10 Best Italian Restaurants in Sheboygan

Trattoria Stefano Italian • $$$
522 S 8th St, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Ossobuco Alla Bergamasca
Ossobuco Alla Milanese
Seppie Alla Plancha
Wild Boar Sausage
Rigatoni Special
Calamari Griglia
Vitello Stefano
Bruschetta
Ragu Pasta
Tiramisu

“My granddaughter (an adult) and I ate outside here one evening. Our server, August, was just amazing. We were here over 2 hours and although we had both been to Italy this was one of the best meals we ever had. We had 5 courses and August did not rush us explaining each of our dishes and answering our questions thoroughly. It was simply a delightful experience. We have been singing the praises of this restaurant since we left. You won’t be disappointed and will want to go back just as we would like to return. Rustica salad is unique and you just want to keep eating it and the veal ossobuco oh my. My granddaughter and I agreed that we are sorry we couldn’t try everything and hope to find a way to return. Thank you for such a lovely experience.“

4.4 Superb112 Reviews
Lino Ristorante Italiano Italian • $$$
422 S Pier Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Served with Seasonal Vegetables
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Antipasto Platter Small
Bread Oil and Vinegar
Calamaretti Siciliana
Chocolate Espresso
Lobster Fettuccine
Pasta with Shrimp
Limoncello Flute
Bolognese Pasta

“Not only are the food and drinks exceptional, but the staff know their business, and make the meal a real experience! Always a 10/10!!!“

4.6 Superb99 Reviews
Luigi's Italian Restaurant Italian • $
2910 Kohler Memorial Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Chicago Stuffed Pizza
Bruschetta with Tomato and Basil
Chicago Style Stuffed Pizza
Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza
Spaghetti Carbonara
Garlic Cheese Bread
Fettuccine Alfredo
Mozzarella Sticks
Chicken Parmesan
Chicken Marsala

“I love the food and the service is great. That’s good enough for me.“

4.5 Superb129 Reviews
Il Ritrovo Italian • $$
515 S 8th St, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Margherita Pizza Now That's What You Call Italian Pizza MA MA Miyaaaàa
Fried Calamari Fra Diavolo
Gnocchi Sorrentina Special
Prosciutto Di Parma
Calabrese Con Miele
Housemade Tiramisu
Wonderful Pizza
Fonduta Al Forno
Caprese Salad
Bread and Oil

“Absolutely outstanding Italian food. Authentic and delicious“

4.4 Superb172 Reviews
Uptown Slice Pizza • $
1116 Michigan Ave, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Apple Bacon Gorgonzola House White Pie
Chicken and Hot Peppers House Red Pie
Sausage Giardiniera House Red Pie
Uptown Margherita House Red Pie
Market Garden House White Pie
Apple Bacon Gorgonzola Slice
Uptown Funk House White Pie
Gio's Meat House Red Pie
Bee Sting House Red Pie
Pepperoni Pizza Slice

“Best slice in town! tasty pie, high quality ingredients, and just all around a great place to be.“

4.8 Superb204 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
4314 Olive Gdn Wy, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo Our Signature Alfredo Made Fresh in-House Every Day Served over Fettuccine
Black Tie Mousse Cake Chocolate Cake Dark Chocolate Cheesecake and Creamy Custard with Icing
Chicken & Gnocchi a Creamy Soup Made with Roasted Chicken Italian Dumplings and Spinach
Chicken Parmigiana a Classic with Our Homemade Marinara and a Side of Spaghetti
Minestrone Fresh Vegetables Beans and Pasta in a Light Tomato Broth
Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Tour of Italy Calamari and Chicken Marsala Fettuccine
Fettuccine Alfredo with Chicken Added Broccoli
Five Cheese Ziti Al Forno
Create Your Own Pasta

“My husband and I ate at our Olive Garden for the first time on July 11 2024. Our food was delicious and there was plenty of it. Our server was Jonathan. He was very friendly and helpful. We had a couple of hiccups but he graciously helped us thru them. We will definitely return and tell our friends to check it out.“

4.1 Good179 Reviews
Sheboygan Pasty Company Italian • $
811 A Indiana Ave, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Appetizer Pasty
Breakfast Pasty
Dinner Pasty
Traditional
Sheboygan
Italian

“Loved my Thanksgiving Pasty ! Got the last 2 for me and my Husband on our way to Greenbay for tomorrow’s game. Loved the lady who prepared them. She made sure we got gravy on the side to go. We scarfed them while we charged up at the nearby Tesla station. Tasty treats, great comfort food.Fresh food, clean bathrooms.“

4.6 Superb42 Reviews
Harry’s Prohibition Bistro Fine Dining • $$
668 S Pier Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Margherita D O C Pizza
Chicken and Gnocchi
Marsala Beef Pizza
Mezza Luna Pizza
Prosciutto Pizza
Camp Fire Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Bistro Meatball
Sausage Pizza
Beef Marsala

“I love coming here every time I am in the area. Food is great, views are gorgeous, staff is great!!“

4.4 Superb116 Reviews
Faye's Pizza Pizza • $
1821 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Faye’S House Deluxe Pizza
Thin Create Your Own Pizza
Cheese and Sausage Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Dip Dish Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cajun Pizza
Great Pizza

“Best pizza in the sheboygan County area. Definitely delicious pizza. Best thin crust pizza. they make it nice!!“

4.2 Good115 Reviews
Marco's Pizza Pizza • $
2610 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Magnifico
Hawaiian Chicken
Buffalo Chicken
Build Your Own
Cheese Bread
Chicken Wings
6-Inch Sub
Small Pizza
Deluxe
Greek

“Some of the best thin crust pizza that I’ve had in a very very long time. Fresh ingredients. Arrived hot.“

4.1 Good67 Reviews

You May Also Like