5 Best American Restaurants near Hatley

“Very impressed with the Friday fish fry. Our first visit but won’t be our last. Clean and busy place. Every employee was friendly. Our waitress (Zoe) is in the running for the best service we’ve had since before Covid. She was on point.It’s worth noting however that all the other servers were rocking it. Soup and Salad bar was above par.“

“Stopped in on our way to the Bull Falls HD. Not busy at all so was able to chat with the owner. Down to earth guy. Incredible food. I ordered the Wisco with fries, wife had the chicken sandwich with tots.This is the place to stop if your doing the HD dealership ride.“

“Tonight was our first time for dinner since this restaurant changed from Clubhouse to Prost Hill. We LOVED the food!The smoked wings were just as tasty & flavorful. Bravo! So glad our fave wing place is still offering the same great wings with new owners!!I had a Mushroom, Swiss & Onion Burger. Just WOW! It might have been the juiciest and best seasoned burger I have ever eaten!Cheers to Prost Hill Bar & Grill! We will return!“

“It was very warm in the bar and restaurant area. No A/C on. Drinks were reasonably priced. Food was good. Recommended by hotel staff to check out. They were able to accommodate a large group. It was slow but they did their best. Chatted with some locals so it was fine, other than being very warm inside.“

“I was here with a large group. Started off in the bar for drinks and "Oh What Fun!: It was mostly our group but several regulars were there and they were fun and engaging. This is a family owned business and they know how to deliver fun and food. They were busy, but made time to talk which always makes me feel welcome. They are known for their Wisconsin Old Fashions. I had a whiskey old fashion with sweet and sour (I'm complicated) and it was so good, had 2! For dinner we had the best fried chicken with light crispy skin (my fav), mashed potatoes, stuffing, gravy, the creamiest cole slaw, and dinner rolls.Will definitely make another stop that way, maybe to sub on their Monday night bowling team!“