20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newburg

“Food was amazing. Bartender and cook were excellent. 'Easy', the, bar dog, was sweet. The owner appeared to have some sort of personal issues going on which was a bit uncomfortable as he was kind of loud, but the professional behavior of the rest of the staff made it a nice experience.“

“Some of the best pizza I've ever had. We don't live in town, and sometimes we make the 15-mile drive just to eat here. The food is very reasonably priced, and there is always a wide variety of slices ready to be served up for a quick meal. Ashley was awesome behind the counter during our visit today, but then again, that's always what we get when we eat here.“

“We absolutely LOVE Tomaso's in Cedarburg. They have my absolute FAVORITE pizza - perfectly crisp thin crust with the perfect proportion of cheese, sauce, and toppings. Their pizza is wonderfully flavorful and I love that the sauce is on top of the cheese.Tomaso's in Cedarburg has a pretty extensive menu. As much as I would like to try other items on their menu when their pizza is your favorite you eat the pizza. We are also partial to their garlic bread and pickle fries; they are very delicious!Tomaso's is a table seating (seat yourself), order at the bar, and pick up your food at the bar establishment. Service is quick. The restaurant is clean. Prices are reasonable.As I stated, we love it here and will continue to frequent it! I highly recommend their pizza!!“

“We have been to Messina several times in the past few years, and always are greeted pleasantly, and enjoy the charming hand-painted murals on the walls. It is the wonderful food and service bringing us back every time. There's quaint Italian music, or a mix of Jazz and Sinatra piped into the lounge. A small but nice wine offering is a plus.Whether we have steak, pasta or seafood, we are always impressed. A favorite is their marsala. Salads are crisp, fresh pepper is applied tableside. Entrees are beautifully presented, and breads are wonderful, served warm with butter. My favorite is the desserts - I never leave without having tiramisu, and Messina's is wonderful... Even on Saturday nights, without a reservation in a snowstorm, or in July at the height of the dinner hour on a weekend this place shines - in every way. Food, Service, and Atmosphere.There is an exceptional wine list which we occasionally enjoy, too. I love this place and have always hesitated putting out such a wonderful review, because I don't want to find the place so busy as to not be able to give me the great service that we have always enjoyed! (Did I mention the coffee? Also rich and wonderful.) Enjoy it. Messina is fantastic!“

“Visiting Cedarburg Wisconsin for the first time today our group really lucked out in finding Sal's pizzeria. After being turned down at a few local spots for not having reservations we continued down main steet in hopes of finding someplace good for breakfast. After a few minutes walking downtown we crossed the street where the familiar smell of fresh baked pizza permeated the air. After a short discussion the group decided I should go inside first to check if they had enough room for the six of us and see if they made gluten free pizza. The answer was yes to both so we decided to give it a try and man are we glad we did! The six of us, all pizza snobs from Chicago had to agree Sal's makes an exceptionally good pie, literally among the best pizza any of us ever tasted. What makes admitting this so hard is the fact Sal's pizza is New York style, a hard pill to swallow for anyone from the Windy City. But hey, anything as good as Sal's needs to be celebrated so that's why we've decided to surrender this battle in the Pizza wars and share this amazing gem with the world.Mangiare“

“We sat and ate at the bar the guy was great help entertain our children, had a great conversation with everyone in our group you really could tell that he enjoyed his job and wanted to be there.Parking: Right before the train tracks set back off the road a little bit hard to see till you are right no top of it.Kid-friendliness: Pizza of all kinds and ice cream for dessert.“

“I can't speak highly enough about this place. I recently moved to the area via military transfer and, after passing it a number of times, I finally stopped in. So glad I did! The staff couldn't have been nicer or more accommodating, and gave me a 10% military discount on my order. After paying for my pizzas and walking out the door with my pizzas, I realized I had goofed up, ordering two cheese pizzas when I intended to order a cheese and a veggie. The staff immediately transformed the cheese pie into the veggie as I intended, thanked me for coming back and wouldn't let me pay the difference in price. What business provides this level of customer service? When I got it home and took it out of the oven, my whole family extremely pleased with the result. It was fresh and delicious. I grew up back East and I know good pizza. This is a place that clearly takes pride in what they do and the products they offer. I will patronize this local business frequently for as long as I am in the area.“

“The first time of having the Baked Potato pizza. The topping was very good, but the crust seemed really dry and didn't taste very good. I am still going to try more of their pizzas.Parking: They have curbside delivery.Wheelchair accessibility: Lots of area for parking and close to door of the strip mall“

