17 Best Caterers near New Berlin

“We loved everything about Matty’s Catering and Event Center. We used their venue for my dad’s celebration of life and their catering service for a graduation party, and both experiences were wonderful.
Melissa’s communication was outstanding. The staff was always professional and understanding. The food was delicious. The event center had plenty of room for everyone to spread out comfortably. The entire staff was wonderful to work with from start to finish. Prices were very reasonable for such outstanding taste & value.
I would highly recommend Matty’s Catering to anyone looking for a great venue or catering service!“

“I have had catered lunches and grilled creations from Tall Guy a few times. Every time, the food was delicious.“

“We were SO impressed with Chef Jack’s from start to finish! Our guests absolutely raved about the food, and we heard so many compliments throughout the night about how delicious everything was.

Beyond the food itself, what really stood out to us was how much care and thought went into the entire planning process. Every question we had was answered quickly and thoughtfully, and everyone we worked with was so personable, kind, and easy to communicate with.

Catering was one of the parts of wedding planning that I expected to be stressful, but Chef Jack’s made it incredibly easy. I ended up having to worry about so much less than I originally anticipated. Their forms were straightforward, the planning process was organized and easy to follow, and we always felt like we knew exactly what was needed from us.

On the wedding day, everything came together beautifully, and it was such a relief knowing we were in good hands. We were genuinely so impressed with the food, the service, and the entire experience. We cannot recommend Chef Jack’s enough!“

“We had the BBQ buffet (brisket and pulled pork) and the food was all fantastic. We had lots of compliments from our guests. The staff was wonderful, set up and take down was efficient and they were great with keeping everything flowing well- we would definitely recommend and use again!“

“Tuscan hall hit the nail on the head! They special ordered our dream wedding food, took our preferences and made them reality, and we didn’t have to lift a finger. The tasting was good, the actual food at the wedding though, was PHENOMENAL. Far surpassed our expectations. Everyone said it was the best wedding food they ever had. Natalie was an angel to work with and everyone from the chef to the servers were exactly what we needed. Couldn’t be happier with how everything turned out. Worth every penny.“

“These things are amazing. Four bucks is not bad at all. The only thing is it’s a long way from Rochester Minnesota to West Elias Wisconsin so I’ll just pay the $10 shipping but I will go there someday promise“

“We ordered dessert from Bishop’s Sweets for our 6th Annual Paintings for Pediatrics Gala, and they were an absolute hit! Our guests devoured every bite—many came back for seconds (and even thirds!). The treats were as beautiful as they were delicious, and the quality and flavor were incredible. Chef Shane was a pleasure to work with. We gave him a budget and he created the perfect dessert assortment that fit our event beautifully. Thank you to the Bishop’s Sweets team for helping make our event extra special. We’ll definitely be back for future events! 💛“

“Brim Cafe and Catering is truly an all-star and gem of the Milwaukee Area. They have graciously donated to Children's Wisconsin's Miracle Marathon the past few years, and made sure dietary needs are met in a delicious and incredible way! The Mediterranean Catering menu is a true highlight, offering incredible flavor! Pair that with the incredible service Brim provides, and it turns into a match made in heaven! I cannot recommend enough!!“

“Timber’s Catering provided our food for our wedding in May! Not only was the food delicious, but the service far exceeded our expectations! They helped guests with their food, had amazing presentation, and were circulating throughout the venue to ensure everyone had what they needed. Guests continue to tell us how amazing the food was and it seemed to be a highlight of the night!“

“We are beyond grateful for the incredible team at Gracious Events who brought our daughter’s wedding day to life with absolute perfection. From start to finish, they executed every detail of the day with absolute perfection. They handled everything—catering, florals, and event coordination, and did so with professionalism, creativity, and care. The communication throughout the planning process was exceptional. We had countless virtual meetings, a full menu tasting, and several on-location design meetings. Leading up to the big day, especially during the week of the wedding, the team was exceptional. We always felt informed, supported, and heard. Marija was an absolute dream to work with on florals and other design details. She listened so carefully to every detail we shared and brought our vision to life more beautifully than we could have imagined. The arrangements were breathtakingly stunning, fresh, and perfectly matched the style and atmosphere of the venue. Guests are still talking about how beautiful everything looked! As for the catering, it was flawless and also a highlight of the evening. The food was absolutely delicious, beautifully presented, and perfectly timed with the flow of the evening served right on time. Every member of the team was warm, attentive, and made us and our guests feel truly cared for. Guests raved about the delicious hors d'oeuvres, entree selections, and desserts! Bella was exceptional as our coordinator. Her communication throughout the planning process was spot on, and we felt completely supported every step of the way. She kept the rehearsal and wedding days running right on schedule and made sure no timeline detail was missed. Her communication with our vendors, wedding party, and families was clear, calm, and incredibly professional — every timeline was not only met but managed so smoothly that we were able to be fully present and enjoy the day without stress. It’s rare to find a company that excels in every aspect of a wedding, but Gracious Events truly did. Their attention to detail, impeccable organization, and warm, responsive communication made all the difference. They created a magical day for us to remember! We feel incredibly lucky to have had them as part of our daughter’s wedding day. Highly, highly recommend!“

“Great Food, Great People And You will Not be Disappointed🥰💯. Brisket & Ribs soooooo tender. That Big Man Potatoe with all the stuff in & on top. That was a meal within itself. Too much to list but dont forget those beans. Banana pudding on point and she even made me a special one without bananas. Ohhh weee, the lemonade is to die for- but please dont die🥰. Trust me and get at Mrs Morgan and her crew at Tasteful Event.“

“10/10 Recommend Apple Spice!!! I have used Apple Spice weekly for the last 2 months. Their menu is so large and I haven’t ordered the same thing twice …. Yet! Their food is fresh and delicious! Their staff is friendly, on time, and very professional! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“Wonderful atmosphere and delicious food. The wait staff was very friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be coming back and it was great place to take our grown daughter for her birthday.“

“I've been coming to Rochester Deli for many years. In the past, it was usually for their Friday Fish Fry. I especially enjoy the Baked Walleye. They also make excellent potato pancakes, and whenever I ask for them extra crispy, they're always happy to accommodate.

Lately, though, I've been stopping in just for the bakery items, which are made next door at Periwinkle Bakery.

This time, I was putting together a dessert tray for a dinner with friends, so I decided to pick up a variety of treats. They had so many tempting choices that day. We came in planning to buy four desserts and left with eight!

We especially love the cannolis. They regularly change the flavors, which keeps us coming back. They're so good!“

“A one stop outlet for all the meat lovers over the north western hemisphere. Not only for the meat but the store fulfils all the daily needs of an individual. Service people are too friendly and are present right at your service. Do visit once when driving past west hampton.“

“Bev makes it just like granny did, excellent quality, Wisconsin portions; all my guests are completely satisfied. Thank you Bev!“