New American Restaurants near Fish Creek, WI

“It was my birthday and Robin was our server.She was absolutely wonderful, as was the food.I love the old supper club feel of this place as well.The only thing that was not pleasant was the bernaise sauce. It was clumpy, cold and separating.It should have been taken off the menu until the “chef” learns to properly make a sauce.“

“Went there tonight for dinner with my husband. He had the perch dinner. I had the seafood chowder & whitefish sandwich. Let me tell you, that chowder was SOOOOO good!! I'm going to rave about this because I just loved the taste. The rest of our food was good too. Definitely would return when coming back to Door County.“

“Fantastic lattes, all the food was wonderful. We had a variety of dishes with our group and all were very good. Neat little place!Kid-friendliness: My only caution would be that if you're dining with kiddos, this may not be what they're looking for. Check the menu ahead of time, especially if you have a picky eater.“

“Absolutely thrilled with our experience at this fantastic restaurant! The atmosphere is unparalleled, and the architecture is simply amazing. Our visit, courtesy of a trolley tour, was a delightful surprise as we practically had the place to ourselves. The family-friendly vibe made it feel like a warm Thanksgiving gathering at Mom's. The bearded gentleman overseeing our experience went above and beyond to ensure everyone was happy, reminiscent of my uncle's genuine hospitality. The fish sandwich was a taste sensation—utterly delightful! Without a doubt, I highly recommend checking out this gem of a place.“

“Consistantly good pies, fun venue and good-natured staff. Beautiful views of the bay a great area to walk after taking in a meal. Right on the main strip in Door Co so it is usually a struggle to find a parking spot. Always enjoy our visit here and we will return!“

“Sara who answered the phone to take our reservation was so friendly, helpful and so sweet! We ate inside and it was so good. We had the salmon and steak and both were amazing! The bread was so good as well as the side salad. It was our 1st time trying LURE and it was 10/10 and we will be back!! Can’t wait to try everything on the menu as it looked top notch… keep doing an amazing job LURE! Even with it being such a busy weekend- service was quick and top notch!!“

“The food was absolutely wonderful except dessert. Fabulous tenderloin steak and chicken marsala. We would order these again and again. But, when your waiter says "the all too often overlooked dessert", there is likely a reason. We were served a very dry "Slice of Paradise Cake" which was Keylime Pie, Coconut Sponge Cake & Passion Fruit. Sounded wonderful until we were served a small slice so dry that the two of us couldn't finish it. Other than dessert, we were absolutely happy with our meals and would return.“

“Went for Comedy night dinner show. Wasn't sure what to expect. Buffet style meal - German theme with good selection of authentic dishes. I particularly liked the pot roast with vegetables. Also had chicken, fish and sausage. Sides were just like grandma makes. There was plenty to eat. And, we did. Dessert was German Chocolate cake. The comedians did about a 90 minute show. It was interactive so the closer you sat to the stage then more fun you had. Lots of kibitzing and nothing off color. We had fun. Overall the food was fine. Nothing to rave about. Wished the dinner plates had been warmed. Good hot food on very cold plates didn't sit well with me. The show was mid range. No guy busting laughing but plenty of chuckles and a lot of self depreciation. We would do it again. Learned that they have other theme nights, so check that out before you go.“