommend The Fireside Restaurant. We will be back!!!“

“excellent food recommend 5 star“

“Stopped for a drink. I had a grasshopper and my husband had an old fashioned. Both were very good. We will come back and try their food another time.“

“We are visiting here from Indiana and googled local restaurants. We tried Burtons because of the great reviews and agree with them.
We sat outside with beautiful views of the lake. I ordered the fish tacos. They were fantastic loaded with great fish. I even took some of the fish out of the shells and ate it by itself it was so good. My husband ordered the steak bites. They were seasoned perfectly with great sauces . One bite had grizzle in it but the rest were perfect. We plan on trying to go again before we leave this area next week.“

“The owner, Kevin, was more than accommodating to the nine in our party. Service was great and the Friday Fish Fry was delicious! Can’t wait to try the filet, new to their Saturday menu! I hear the burger is great, too! 😊“

“Family friendly place! The spicy white fish wrap was honestly the best fish wrap I’ve ever had 💯👏 great customer service. Friendly atmosphere“

“Warm and friendly atmosphere. The staff was always there to help you feel comfortable and enjoy your meal. The food was great. I would recommended to everyone.“

“Wild Tomato never disappoints! We usually visit in the off-season, but even in the busy season this place is amazing. Best. Pizza. Ever. �“

“Love the food, the environment and Alex and Nick made our visit so much fun!! We came back 3 times in our 4 day stay!!“

“food, atmosphere, staff are all incredible“

“Four years in a row! Always a great time with service, food and atmosphere“

“I just want to start by saying our waitress was SO great, helpful & friendly! I'm sad we didn't get her name to add to the review (visited 9/13/24 around 7pm). The food was delicious. Charcuterie board was tasty with the cherry chutney 👌 & the seafood Alfredo was 10/10 sooooo good“

“Excellent food. We loved the French Onion Soup, Ribeye, Fries and the incredible desserts. Most of all, we loved Carlton. He took great care of us and made it fun. Megan was super helpful as well. Great experience.“

“They were so nice and turned the back TV to Sunday Night Football for us. We’ve been coming up for many years and always try and hit the Northern Grill. One year we discovered all you can eat spaghetti night. They no longer do that but we still get the spaghetti. Prices have gone up and they have reduced their portion size and nights they are open. But we still recommend it.“

“Don't sleep on the Korean BBQ wings. Delicious!“

“My husband and I went here during our annual Door County trip and it was outstanding! Our server, Jennifer, and the vibes of this restaurant are spot on. Friendly, warm, and well decorated. Everything we got was quality! The lobster mac n’ cheese specifically was the best we’d ever tried and was so delicious. Can’t wait to return! ☺️“

“Sara who answered the phone to take our reservation was so friendly, helpful and so sweet! We ate inside and it was so good. We had the salmon and steak and both were amazing! The bread was so good as well as the side salad. It was our 1st time trying LURE and it was 10/10 and we will be back!! Can’t wait to try everything on the menu as it looked top notch… keep doing an amazing job LURE! Even with it being such a busy weekend- service was quick and top notch!!“

“Beautiful scenery from outdoor dining. Delicious food served by friendly people.“

“The best perch dinner we have ever had! We always said if we have a last supper it would definitely be at The Sister Bay Bowl!“

“The French onion burger is to die for! Delicious food & dessert. Our waitress Deondra was fantastic! We will definitely be back 😊“