29 Best Pizza Restaurants near Merton

“I have not been in here since it was OTR, I heard great things about the food so my family and I gave it a try tonight—I was super impressed with the food, the portions were large and delicious. Our waitress was extremely friendly and proficient and juggling waitressing and bartending.“

“best pizza ever! affordable delicious and fast delivery“

“Had the pizza delivered to an assisted living facility for a little family reunion. The family really enjoyed the pizza and made for an easy get together. The delivery was right on time and the delivery guy was very congenial. Thanks. Will do that again!“

“I took home a cheese , sausage , mushroom , and onion pizza , and was impressed with the quality of the cheese and the flavorful sausage , the fresh mushrooms , all abundantly portioned on a crisp crust . The sauce was tasty and also flavorful , I hate bland sauce . A very good pizza .“

“Pizza was better then most in the state, definitely a 8.1 one bite review, I personally stick with traditional pizza but we tried a BBQ chicken also, crust was very crunchy thin, great sauce, fresh veggies, all sides we tried were fresh and very good including mozzarella sticks and Reuben bites, will travel to go back definitely!!! Service was very fast and on point, people were very nice!!!“

“The pizza is our new favorite!!!! loved it!!!!“

“Came for my lunch break with some coworkers and ordered from their lunch menu (a slice and a drink). There was only one person working and I felt for him because he was trying his best to work on take out orders and cashiering by himself. It didn’t seem they had any pizzas ready for their pizza by the slice, which my coworkers and I found odd, so the slices took quite a while to finish as he had to make a whole pizza for us to have a slice. The bad news was that he quoted 15-20 minutes and it took over 30, but the good news is the pizza was fresh and extremely delicious. Slices were also huge, like a quarter of a good sized pizza, and had the perfect amount of grease (barely any, so the crust was not soggy AT ALL). The gentleman working gave us a 2 liter of soda for our patience, which was super kind and appreciated. Not really a sit-down unless you’re just waiting for pizza, though you can if you want as they have some tables in a well-decorated space!100% would recommend, as long as you call ahead and place an order so you don’t have to worry about wait time!“

“There are 2 young girls working today, standing in view of customers, eating breadsticks, drinking and using cell phones. When a customer walks up to the counter, they are giving them food, plates, silverware, with unclean hands. I don't see this kind of thing going on when the manager is here.“

“A great local spot for great food served by friendly staff. The Asiago Cheese dip appetizer, Lasagna & Miss Piggy pizza & Walleye Fish Fry are favorites. Friendly bar with a good variety of specialty beers on tap. Tom Basil Collin’s is a great go to in all the seasons. Soft serve custard is delicious. Specials every day. There’s outdoor seating when the weather allows, plenty of free parking

Kid-friendliness: A great place for families of all ages.“

“Had the Haystack onions and an individual pizza. Very good as always. My favorite place to go for pizza around here.“

“Everything was wonderful! We had the French Dip and cucumber salad. The cucumber salad was so good we wanted to buy some to take home. My husband went in and came out with--CHOCOLATE CAKE. That's my guy! :)“

“Amazing food! Wonderful staff! Best saxophone player ever is a cook.“

“The food is AMAZING. Extremely cool atmosphear especially after their remodel/addition they just did. The real fireplace is a nice touch. I recommend the pizza and garlic bread but have had their steaks and sandwichs too and have been very happy with them.“

“First visit to Noah’s and very impressed with the pizza. Recommended to by a friend for the pizza and it did not disappoint!We took our pizza to go, so by the time we got home the box was a bit greasy from the cut pizza, but easily remedied by putting it on a pan. Impressed that the pizza was still warm after the 10 minute drive.We had sausage and pepperoni, 16-inch, traditional crust ($21.00) along with an appetizer of chicken tenders (6 for $7.99–dipped in their Caesar dressing. Yum!).The pizza sauce is there and noticeable but compliments the toppings—not to sweet and not to acidic. The meat toppings came next and a generous helping of mozzarella covered it all. The pizza was in the oven long enough to get a little color on the cheese (good cheese pull) and the bottom of the crust was nicely marbled brown and not flimsy at all.Will definitely return for more pizza, and, the menu is huge with Mexican, pasta, soup, sandwiches, salad, and catering offerings , too. Will have to try more foods here at a later time.“

