Benny's Pizza

$$ • Pizza

1102 W Lincoln Ave, Milwaukee
(414) 384-5500


Take-Out/Delivery Options

Reviews for Benny's Pizza

Wow this pizza is amazing! We got the large thinking it was like most places where you need 3 or 4 pieces to get full but only needed 2 pieces because it was made so well. Thick crust but not too think cooked perfectly. We got sausage pepperoni bacon and ground beef and my goodness they pile on the toppings and a whole lot of cheese!!! New favorite place for sure!!! Great job

Really good food, but ironically the pizza is meh. Fantastic sandwiches and really reasonable prices. The dining area isn't much in the way of atmosphere and the neighborhood is a little sketchy. Still worth the trip for the grilled chicken sandwich or Italian beef sandwiche.

Done eating here for good. My family and I got really sick after eating here once. Decided to give them one more chance and was told they didn't deliver to my address. They had delivered once before and the "manager" tried telling me he's worked there for a whole 3 years. Well, you just lost over 8 years of business. I've been ordering from this place since I moved back to Milwaukee from Chicago. You guys don't have anything on the original Benny's in Pilsen.

More Reviews(56)


Monday 10AM - 12AM
Tuesday 10AM - 12AM
Wednesday 10AM - 12AM
Thursday 10AM - 12AM
Friday 10AM - 12AM
Saturday 10AM - 12AM
Sunday 10AM - 12AM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.