“Highly recommend!The delivery on March 3rd around 6 pm, was on time and the delivery driver was incredibly courteous and professional. I wish we had gotten his name so we could let his manager know we both really appreciated such great service.'The Worx' pizza was absolutely delicious. The hand tossed crust was perfect and all the toppings were even better than anticipated.The whole experience was great, thank you, and we'll be ordering from your restaurant again!“

“Takeout for the first time...5pm on a Saturday, short wait time, and possibly the best pizza I've ever had. If you're looking for thin crust with a little crisp and blow-your-face-off flavor...this is the place. Satisfied everyone, even the 1.5 year old!“

“I have never NOT had an amazing experience with this Bada Bing. I've had delivery, picked up, and dined in. Always happy and funny employees. Management is awesome (a few times I've come in to them training and they are always great). And I'm so glad that while it's one of the few restaurants in the area, especially that delivers to us, I could not ask for better. I invite family from Milwaukee, Greenfield, New Berlin, and even all over the country, over a lot, and can always count on an easy and fast dinner/delivery that knocks the socks off of EVERYONE!Kid-friendliness: While the lobby is small for dine-in with a brood, the employees are amazing with kids! Even the "younger" crowd were all so sweet to my little girl. It's always nice to go to a place where everyone is just chill with kids and don't mind the possible ruckus!“

“You gotta come for the fish fry! Great portion sizes and tasty flights of drinks so you can try different flavors. Nice patio in the warmer months too. They're usually always busy though so expect a wait especially if you're coming on a Friday or Saturday.“

“Was visiting family but since it was raining we decided not to go out to eat but instead got pizzas. Can’t go wrong with Papa John Pizza since you can either go with what’s on their menu of just build your own. You may have to bake it yourself, but you’ll know it’s hot and fresh out of the oven. We had the Papa’s Favorite and Papa’s Perfect (never understood the need for pineapple on a pizza.)“

“This was our first time there after multiple years of people saying we should go. We got cheesy garlic bread and their monthly special pizza, a French onion, and both were great. We were able to speak with the owner, and it was fun learning the history from such a kind woman. We will be back!“

“I come here frequently. I have never run into a worker who wasn't pleasant and able to do any job in the store. If you come on Tuesday, be prepared to wait in line unless you order ahead. Food is always done to order specifications. I'm pretty sure I've had everything on the menu. The only ding I would give is to corporate because the gift cards do not work in the app.“

“I wasn't expecting much until I walked in and saw the blonde hair waterfall That was the mullet rockin bartender, whose eyes I could not get out of. I usually don't swing that way, but for him I might reconsider. Especially after a delicious cold beverage that they often serve at this location with a side of chicken wings and ranch dipping sauce. Jimmy is his name, and if you fall in love, easy stay out of this place“

“It’s not fancy but the pizza is delicious for us it is the sauce and cheese that makes a pizza. Thin crust. It is pizza done well. The mozzarella sticks are awesome, they are rolled not breaded and the chef salad is enough for multiple people.“

“After having a very disappointing experience with my usual pizza place (Domino's, 2 hours, cold pizza) I decided to pick up a pizza from a place that I drive past all the time but had never been. So I called and ordered a pizza to be picked up. When I got there to the small store Mike the owner (? Not sure about that) and I started talking about delivery since I'm a Doordasher and Mike gave me a tour of the place, (spotlessly clean and uncluttered) and his $5k heating system for his deliveries. He is the only one in the area that has special pizza bags that contain a disk which is heated up in the kitchen ( in 1.5 minutes so hot I couldn't even touch it) and the pizza placed inside the bag. Never get a cold pizza delivered again! And how was the pizza? Hot and fresh with big chunks of vegetables lots of cheese and a great sauce. Even after 10 minutes to get it home the crust was great and crunchy. Impressive pizza. Price wise a Large 16" pizza with tomato, olive, sausage, pepperoni, onion, green pepper was $26. Worth every penny! Take out and delivery only are available. I will absolutely be back.“

“Cheesey loaded pizza and fair prices! 2 pc fish fry only $9.75. After hiking on the Riverwalk, we walked over to Michelano's newer convenient location, downtown, which was open for lunch. Extensive menu, clean restraunt-could use decor and music. Friendly and helpful staff!“

“Haven't ordered from Domino's in years, but just had to try the new $19.99 special. It was AWESOME! The pizzas were cooked EXACTLY the way we like them, cheese just a little brown, and the parm bites were to die for. We chose to pick up our order (West Bend) and the employees were very polite and friendly. We will be making this a monthly (or bi-weekly) occasion.“