“Bought 4 separate types of pizzas for my son's 14th birthday party and every pizza was a hit. Teenagers liked the original pan the best, I liked the Detroit style the best, and my wife said her gluten free pizza was very good as well (one of only two gluten free pizzas she likes). Also, I called to seek help with my online order regarding the gluten free pizza and received unusually good service over the phone.“

“I have been to multiple locations and this one sticks out to me. The staff is always conversational asking about your day. They always treat my take out order with genuine care. Not to mention the quality of the food is great. Definitely recommend this location.“

“the best Italian food I ever had, and I'm from the Racine area where we were raised on Italian food, but not like Tony's, his is the best, I like how he guarantees his pizzas, there's been plenty of DeRango pizzas I wish I could of sent back, worth the trip to Sussex“

“Talked to a Rose there, VERY nice and helpful. Would definitely go again!“

“I am from Chicago and I ordered here to pick up lunch for a customer in the area. Even though being from Illinois and knowing pizza very well, this place is awesome. I would highly recommend. It was delicious. We ordered 3 thin crust pizzas and they were all very good.“

“Very few things in life are consistent, but the food from Papa Murphy's is one of them.The people working here are hard working and polite, and I've never had to worry about a bad order or mistakes. Order, pick up, enjoy.Great work, guys.“

“Park Avenue Pizza truly is the best pizza in Pewaukee! A great family run business with great food and staff. If you're looking for a cool place to take the family, meet up with friends, or a cozy spot to relax this is it. I recommend this place for dine-in, carryout, or delivery! Fabulous pizzas, made to order chicken, pastas, and apps! Come try what you've been missing!

Wheelchair accessibility: Wheelchair accessible restaurant and bathrooms“

“I came in for lunch with a co-worker. We were seated right away, and everything was great. It's a nice cozy small place that is perfectly suited for casual dining. Our server was excellent and pleasant, and the food was promptly made. I would recommend Spring City for nice comfort food. One thing to note is that they have a very extensive menu, which is always a plus! It is also an affordable place.“

“First time visiting. Old supper club atmosphere. Family friendly place. Our server suggested the garlic bread (seems to be a famous staple in this place). It was on the bland and greasy side for my taste, but maybe a good thing for your blood pressure. Mozzarella sticks were great. Ordered two small pizzas. The cheese pizza had a funny taste (we asked for extra cheese but I assume it was more mozzarella than other kind of cheese), maybe eggplant or other food. It was notorious enough my kid did not devour it as usual. Canadian bacon and pineapple was fine (don’t judge me). Marinara was fine. The site could do better (I’m spoiled by eating at Balistrieri’s on 68th Street in Milwaukee).“

“Love the fish fry, chicken isn't what I remember growing up in Milwaukee but that's okay. Excellent service always freindly and quick. Oh the Mac n cheese is AWESOME!

Parking: It's a strip mall and always full

Wheelchair accessibility: It's a strip mall all on the first floor“

“This is by far the "BEST DAMN PIZZA" in Waukesha County. The pizza is LOADED with Oooi gooie fresh cheeses, lots of meat & veggies, flavorful thick sauce but that crust ..Oh Yum Yum.... it's to die for!! I haven't had a chance to visit MARCO'S PIZZA restaurant inside so I haven't rated the atmosphere. We always have our pizza delivered and it's piping hot, arriving ahead of schedule with a smile! ? Can't beat that.?????“

“This is a nice local bar in Pewaukee. ***In all fairness, my food rating is based on a frozen pizza cooked after the grill was closed. It was available and ok. If it were about ten pm and I wanted a bar pizza, I would order this again.That being said, the server was attentive and very nice. I ordered a Bloody Mary hot. It was reasonably priced and came with a nice amount of fixings. I also received a decent amount for a beer chaser.I was meeting a friend briefly as she drove through town, so we didn't explore the many things available at the bar.They had pool tables and other machines there. ( I wasn't looking too closely, I'm sorry.)I will probably plan another late meeting with my friend as she finishes her classes at WCTC.

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes, they have a wheelchair ramp. I did not use the facilities.“

“Disregard any reviews about mask mandates..how can you eat a pizza with a mask on?... anyway..this is a review of decadence...the MONSTER is just that..the absolute pinnacle of pizza...have never been disappointed...good people equals good pizza....“

“Excellent food- we really enjoyed the smoked wings. Friendly service. It was our first time but I look forward to going back to try one of those great looking pizzas!“

“Awesome wings! Very nice biker hideout, with great food!“