18 Best Bakeries near Genesee Depot

“These cookies not only look amazing, but they taste just as good. We tried these for the first time this week and we were thoroughly impressed. Highly recommend these.“

“We have ordered custom cookies and cupcakes a handful of times from Sally’s, and not only are they DELICIOUS, the staff is great at communicating and so friendly!! Highly recommend!!!!“

“Not busy at all on Labor Day. Staff was patient to listen to our needs, asked questions, and recommend a purchase option.

$5.00 a cookie seems a bit high but the taste was exquisite and satisfied the receivers! Appreciate the help!“

“We ordered cheese cakes for our wedding from mama ducky. Melissa was awesome start to finish! She took time to talk with me with out an appointment.(I had been to 3 other bakeries and no one would even answer any questions I had with out a appointment) We like red velvet and Melissa made little trials of each red velet option for us to try. She was always prompt to respond to any messages we sent. The day of She delivered to the venue right on time. She truly cares about her customers. We would highly recommend her and mama ducky!“

“Wonderful fresh homemade gluten free goodies! The breakfast sandwiches and pizzas are so good!“

“My wedding cake was amazing! So pretty and very yummy. My guests couldn’t stop talking about it. There was barely any left by the end of the night. And so happy we saved the rest of our top tier for our anniversary next year. Thanks Aly!“

“Brought these into the office for my co-workers because they are the most delicious cinnamon buns I have ever had. They were gone in seconds. I cannot say enough wonderful things about this bakery, I recommend it to everyone!“

“Very nice place with great people and excellent food and bakery! We will definitely be going there many times in the future.“

“Me encantan desde años mis favoritos“

“I have been to Beach Bum Bakery a few times now, and everything I get there has been superb. The baked goods are of spectacular quality and the staff there is always very nice and welcoming. Every time I stop by, they have something new to try. They have been a great addition to our village.“

“I called with a bit of a special request at the last minute. The cheesecake turned out to be awesome and I will definitely be returning with my next request.“

“Been to Rochester Deli many times over the years, mostly for their fish fries. This visit was specifically for bakery items, and that is when I learned that I have apparently been enjoying Periwinkle desserts all along. Their production facility is next door, but the baked goods are sold through Rochester Deli. I also learned that the deli owner’s daughter runs the bakery.

I came in hoping to pick up a few cupcakes and possibly a small round cake. There was only one cupcake option available, a Boston Cream, which did look good. Unfortunately, there were no cakes available, so I struck out there. I did grab a couple of the peanut butter cookies half dipped in chocolate, which are always a hit at my house.

The staff member who helped me apologized for the limited selection, but there was not much they could do.

Overall, I really enjoy their cookies, bars, and cake slices, and I will definitely be back for some of their regular items.“

“We got all our buns for my sons graduation party they did a great job!!! We had burgers and brats. They said they've never done brat buns but willing to try. They were great. hot out of the oven literally. Thanks Again!!!!“

“Highly recommend. Excellent experience. The atmosphere and staff were very welcoming and friendly. Thank you for the coffee(s) and meeting space. See you soon!“

“The food is always so fresh and hot when it comes out, the service is always amazing, even when it’s busy. Their bakery is to die for and it’s such a cute vibe in this place!!!!

I’ve tried the chicken parm panini and dans pulled pork panini and they are both absolutely amazing. The chicken dumpling soup is so flavorful.“

“Just ok. Probably not worth a second trip. Chaotic service. Breakfast sandwiches are not made on site. I woukd not recommend. Too many probably better choices in the area.“

“An Ocon hidden gem! Fantastic coffee and friendly service in an adorable shop.“

“My wife and I don't get here often but we do love the pies and other bakery that we purchase. Unfortunately we stopped Saturday march 8th 2025 and bought a lemon poppy seed muffin and when we opened it the next day for breakfast it was dried out. this is the first and only time we were disappointed with something we bought. We ate it with a cup of hot coffee and the flavor was great. We will be back again and I'm sure what we purchase will be awesome!“