7 Best Seafood Restaurants near Fort Atkinson

“Everything about North Shore was outstanding until we were just finishing our meal. We weren’t told there was a time limit on our table, which we had to vacate, only to finish our beverages standing, no seats available, in the bar. Very disappointing.“

“Our visit in May was to say the least disappointing. But Sean reached out to me to discuss the issues. He asked me to give them another chance. So we did last night. To say the least this visit was exceptional. Our server was outstanding, the food was hot and excellent, and even his Bad Dad jokes were good. All in all we had a great time and we will be back! Thankyou to Sean and his staff for a great experience! FIVE STARS!“

“Good was excellent! Priced very reasonably.“

“What a great restaurant! Saul was so efficient and attentive as a waiter. He took care of our table of 12 with ease. He was so kind and responsive to our requests. The food was awesome and we all had a great time. Nicolas, what a nice venue. Thank you!“

“I will be the first to admit I was pretty skeptical walking in to this place, having been to many sub par supper clubs in Wisconsin, I figured this could be a miss. Thankfully I was dead wrong! We had a large group in town for a bachelor party, and they were so accommodating to us. We had called to make a reservation with no issue, got seated and were served promptly and the food was fantastic. I kid you not they had one of the best Caesar salads I’ve had at a restaurant in a while. I had the broiled walleye which was cooked perfectly and the sauce it came with had great flavor. The rest of my group got various specials and steaks and everyone really enjoyed their meal. I finished off dinner with a slice of their homemade cheesecake and it was amazing. Such a fun night, if you’re in the area be sure to check out Edgwater Supper Club for a great meal and even greater time!“

“Very nice place. Attractive decor, very good food In my opinion. Lots of choices! Prices are reasonable as well. They were doing a brisk takeout business mostly Latinos, so a good indicator that the place is highly regarded by the locals. We sampled the birria and believe we were told one kind was beef, but yay, one was GOAT, the way it traditionally. Both were melt in the mouth and seasoned wonderfully.“

“The Lobster Boil is a must try! The staff, food, drinks, and experience was a 10/10!“