35 Best Pizza Restaurants near North Lake

“ordered a pizza to go Friday night. While they stated they were short staffed. I received a salad drenched in dressing verses the dressing in a separate cup which then leaked all over the place along with a mediocre pizza with maybe 5 pieces of sausage. $40 for terrible take out. Do better... I would have rather waited longer for a pizza and salad done correctly.“

“Best pizza ever and so many variations of it too!!!!“

“The Margherita Pizza was delicious!“

“Many years ago, I ordered pizza from Papa Murphy’s every single week throughout the year. A few years back the location in Pewaukee/Waukesha went downhill drastically. I gave it a try, but it was just awful.

We moved and the Oconomowoc location is the closest one to us. My picture is before I cooked the pizza. This has to be by far one of the best nondairy pizzas ever! Specifically from the Oconomowoc location.

In the past, when I ordered nondairy pizza from Waukesha, I received a pizza with literally five pieces of each ingredient and it was just bad.

This pizza has plenty of veggies for a nondairy pizza lover to enjoy. The most important part is the customer service. Highly impressed by the staff there. I will be back and perhaps a weekly regular.“

“Pizza is amazing! We always have a great time sitting at the bar & meeting friendly folks.“

“This was our first time trying Eric’s & it was super delicious! My son loved the gluten free crust! My daughter & I had the hand tossed Margarita pizza & it is the best I’ve had in a long time! Delivery was fast, pizza was hot when it arrived & Eric was very friendly when I called with questions & concerns about the gluten free crust/my son is celiac. Five stars!“

“My kids highly approve of the D'Eli Pizza pizza, and so do we.“

“Kim catered a rehearsal dinner for me and did an amazing job! She is super responsive and communicated well. She even provided a gluten free meal with less than 24 hours notice! She and her staff were so friendly and everyone loved the pizza.“

“The pizza is our new favorite!!!! loved it!!!!“

“The pizza is amazing! Thank you for a great dinner experience.“

“There are 2 young girls working today, standing in view of customers, eating breadsticks, drinking and using cell phones. When a customer walks up to the counter, they are giving them food, plates, silverware, with unclean hands. I don't see this kind of thing going on when the manager is here.“

“It was our first time at your restaurant; I brought my two children who are wheelchair users, and my twelve year old. The hostess didn't bat an eyelash: just got is to an appropriate table, which is something that is rare. The server was helpful and kind. The food is delicious: love the broasted chicken and Cole slaw. My daughter's burger was nicely done. The onion rings were perfect, and the root beer was refreshing. Thank you for a lovely dinner in Pewaukee on the 4th! We will come again.“

“All the food was very good, I recommend the quesabirias.“

“A little pricey for what you get. $30 for a thin crust pie that clearly should be $17.
Don’t get me wrong the food is DELICIOUS. I eat here a lot.
Can’t bring my kids in to pick up pizza because they are usually playing hardcore rap on the radio. Takes a little hit on atmosphere for that.
My recommendation is the Garlic Chicken Ranch. Absolutely electric.“

“We had such a nice lunch today at around 2pm, the food was fantastic. The main reason for leaving a review though, is for the wonderful service we received from our waitress. She was so friendly and helpful, and we appreciated her very much. Her manner was pleasant and upbeat and we left with full bellies and huge smiles. We will definitely be back!! 💜“

“good food good people staff is always asking if you need anything the owners are really awesome if they don't have a driver he will personally deliver it is the best pizza around they so out pizza the hut especially with a LG Italian beef n mushroom extra sauce pizza it's fantastic hot or cold I always get the 10$ Mon special two LG two toppings pizzas 10 bucks each can't go wrong I have personally met some of the staff the owner is friendly and outgoing and treats you like family when you visit“

“The wide variety of toppings and customizability mod offers allows you to make the pizza you want your way even if it's like me, making essentially the entire pizza covered in pepperoni. The staff will do it, and that brings another great thing about this place. The people here really care. They know me by name and we chat about how our lives are going whether it is the good, the bad, or the in between. They make time, even if it is busy, to talk with me while STILL managing to be efficient, fast, and assure quality service to other customers. They are all amazing, friendly, and thoughtful people. Just chatting to them and combined with the great food and welcoming atmosphere makes it something I look forward to when I visit and genuinely makes my day a bit better. Thank you all you guys for what you do and for caring.
- Kiki“

“Very happy with the store in Sussex, however, I will never go to the one on Pilgrim. That one looked dirty, messy and had rap music playing so loud it had to be turned down in order to place my order. Very unfriendly staff. Just had what was supposed to be a BOGO deal. When I tried to order on line, I was told the deal wasn't for my cowboy pizza. When I picked up my order, I was told that everyone else had no problem getting the BOGO deal. What's going on?“

“Amazing service! The manager Norma is so kind and was extremely helpful with our large order. Food is super delicious too!

Vegetarian options: Pizza with no meat, salad, Italian Ice, chocolate cake, etc.

Dietary restrictions: Vegan pizza if you ask for it“

“We had a party of 12 on the Fourth of July after having made a reservation earlier in the week. Our server Phoenix had other tables as well but she was friendly, happy, and super attentive (give her a raise!). Everything was great and she met all our needs with beverage options and special requests and we all left super satisfied.

