16 Best Italian Restaurants near Menasha

“Placed an online order on a Friday night around 5pm for a 7:30pm delivery.Order arrived at 7:26pm and was so hot and fresh!!Mozzarella sticks were crispy on the outside and stringy/gooey on the inside. The custom made cheesesteak sandwich was perfection!!The online ordering was so easy...the delivery driver was great!..I've ordered from here a few times now since moving to Neenah and it's been nothing but excellence so far!!Keep up the great work guys!!“

“Looking for a spot to hang out and have some good beer? This place is it! They have their own brew and other great picks on tap. No liquor but they do have wine. They also have really good homage pizza made in a stone fire oven! Their patio is also a nice place to chill and enjoy beer or glass of wine.“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐Carmella’s is a gem for amazing Italian food! The friendly staff adds a warm touch to the dining experience. I accidentally left my sunglasses, and the owner went above and beyond by offering to mail them to me in Minnesota. Don't miss out on their incredible bread, butter, and olive oil- a must-try!“

“Very clean service was amazing very impressed since it’s a fast food place. Worker was very nice asked if we wanted more breadsticks came and checked on us multiple times. Food was very good for how quick it came would recommend. Best place to stop for super quick food.“

“My family and I had dinner here tonight and the food and service were top notch! Our pizza and breadsticks were amazing, and the staff went above and beyond to keep our kids entertained so mom and dad could enjoy dinner. Our kids picked a special movie and sat at a special table by themselves, so my husband and I were able to have adult conversation and enjoy our dinner. At the end of dinner, we were shocked by how reasonable our bill was. We had an XL pizza, an order of breadsticks and a beer for just under $25 (and we have lots of leftovers to bring home).Cheers to Luigi’s!!“

“Always a solid choice for Italian food. Pizza is always great if you're looking for something more casual, but the entrees and untouchables are fantastic for a more upscale experience. The only complaint I have is that sometimes it gets a little chilly at the tables near the main entrance during the winter. Just order an extra glass of red wine to warm up“

“Best pizza in town. Also many other tasty options. oh and don't forget to try their yummy desserts. 0Vegetarian options: I dont eat meat and find tons of options to eat. Cheese pizzas to veggie pizza. Salads, pastas, bread sticks, and many other yummy choices.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust, meatless optionsParking: Plenty of spots to parkKid-friendliness: Yes, All ages can enjoy.Wheelchair accessibility: Entire building wheelchairs accessible“

“Great place! I went there about 10 yrs ago and wasn't impressed but tonight was really good. Atmosphere was good and had remodeled since I've been there. I had an old fashioned and the T-bone and they were both fantastic! I didn't like the baby reds were deep fried and crispy, other than that I'd definitely go back.“

“Great Italian comfort food with friendly and hard working staff, very fast service with filling meals for good prices, with a decent amount of vegetarian selections (3-4).Our excellent server was named DenzelVegetarian options: Salad, fettuccini Alfredo, pasta“

“Stuc's Neenah is our family's favorite local pizza spot! Always delicious and always consistent high quality! Amazing beer selection as well!Vegetarian options: Meat-free pizzas and calzones are still super flavorful with fresh ingredients!Dietary restrictions: Noticed a gluten free option on the menu (not sure specifics)Kid-friendliness: Kids are perfectly welcome here and there's a pinball machine to play!“

“We had Noah as a server tonight and he was absolutely wonderful. We haven’t had a server anywhere in a long time that actually seemed like they care and want to be here. He was truly phenomenal. We couldn’t have had a better experience.“

“Cool old school pizza place. Bone in wings were pretty good - I believe they’re breaded though as an FYI to anyone who might be gluten intolerant. They do have GF crust and to go pizzas which is nice. Traditional pizza was good, but the sauce has a hint of sweetness which is not my preference. Crust is very good and all the ingredients are fresh.“

“I've stayed at this hotel twice but never visited the restaurant on-site. A late flight in and a busy day ahead left me with limited choices, and I decided to check it out.The waitress/bartender was super helpful in answering questions I had concerning items on the menu.I decided on the pretzel bites and teriyaki chicken wings. She brought the pretzel bites out first, and although the beer cheese was not the best I've had, it was good.At the moment, my wings were brought out. I was so excited I told my husband who was on the phone with me that I would call him back because my favorite dish had arrived.I pushed my pretzel bites to the side and immediately dug into my wings to be immediately disappointed. They were cold! I reached down to the lower portion of the basket and tried another one, but it was also cold.The taste of the wings were amazing, but I could not eat them cold, so I asked them to be sent back. By the time my waitress got back to me for me to send them back, her explanation was that I had let them sit too long before eating. Hold up! What did you just say? I cook wings at home, and my family has to wait at least 5 mins before eating to prevent burning their mouths! I literally tried to eat these as soon as they were set before me!She was kind and removed the charge from my ticket but politely let me know that they were hot when she brought them out because they were personally cooked by their manager. I declined to comment that managers make mistakes, too.All good things start from leadership. Perhaps they need to implement corrective actions based on their customer complaints. Here's your sign.“

“My husband and I went to Olive Garden for Valentine’s Day. It was very busy but the staff was amazing and did well under pressure. However, our usual food we order wasn’t right. It tasted like it had been sitting there awhile and it just didn’t taste right. But on the bright side, the GM Abi, spoke to us and gave us our food for free and was so accommodating and amazing! If she wouldn’t have came to spoke to us we probably wouldn’t ever come back but because abi handled the situation the correct way. She went above and beyond for us and that’s why she is the GM of this place. She is literally amazing!!“

“Still the absolute best thin crust pizza I've ever had. Between the one in Neenah and what used to be Frank and Pats in GB, I've been going here for more years than i care to admit to. It's really hard to maintain consistency over several decades, but they're as good today as they ever wereParking: If you come in on Cecil, it can look like there are only a few spots. Just turn the corner onto commercial and there is a big lot“

“Always the best Italian food.Family owned and operated.Great service.Amazing food. HUGE portions. The best leftovers you've ever had. Will drive your coworkers crazy!.Highly recommend the Mecchi's ChickenParking: Definitely worth a short stroll back to the car.“