16 Best American Restaurants near Palmyra

1 Seven Oak Public House

4.8 Superb 107 Reviews

300 West Main Street, Palmyra

• Delivery

“Great service, great food!!”

2 Edge Of Town Cafe

4.8 Superb 217 Reviews

W1242 WI-59, Palmyra

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“The staff is very polite and very friendly and helpful, would advise going there .”

3 Main Street Family Restaurant

4.7 Superb 191 Reviews

123 West Main Street, Palmyra

• Take-Out

“Food was great are waitress was outstanding she needs to smile more but she was outstanding! The food just took an extraordinarily long time to come to the table. I do understand that it was quite busy but it shouldn't take 45 minutes for table of four to get their food. That being said I do recommend the place if you like Hometown cooking this is where you come.”

4 Nite Cap Inn

4.2 Good 159 Reviews

227 South 3rd Street, Palmyra

• Take-Out

“So sad they're closed. We always enjoyed coming here and Eileen was the best bartender and always remembered us, especially my daughter!! The establishment and food will be greatly missed! Especially the homemade cheesecakes. Enjoy the retirement!!!”

5 Squidys 2

4.4 Superb 121 Reviews

102 North 2nd Street, Palmyra

• Delivery

“been going to Squids 2 for quit a long time my sense was 25 im 45 now use to be me and my uncle and sometimes parents now it's just me and wife go on Friday. Love all you can eat Fish on Friday with buffet and there homemade Tatar sauce, me and family use to go all around to all you can eat fish frys been to at least 10 all you can eat places in this neck of the woods and I want to say honestly for price and quality it's one of better places to get all you can eat fish. I enjoy a pitch of spotted cow with me fish here..”

6 Hot Rods Bar-N-Grill

4.3 Superb 73 Reviews

200 West Main Street, Palmyra

• Take-Out

“Great drinks, and great people. !”

7 Red Roof Station

4.6 Superb 130 Reviews

201 Grove Street, Eagle · 5.66 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Awesome food, awesome atmosphere. Everyone is super nice and welcoming!”

8 Knucklehead Pub

4.5 Superb 271 Reviews

100 S Road, Eagle · 5.63 miles

• Delivery

“We're here several times a year, as it is a MUST GO destination while out on the bike! Food is always fantastic and they never judge when I ask for a vat of beer cheese on the side 😂”

9 Rustix

4.6 Superb 334 Reviews

105 West Main Street, Eagle · 5.64 miles

• Take-Out

“Great place to stop at and enjoy a nice cocktail with good company 😁 From the other Tiffany and her Mom”

10 Black Frog Grille

4.6 Superb 182 Reviews

151 Main Street, Sullivan · 9.33 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“So it's been awhile since I last did a review. My friend and I were hungry for burgers. The place we normally go to. The their kitchen was closed. So I saw Black Frog Grille. Oh my God! These burgers are so juicy and made right how I like them! I am still craving for their burgers. The gentleman who I assume is the owner. He told us that back in the day it use to be a bar and a butcher place. How wild is that. The staff they were awesome and very friendly and welcoming to us. They were all so sweet good people. I am going back for sure to get more burgers! And the decor is awesome too. You'll have to try them out! Cheers!”

11 841 Brewhouse

4.2 Good 291 Reviews

841 East Milwaukee Street, Whitewater · 7.2 miles

• Take-Out

“Swung in for a quick beer and bite to eat after hiking in Kettle Moraine. Everything was great!”

12 Lefty's Chicago Style Hot Dogs

4.6 Superb 140 Reviews

N7033 US-12, Elkhorn · 9.16 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Been coming for 20 years. Love the food and service!!! Clean the seating area up! Hodge podge okay, dirty no., especially in back area. Weeds and Dandelions growing through mulch, tables unwiped. Broken furniture, some furniture is needing a coat of paint.”

13 Bark River Lanes

4.6 Superb 124 Reviews

W1914 Main Street, Sullivan · 7.42 miles

“Amazing fish fry, steaks are always cooked to perfection, a fully stocked salad bar (supper club style) truly amazing specials. This place is a perfect hidden gem. Service is always good.”

14 Barley's Hops & Malt

4.5 Superb 171 Reviews

N8720 County Road North, East Troy · 7.85 miles

• Take-Out

“Best evet”

15 Lauderdale Landing

4.4 Superb 219 Reviews

W5625 Westshore Drive, Elkhorn · 7.42 miles

• Take-Out

“First time here. food was delicious. They were very busy and we were still able to get our food quickly. Had the fish fry. So delicious. Highly recommend this place.”

16 Brain Freeze

4.0 Good 171 Reviews

535 East Milwaukee Street, Whitewater · 7.53 miles

• Delivery

“Wonderful place! We stopped in since my husband was working in Whitewater! The woman at the front taking our order was so friendly and helpful (assuming she was the owner- maybe?)! Food was great and came out quick for how much we ordered! Definitely will be back when we are in town!”