Gotham Bagels
$ •
Hours:
112 E Mifflin St, Madison
(608) 467-7642
Customers' Favorites
Gotham Bagels Reviews
I stopped at Gotham Bagels right when they opened on a Saturday morning. The line was short, but there were definitely people there who had already ordered. I think we waiting maybe 15-20 mins for our bagels. Well worth the wait! I got a bacon, egg, and cheese on a Everything bagel. This was so good! These bagels were perfect - soft to bite into and very fresh. The chocolate rugelach was out of this world delicious, I wished I would have grabbed 2 bags! I can't wait to go back...read full review
Good bagels in Madison. The bagel sandwiches are a bit pricey for the amount of toppings, but they are pretty good quality and fresh. They have lots of cream cheese flavor options. They recently reopened the dining room so you can eat in the restaurant again.
Ratings
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Wednesday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Thursday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Friday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Saturday | 8AM - 2PM |
| Sunday | 8AM - 12PM |
If you're looking for mediocre bagels for high prices, this is your place. Over $5 for just a bagel with cream cheese, I have never seen bagel prices like these. If you're craving a bagel, sure go here, probably best bagels in Madison but very, very expensive for what it is. Also took over 45 minutes for us to pick up our orders. Three stars for food, two (maybe even one) stars for pick-up.