11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Oconomowoc

“Many years ago, I ordered pizza from Papa Murphy’s every single week throughout the year. A few years back the location in Pewaukee/Waukesha went downhill drastically. I gave it a try, but it was just awful.

We moved and the Oconomowoc location is the closest one to us. My picture is before I cooked the pizza. This has to be by far one of the best nondairy pizzas ever! Specifically from the Oconomowoc location.

In the past, when I ordered nondairy pizza from Waukesha, I received a pizza with literally five pieces of each ingredient and it was just bad.

This pizza has plenty of veggies for a nondairy pizza lover to enjoy. The most important part is the customer service. Highly impressed by the staff there. I will be back and perhaps a weekly regular.“

“This was our first time trying Eric’s & it was super delicious! My son loved the gluten free crust! My daughter & I had the hand tossed Margarita pizza & it is the best I’ve had in a long time! Delivery was fast, pizza was hot when it arrived & Eric was very friendly when I called with questions & concerns about the gluten free crust/my son is celiac. Five stars!“

“Kim catered a rehearsal dinner for me and did an amazing job! She is super responsive and communicated well. She even provided a gluten free meal with less than 24 hours notice! She and her staff were so friendly and everyone loved the pizza.“

“Very nice Employee answer the phone after having an issue with one of my pizzas. I’ve been buying From the store for over three years now And honestly, I never really get an issue. The other day I ordered a pizza and this time it was burnt a little And the dough was really thin, not like normal So I called Two Days later And they were very apologetic and told me they had a new dough maker Completely Understandable!!!“

“I had an amazing experience at MOD Pizza! The restaurant was clean, the atmosphere was welcoming, and the food was absolutely delicious. As for the 3 pizzas and 2 salads I had ordered they might have been the best pizzas and salads I’ve ever had.

What really made my visit stand out, though, was the service. A worker named Sergio went above and beyond to make sure my order was exactly how I wanted it. He was friendly, patient, and clearly takes pride in his work. You can tell he genuinely cares about creating a positive experience for customers. Workers like Sergio are what make a place memorable—he’s a true asset to the MOD team.

If you’re looking for great pizza and even better service, this is the place to go. I’ll definitely be coming back! 5/5 would recommend!“

“My husband and I had dinner at Twisted Fire, Oconomowoc, WI on Thursday, June 17, 2022. It was fabulous! I ordered Truffle Fries, Chorizo Stuffed Dates wrapped in bacon & pipperada sauce = sooo delish! I have to go back and order these again! Out of this world amazing! I also ordered the Tuna Special which was grilled to perfection and came with baked small potatoes and baby broccoli tips all prepared just right. My Husband ordered the Italian Pizza with Breadsticks. He also raved about his choices. We want to give a shout out to our server Colton who was knowledgeable, and so fun! The whole night was worth every pretty penny spent there. We can’t wait to go back! This was my second time there and both times they didn’t disappoint. Kudos to you Twisted Fire for beautiful atmosphere and a ton of Gluten Free choices. The whole experience is worth going back again!“

“Had such a great experience my first time at this Pizza Hut. We were greeted and seated right away. I was impressed with how clean the place was. We did the lunch buffet, and all the food was great, including the different pizzas and pasta. Food at the buffet was being restocked regularly so I was never waiting for more food to come out. Our waitress was very friendly and checked on us regularly to see if we needed more soda or anything else. Overall I was so impressed and will definitely return!“

“My parents & I met here with my kids on a whim bc the original place we were going to had a long wait. We know a couple that frequents HSA so we thought we’d check it out. We had a great experience- food was good and our waiter was awesome! My only complaint would be the prices on everything. Up charge for everything - including to add fries & $3.50 for kids drinks is a little over the top. I understand the kids cups are probably not cheap but still. I’ve been to many places where we didn’t get charged for kids drinks & got the nice plastic cups. Asked for an extra side of ranch & was not told it would be an extra .85.

It was kid friendly but no kids menu. I bet it would be easy to come up with some creative kids options, that people would really enjoy. (some fun and creative kids’ menu name ideas: Mini Chopper Sliders, Roadster Chicken Bites, Lil’ Rider Fish Fry, Kid Cruiser Dog, Handlebar Grilled Cheese, Pit Stop Mac & Cheese, Easy Rider Chicken Tenders, Scooter Shrimp Sticks, BBQ Highway Skewers, and the Motor Mini Burger. Sides could include Chrome Tots, Cruiser Fries, Road Trip Veggie Cup, or Fuel-Up Fruit Sticks.). -How fun would some of those be :)

Will definitely be back to check it out in warmer weather. Great place!“

“Joel is the best! Love Mapleway!!“

“I ordered an Italian sandwich over the phone. The guy was very nice. When I arrived for pickup the staff was extremely friendly and attentive. The sandwich was fresh out of the oven and you could tell it was mad with TLC! Thank You to who ever was working night 3/16/25 keep up the great work!“

“Have always enjoyed this place! We were lucky enough to have them host our holiday work party with a two week notice due to the other venue cancelling on us. It was such a wonderful space and experience!! I highly recommend them! Thank you!!“