13 Best Italian Restaurants near Sun Prairie

Sugar River Pizza Co. Pizza • $
1390 Cabela Dr, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Murder Hornet Is My Safe Word by Warpihs Brewing G Co
Italian Creek Meatlovers Pizza
Rio Grande BBQ Chicken Pizza
Sugar River Pretzel Bites
Italian Creek Meat Lovers
Yahara Chicken Alfredo
Spinach and Artichoke
Amazon Deluxe Pizza
Appetizer Platter
Cinnamon Nuggets

“BEST PIZZA I have ever had! They have great burgers soup, salads, appetizers and pastas too. Definitely coming back.“

4.3 Superb354 Reviews
Country Cafe Italian • $
1030 Emerald Terrace, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Country Fried Steak Dinner
Over Easy Eggs and Toast
Breakfast Skillet
Cheese Burger
Hamburger
Pancakes
Waffle

“I have become a regular ever sense I found this place ⁽⁽٩(๑˃̶͈̀ ᗨ ˂̶͈́)۶⁾⁾
They have big portions without being crazy expensive.
I got my food quickly, the waitress was very polite, the food was delicious and filling!
I like how it is a very peaceful old school dinner feel as well!
I will definitely come again!!
(I was to hungery and forget to take a picture but I had the country omelet this time)“

3.9 Good77 Reviews
Salvatore's Tomato Pies Pizza • $
121 E Main St, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Fat Uncle Tony’S Pie
Fat Uncle Tony Pizza
Classic Cheeseburger
Farmer John's Pizza
The Woodsman Pizza
Side Market Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Sal's Supreme
Cheese Pizza
Caesar Salad

“We love bringing out of town friends to Sal's. We had the Valentine's menu and it was the best food we've had in years! Tameka was amazing and the food came out so quick. Clean plates all day!“

4.6 Superb151 Reviews
Meze Mediterranean Grill Mediterranean • $$
503 W Main St, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Imam Fainted Bayildi Vegan-Gluten Free
Mediterranean Salad
Gnocchi with Shrimp
Ottoman Platter
Red Lentil Soup
Grape Leaves GF
Iskender Kebap
Salmon Piccata
Falafel Wrap
Grape Leaves

“Fabulous food, fantastic service and feel great supporting a locally owned family restaurant.“

4.4 Superb178 Reviews
Johnny's Italian Steakhouse Steak House • $$$
1220 S Grand Ave, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Steak and Stuffed Shrimp
Parmesan Encrusted Steak
Goat Cheese Salad
Turtle Cheesecake
Stuffed Mushrooms
Center Cut Filet
Crème Brûlée
Tiramisu Cake
Sausage Bread
Garlic Bread

“Me and my wife are new to the Madison-Sun prairie area and decided to try a restaurant with great reviews in the area! Johnny’s Steak House delivered an exceptional experience from start to finish. Our server, Chris, set the tone with a warm welcome, expert menu guidance, and impeccable timing. The steaks were perfectly cooked, cocktails balanced, and every detail felt intentional. Chris anticipated needs before we asked, checked in discreetly, and made the evening feel effortless. Five stars, confidently recommending Johnny’s, and asking for Chris by name next time.“

4.4 Superb176 Reviews
Rosati's Pizza Pizza • $
355 E Linnerud Dr, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine Alfredo with Grilled Chicken
Chicago-Style Deep Dish Pizza
Three Cheese Baked Penne
Rosati's Antipasto Salad
Thin Crust Cheese Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana Pasta
Rosati's Dough Nuggets
18 Pizza - White Pizza
Italian Beef Sandwich
18 Pizza - Meat Mania

“the chicken dinners in the tiramisu“

4.4 Superb104 Reviews
Rocky Rococo Pizza and Pasta Pizza • $
2828 Prairie Lakes Dr, Sun Prairie

Customers` Favorites

Sausage & Pepperoni Slice Super Slice
Extra Cheesy Sausage and Mushroom
Sausage & Pepperoni Super Slice
Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
Super Slice of the Day
Salad Bar and Dressings
Cheesy Breadsticks
Family Meal Deal
The Chicago Pizza
The Motheroni

“I have always liked pizza from Rocky's. Even more so that you can get a slice quickly, eat it and get back to what you were doing. The breadsticks also are very good so as far as a quick pizza place this does a good job.