I had the 10” “Just Meat Pizza”. Pizzas are made to order on a prepared crust and cooked in the oven. But it was a light, airy, yet crispy crust—see photos. Plenty of hand added meats but not too much to make the pizza greasy. Sausage and pepperonis had spice but not over powering. And just enough cheese to get a nice cheese pull without being too heavy.

I will definitely be back for the ‘all day breakfast menu’ and to try many of the other foods on the menu!!

Overall a wonderful experience. Just to note 20% added for large parties (though we gave here more cash) and 3% added for credit card payments.“

“Horrible experience! Extremely frustrated! No fault of the wait staff. ordered a pizza and salad, They ran our card through 4 times. then would not refund us 3 of the pizzas and salads, much less the tip. Then sent us home with 4 pizzas 1 salad and 2 garlic monkey breads... They comped us Nothing!!!! We asked for reimbursement of the 3 charges in gift cards, manager said No, they don't have gift cards... Manager Said the could not give us a refund!!!! what a scam“

“Their food is the BEST Italian and pizza in this county- and I’ve lived in Waukesha County all my life. Hands down the winner- even better than Rosati’s and their prices are SO affordable! We have never had an issue with any order from here and we order frequently through DoorDash. So glad we found out about this place!“

“Very disappointed
They do not make Garden of Eden anymore
Really they could not make one piece?

Vegetarian options: They have taken it off the menu...at least at this location

Parking: Person behind the counter could have offered to make me a slice of Garden of Eden“

“Had such a great experience my first time at this Pizza Hut. We were greeted and seated right away. I was impressed with how clean the place was. We did the lunch buffet, and all the food was great, including the different pizzas and pasta. Food at the buffet was being restocked regularly so I was never waiting for more food to come out. Our waitress was very friendly and checked on us regularly to see if we needed more soda or anything else. Overall I was so impressed and will definitely return!“

“Pizza and Wings were delicious, ready when I stopped to pick it up. Only downside was the wing container, the sauce leaked out the edges and onto the seat of my car, so not anything to do with the staff and their work, so will definitely go here again.“

“I ordered the fish and shrimp combo, and man let me tell you, it was outstanding! I had the fish blackened Cajun style had them dust some Cajun seasonings on the perfectly fried shrimp. I thought I was in Florida. If you know you know!“

“They have amazing food and excellent customer service. everyone is so nice there“

“My husband and I had dinner at Twisted Fire, Oconomowoc, WI on Thursday, June 17, 2022. It was fabulous! I ordered Truffle Fries, Chorizo Stuffed Dates wrapped in bacon & pipperada sauce = sooo delish! I have to go back and order these again! Out of this world amazing! I also ordered the Tuna Special which was grilled to perfection and came with baked small potatoes and baby broccoli tips all prepared just right. My Husband ordered the Italian Pizza with Breadsticks. He also raved about his choices. We want to give a shout out to our server Colton who was knowledgeable, and so fun! The whole night was worth every pretty penny spent there. We can’t wait to go back! This was my second time there and both times they didn’t disappoint. Kudos to you Twisted Fire for beautiful atmosphere and a ton of Gluten Free choices. The whole experience is worth going back again!“

“Talked to a Rose there, VERY nice and helpful. Would definitely go again!“

“Love it. thin dry crust. Anyway you like it, they will make it. Fast and fresh. So my last visit was awful. This comes a month after announcing closing of stores. Staff was pathetic. Slow and lethargic. The dough seems to be different. $9 for a mini salad. Place was empty for a Saturday at 12, should have been a warning not to go. They had a great thing going, not sure I'll ever go back.“

“Stopped in for lunch and was glad I did. Friendly service from the jump—felt like a place where everyone knows each other, but newcomers are still welcome. Locals at the bar, couple of regulars playing games in the corner, and the staff chatting like it’s just another day in paradise.

It’s not quite a dive bar, but has that same laid-back, no-BS charm. Heard good things about the steak sandwich—can confirm it lives up to the hype. Solid lunch spot with a comfortable vibe, decent menu, and just enough grit to keep it real.“

“I ordered an Italian sandwich over the phone. The guy was very nice. When I arrived for pickup the staff was extremely friendly and attentive. The sandwich was fresh out of the oven and you could tell it was mad with TLC! Thank You to who ever was working night 3/16/25 keep up the great work!“

“The manager Nico not only made me a great pizza....his sparkling personality made my day! Thanks for the great service!“

“My husband and I love everything about this place! The service, food, and atmosphere are all great!

Crystal is super nice and friendly. Ask for her if you go!

We recently ordered the fried pickles and cheese pizza...both are a favorite!“

“I went with my mom and friends to play bingo and it was a blast! We had played and sadly I didn’t win but friends at the table took home over 1100$ that night. We ordered chicken tenders and fries and it was great tasting and a healthy portion. Mom ordered the Italian sausage sandwich and I was impressed with this as well. Great place for a night of family fun. Proceeds go to a good cause as well.“