Gotham Bagels
$ • Bagels, VeganAbout Gotham Bagels
Customers' Favorites
The Peruvian Chimichurri Chicken Salad Greens Avocado Onion
Everything Bagel with Vegetable Cream Cheese
Super Egg Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Super Everything Bagel
NY Delicatessen Salads
Cream Cheese Flavors
Bagel & Cream Cheese
The Brighton Beach
One Dozen Bagels
Gotham Bagels Reviews
382 ratings
Share your opinion about Gotham Bagels
We stopped today on our way out of town. The Owner and staff are awesome. Bagels - Perfection!
Best place to start your day.
The bagels are pure heaven, but the logistics are a head-scratcher!
As a New York-style bagel shop, a few things about Gotham Bagels in Madison really don't make sense. First, opening at 8:00 AM is way too late. Most traditional bagel stores open at 6:00 AM or earlier. By 8:00 AM, most people are already at work or finished with their morning commute.
On top of that, the coffee situation is frustrating. They only offer one size of coffee cup, so you can't upgrade to...read full review
As a New York-style bagel shop, a few things about Gotham Bagels in Madison really don't make sense. First, opening at 8:00 AM is way too late. Most traditional bagel stores open at 6:00 AM or earlier. By 8:00 AM, most people are already at work or finished with their morning commute.
On top of that, the coffee situation is frustrating. They only offer one size of coffee cup, so you can't upgrade to...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Wednesday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Thursday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Friday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 12PM |
Gotham Bagels is a well-known spot for delicious bagels and sandwiches, offering a fun atmosphere. They serve a variety of tasty items, including pasta and chips. Although there may be long wait times, especially on weekends or busy days, the staff manages them efficiently. Prices can be on the higher side, with bagels starting at over $5 with cream cheese. However, many customers believe that the quality justifies the wait and expense. Signature items like the lox bagel and the Williamsburg Hot, which features hot pastrami and stoneground mustard on an Everything bagel, are highly recommended. The bagels are fresh and large, making them better than what many expect from local options. Guests appreciate the homemade toppings and the friendly staff. While the location may pose some challenges for parking, the overall experience is enhanced by the buzzing atmosphere and the fact that everything is made fresh daily. Don't forget to grab a chocolate rugelach for a sweet treat.