13 Best Italian Restaurants near Sun Prairie

“We love bringing out of town friends to Sal's. We had the Valentine's menu and it was the best food we've had in years! Tameka was amazing and the food came out so quick. Clean plates all day!“

“BEST PIZZA I have ever had! They have great burgers soup, salads, appetizers and pastas too. Definitely coming back.“

“I live in deforest and this is the only breakfast spot I’ll go to. It never disappoints. The food is great. Nothing crazy, but it’s simple midwest food cooked how you ask and brought out in a reasonable time with a friendly waitstaff. Love this place!“

“the chicken dinners in the tiramisu“

“Fabulous food, fantastic service and feel great supporting a locally owned family restaurant.“

“All 5 ⭐'s from me. There's no other pizza like Rocky' s. I'm not a huge sausage fan unless it's on a meat pizza, but I'd say 4/5 times I have to get a slice of pep/saus. Their sausage has such a great flavor to it. Their sauce is good too. If I get a super slice, I get 2 sides of pizza sauce to put on top. It's that good. They also sell their sauce at the store which is a plus.“

“We were rolling in from a long day of driving. We expected the usual hotel food, but were unexpectedly surprised that Johnny’s was there. What a special place. The food was amazing, and the service was stellar! Our server/bartender, Alyssa, was fantastic! Would absolutely recommend eating here when in the area, even if you are not at the Hilton. Oh, and all the desserts are house made!“

“Always amazing here. Food , atmosphere, staff, and great cocktails to boot.“

“So good and great service“

“Excellent service! Delicious food! Four of us celebrated my birthday here last night and enjoyed every single detail. The calamari and arancini appetizers were flavorful and breaded perfectly. One person had a Caesar salad, he said it was perfect. For our courses, my husband devoured his Cappellaci All Aragosta, but not before sharing a bite with each of us, and it was soooooo good. I had the Spaghetti Al Funghetto and absolutely loved it. Mom and dad also enjoyed their pasta dishes very much. Our desserts were crème brûlée, cannoli, and tiramisu. All made in house and all delicious. Then the service. The staff took very good care of us. Our waiter happened to be one of the owners, Sergio. We were lucky to hear about his history of working in the restaurant industry in Madison for years at restaurants we had known, now running his own! He was so passionate and interactive about the menu, it was so fun! By the end of our meal, my husband and I already had our next date set for another dinner at Fratelli’s. And in Madison, with so many options to try, we don’t revisit many places often, but Fratelli’s is going to the top of our list.“

“An Olive Garden with attentive servers.

Food is what you expect from any other Olive Garden. This is a large location. One drawback, we arrived near 9pm and instead of utilizing the entire restaurant space, the hostess guided us to only one side. We asked for an area away from other patrons to enjoy our dinner. Not sure why restaurants do this but it feels a bit like herding cattle in over direction for the sake of keeping the cleaning in one area.

Our server William was very kind and funny. He provided suggestions for food and beverage choices.

Food tasted good and as you would expect. The sauce used in the lasagna is a basic marinara sauce with a few chuncks of tomatoes yet a bit on the watery side. The Alfredo sauce I heard was good and thick. The paired wine Merlot was ok.“

“Bunky’s is simply amazing! They catered our wedding 12 years ago. Authentic Mediterranean food, expertly prepared, with superb customer service... highly recommend!“

“I come in there for my lunch break almost everyday, I love the people who work there, I love the restaurant itself, and for the longest time the food was always great. But in the last few weeks, the food has taken a downward spiral. The fries aren't crunchy anymore, and they seem completely different than before, I couldn't even finish eating them because I thought they were so bad and it sucked because I used to LOVE these fries, the breadsticks were almost inedible this week too. I thought thr first day that maybe it was just a fluke, and then the next day I held onto hope, but now a week or so later it's still the same. 💔 I love Rockys and I love the people who work here I just wish the food had stayed the same.

UPDATE: THE FRIES ARE BACK YOU ALL CAN THANK ME!!! THANK YOU ROCKYS IM SO HAPPY“