New American Restaurants near Mukwonago, WI

“Shanahan's is the place to go. Way better than Brew52 - a chill spot to read, do work, or be with friends. Seasonal drinks are always the bomb (but their regular menu is a great go-to). Love love their thai chicken salad (so gooddd) and all of their coffee. I always get one coffee drink and then one light seltzer drink and I feel light and happy the rest of the day. Absolutely go here!“

“I always enjoy the food when I come here. They have a very large selection of food. The service is always amazing. Not to mention the interior design is elegant and very beautiful. It has a very nice consistent theme to it as well. I would recommend this restaurant.“

“This is such a hidden gem! I’ve driven past many times and always wanted to stop - we finally did this evening and everything was so delicious! There’s a great variety of items on the menu without being overwhelming. We ordered the any day fish fry and it came with not 3, not 4, but 5 generous pieces! Potato salad and coleslaw were also good (and that’s saying a lot - I don’t enjoy coleslaw!) as well as the chicken portebella sandwich special (so good!). The pumpkin cheesecake was also delicious. We will definitely be back!!“

“Fantastic dining experience! You’ve gotta try the square cheese curds, our burgers were juicy and flavorful, cooked perfect. Pulled pork sandwich was tender and tasty. Bbq pizza was awesome, loved the crust. Great service and food that tastes like it’s supposed to is a win!“

“The food arrived not as warm as I would have liked, BUT, there was only one server. My party arrived shortly after the restaurant opened and quickly became very busy. The server did a great jun but was overwhelmed until help arrived! The food however was very good albeit the temperature was not. The hostess was most gracious in apologizing and I will return in the future.“

“We ordered the battered cod and half the fish was pollack and the other was cod. The pollack was so fishy tasting the dog wouldn't even eat it. It went down the garbage disposal. Fries were overcooked, almost burnt. Salad was all leaves, no tomato except for 2 tiny pieces.The bun was the best of the whole meal.Tally's has always been our go to for fish fries. Always excellent. Hopefully our next visit will be better or we'll be on the hunt for a new place.“

“The full dining experience is SPOT ON! From the well kept appearance to the sincere and attentive staff to the fabulous food! It's what the dining experience is supposed to be! They make French Fries like everyone should! They are so delicious! Beer Cheese to dip them in? Extraordinary!! Doc's on the Fox is doing everything right!“

“It IS worth it. There will be a wait. You're going to need to accept that first and foremost. With great food comes long wait time. Unlike most restaurants, the Blue Heron team knows how to run their show. Once you make it to a table and make the obvious choice to do the all you can eat fish and chicken fry (on Wednesdays and Fridays) you truly won't be waiting long before food arrives at your table! The food is always hot, fresh and delicious! Refills arrive promptly, dishes are cleared quickly... just an all around amazing experience.“