28 Best Seafood Restaurants near Middleton

“Hands down amazing. We’ve tried most of the menu and it’s all lived in my head rent-free!“

“Incredible customer service. I had an issue with my order and they refunded everything, including the delivery fees, without hesitation. It was more than I asked for, but it shows they really care about their customers. The Egg Drop soup is great!I’ll be a returning customer for sure!“

“I visited for my first time last night. Service was excellent, attentive but not overly so, and the food was on point. There are some great things happening in that kitchen—everything was delicious! Thanks for a memorable meal and a fabulous first impression!👏🏽“

“The service and food were excellent!! Highly recommend! If you haven't tried this Steak house, you definitely should.“

“We just finished eating at the Madison location, and our host/server Shawn was amazing! Probably the best host/server ever! He was friendly, efficient, and had the best personality with impeccable comedic timing. The food was also top notch, but Shawn really made it a fun experience.“

“Everything was phenomenal, my family and I were very pleased! We tried the catfish appetizers, as well as the cheesecurds and fried pickles….all delicious!! Brisket was absolutely delicious as well as the pulled pork! We will definitely be back when we’re in Madison! Our fave place now“

“Very good seafood boil! Very fresh and great service!!“

“Went with my family last night and it was a great experience. We shared the meatballs appetizer, a salad and a pizza. The salad was full of a large variety of vegetables. The food was delicious, prices were reasonable, and the service was excellent.“

“Terrific dinner tonight with work colleagues. Delicious dishes and great service.“

“Amazingly fresh seafood and beautifully done steaks with equally great side dishes, large enough to share! Go early and take advantage of their fabulous happy hour drinks and apps. Always a good time and a local favorite. Top notch service as well. Recommend for a night out, date night or special occasion.“

“So nice to get fish beyond what you can get in a grocery store. They also have a good freezer of various seafood blends if you like to make chowder like I do. I make New England style, Bahamian chowders, saffron stews... All of which benefit from fish and shellfish blends.“

“Great experience…everything from the ambiance to the waitstaff to the drinks, appetizers, entree, desserts and coffee were amazing!“

“Their sides are so tasty, even the most devoted carnivores might be caught sneaking a forkful.“

“My husband had the pork belly from Jap Chae menu. Tasty, but my order of chicken bulgogi was better. He did not have to cook his. I did - it would have been nice to have more instruction/suggestions as to how to prepare how to use the oils and sauces (I wished my daughter was with us.) The server shared information when asked but this was after the meal. I'd go back again and ask for lettuce leaves to make roll ups (something I saw another table had). But two bottles of Soon Hari (plum jinjo) was very good!!“

“Best Poke in Madison - I keep trying others but none compare. Highly recommend the Hawaii green bowl.“

“Had an amazing night out at Johnnys. Our waiter Ryan was attentive, kind and so accommodating. He truly made our dinner experience the best. Great recommendations and super friendly. Johnnys is lucky to have him for sure! Delicious food and great cocktails. Will be back soon!“

“God was absolutely amazing! We will definitely be back!“

“We had heard some mixed reviews but dinner last night was perfect! The food was all done exceptionally well and service was fantastic. First time and had a great time. Looking forward to coming back and trying some new things! Salmon and broccolini tasted perfect and my dining partner enjoyed their steak and mashed potatoes. Thank you for the wonderful meal and the servers for being so lovely.“

“the beauty of the lake and the warm air. the food is amazing. never had a meal I didn't love. the service is wonderful and friendly. must try the sangria!“

“I’ve always loved Muramoto! Can’t go wrong for fantastic sushi!“

“Tried this spot for the first time today—so good! Every dish our fam ordered was packed with flavor, super affordable, and the service was awesome. We’ll definitely be coming back!“

“Food and service were excellent. Beautiful decor.“

“​⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A spectacular experience that feeds both the soul and the palate
​We went to dinner as a family—two adults and two children—and the experience at Nani Restaurant exceeded all expectations. We went in just thinking we’d have a good meal, but our waiter's service completely elevated the evening: he reflected a genuine love for his work and transmitted a peace that truly brightened the place.
​We ordered the duck, and we absolutely loved it. It came with scallions, cucumber, perfectly seasoned shredded meat, and golden, crispy duck. Even though I am not a fan of bread, the buns that accompanied this dish delighted me; they have a different texture and a very special flavor. With this dish and two sides of rice, it was more than enough for the four of us. The atmosphere is incredibly quiet and relaxing. We paid approximately $83 (including the tip, which we gave with absolute pleasure). I highly recommend it!“

“Fabulous place, omg the view of the capital is amazing“

“For starters, we were treated to an excellent show comprised of two of the best bluesmen in the Midwest, Westside Andy & Glenn Davis. The food was amazing and service was prompt and courteous. I’ve been a restauranteur for over 40 years. Otto’s knocked it out of the park. We will most definitely be returning.“

“The prime rib was as good as you get to night. It was a real high quality piece of beef cooked to perfection. I'll be back.“

“Wonderful experience from start to finish. Every detail attended to. Dinner (prime) was delish. The goulash soup was superb. Not rundown at ALL as in previous reviews. Our waitress was phenomenal serving 15 of us. Bar staff very attentive to customers at bar. I highly recommend!! Worth the drive from Milwaukee!! Thank you!!“