The Old Fashioned
23 N Pinckney St #1, Madison
(608) 310-4545
Customers' Favorites
Wisconsin Beer Cheese Soup
Dine in: Yes
Outdoor seating: No
Wisconsin Fried Cheese Curds with Ranch Dressing
Classic Tavern Summer Sausage Sandwich
Hickory Smoked Bacon Mac & Cheese
The Old Fashioned House Burger
Wednesday - Perch Fish Fry
Door County Cherry Salad
Wisconsin Grilled Cheese
Kids Macaroni and Cheese
Fish and Chips Walleye
Menu
Photos
+94 photos
+93 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The Old Fashioned is a true Madison staple. The food and service are consistently reliable, and it’s one of the best places to experience classic Midwestern comfort food. The cheese curds are some of the best in town—crispy, melty, and always satisfying. Portion sizes are generous, making it a great spot whether you're sharing with friends or looking for a hearty solo meal. It’s the kind of place that feels familiar, even on your first visit.
Nice place in a great location with perfect, friendly staff. They were very helpful when we ordered. I had an amazing Old Fashioned, and honestly, I think I got the best onion rings of my life here!
It’s a must-try spot if you visit Madison. I highly recommend it!
It’s a must-try spot if you visit Madison. I highly recommend it!
I've been here twice now and will always make a stop when coming through Madison! The service from everyone we met was outstanding, the food and drinks were delicious and reasonably priced. I'm in love with the cheese curds, Reuben, and Patty melt! The only thing I'll be skipping is the beer cheese soup, both times the texture has been off for some reason. Overall, highly recommend this place!
You May Also Like
Sol's on the Square - 117 E Mifflin St
![]()
Korean, Vegan, Vegetarian
Gotham Bagels - 112 E Mifflin St
![]()
Bagels, Vegan
Heritage Tavern - 131 E Mifflin St
![]()
New American, American, Gastropubs, Vegan, Vegetarian