The staff member that we encountered was not super friendly and did seem as if she would have rather have no one show up.

Overall the food was good and we needed something quick. This was both of those things.“

4.3 Superb89 Reviews
Bar Corallini Italian • $$
2004 Atwood Ave, Madison - 9.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni and Pickled Pepper Pizza
Rigatoni Alla Bolognese
Pappardelle Bolognese
Grilled Eggplant Pizza
Soppressata Pizza
Eggplant Fritters
Mushroom Risotto
Margherita Pizza
Pizza Prosciutto
Chicken Piccata

“Always amazing here. Food , atmosphere, staff, and great cocktails to boot.“

4.8 Superb288 Reviews
Fraboni's Italian Specialties & Delicatessen-East Italian • $
108 Owen Rd, Monona - 10.48 miles

“Love the deli for the Italian products!!! Cheeses, passatas, etc are fantastic!“

4.7 Superb226 Reviews
Fratelli's Trattoria Italian • $$
5801 Monona Dr, Monona - 10.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ceaser Salad and Fried Risotto Balls
Mozzarella Marinara
Fratelli's Pasta
Chicken Parmesan
Gio's Fettuccine
Profiteroles
Caesar Salad
Bread Sticks
Bruschetta
Antipasto

“Excellent service! Delicious food! Four of us celebrated my birthday here last night and enjoyed every single detail. The calamari and arancini appetizers were flavorful and breaded perfectly. One person had a Caesar salad, he said it was perfect. For our courses, my husband devoured his Cappellaci All Aragosta, but not before sharing a bite with each of us, and it was soooooo good. I had the Spaghetti Al Funghetto and absolutely loved it. Mom and dad also enjoyed their pasta dishes very much. Our desserts were crème brûlée, cannoli, and tiramisu. All made in house and all delicious. Then the service. The staff took very good care of us. Our waiter happened to be one of the owners, Sergio. We were lucky to hear about his history of working in the restaurant industry in Madison for years at restaurants we had known, now running his own! He was so passionate and interactive about the menu, it was so fun! By the end of our meal, my husband and I already had our next date set for another dinner at Fratelli’s. And in Madison, with so many options to try, we don’t revisit many places often, but Fratelli’s is going to the top of our list.“

4.5 Superb129 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
4320 E Towne Blvd, Madison - 6.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Alfredo Dine in: Yes Outdoor seating: No Takeout: Yes Curbside pickup: Yes
Chocolate Brownie Lasagna
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Unlimited Soup and Salad
Chicken Alfredo Pasta
All You Can Eat Salad
Herb-Grilled Salmon
Eggplant Parmigiana
Mozzarella Sticks
Eggplant Parmesan

“We had the absolute honor of being one of Jasper’s first tables, he was such an incredible server! So attentive and so helpful! Our drinks never stayed empty, our soups and breadsticks were refreshed so quickly, and our food came out so fast. On top of that, all of the food was absolutely delicious. We will definitely be coming back!“

3.9 Good231 Reviews
Bunky's Catering Caterers • $$
2425 Atwood Ave, Madison - 9.12 miles

“Bunky’s is simply amazing! They catered our wedding 12 years ago. Authentic Mediterranean food, expertly prepared, with superb customer service... highly recommend!“

5 Superb3 Reviews
Rocky Rococo Pan Style Pizza Pizza • $
4556 Monona Dr, Madison - 9.64 miles

Customers` Favorites

Super Slice Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza with Breadsticks
Original Italian Breadsticks 6
Motherload Sausage Pizza
Super Slice of the Day
Tuesday - The Perfect
Pepperoni Motherload
Sausage Mother Load
Sausage & Mushroom
Cheese Pizza
Salad Bar

“This is a wonderful Rocky Rococo’s!! There is a nice salad bar here. Their pizza and breadsticks were amazing! There is an arcade here as well. This Rocky’s is a GREAT ONE! It has a perfect nostalgic look and feels like exactly what I think a Rocky’s should look and feel like. It is great! We highly recommend this Rocky’s!“

4 Good91 Reviews

You May Also Like