10 Best Italian Restaurants near Oconomowoc

“I have dined here several times, and at each visit I am more and more impressed I am! If you have not been, then you need to go!!“

“Bella Gusto is the friendliest and most welcoming restaurant. The passion for quality wine, spirits and thoughtful dishes flows so naturally from the hands-on owner Brett. He is an expert in wine making as well! Every local seems to not only know, but trust him. I'm from out of town, (Chicago!) and have experienced nothing but positivity and attention to detail both times I've visited. 10/10 highly recommend!“

“Always great variety of flavors. Love coming here for a treat“

“Been going there for years and the food is awesome but our last visit this past weekend was not that good I don’t know if it’s because of a different cook that we saw but my wife chicken salad the chicken was really dry and even with extra salad dressing it was still dry and I had the cheefSandwich and the Sauce for dipping had no flavor to it and that was usually the best part of the sandwich. Just leaving this message in hopes that management fixes the issues because normally We really enjoy their food.“

“Our first time dining here was absolutely amazing, from the moment we walked in to the moment we left. Professional service and high quality food and drinks. I highly recommend IL Mito Cafe, you won’t be disappointed! Their stuffed mushrooms and lamb dish was tasty and juicy.“

“Food was amazing, cooked perfectly.
I had never been there before, but I will definitely go back.
This is a high price place, so we (our family) will only go on special occasions.
Excellent!
Definitely would recommend“

“Wow! This is a great little restaurant. When the patio opens, seating will double. Make a reservation. Parking is hard to find, so plan accordingly. There are great specials almost every night. We ordered of the regular menu Grouper and Beef Short ribs. Both are excellent. The Terimisue is homemade and is outstanding. Service and atmosphere are fantastic, very upscale and sheik.“

“This Olive Garden sets the standard for what every location should strive to be! The restaurant itself is impressively spacious, with high ceilings that could probably only be reached with a 35-foot ladder. The entire space was spotless – from the tables to the floors. I was even impressed to see a dedicated waitress on her hands and knees retrieving a dropped dish under a table.

Our server, Kate, was absolutely amazing! Not only did she provide top-notch service, but she also kept us entertained with her great sense of humor. She proudly called herself a "service pro," and I have to say, she truly lived up to the title!

Honestly, I can't imagine coming back to this location unless Kate is working – she made the whole experience unforgettable.

Oh, and the food? Delicious! We indulged in way too many breadsticks, bowls of soup, and of course, endless pasta. Everything was perfect!“

“Had the Haystack onions and an individual pizza. Very good as always. My favorite place to go for pizza around here.“

“ordered a pizza to go Friday night. While they stated they were short staffed. I received a salad drenched in dressing verses the dressing in a separate cup which then leaked all over the place along with a mediocre pizza with maybe 5 pieces of sausage. $40 for terrible take out. Do better... I would have rather waited longer for a pizza and salad done correctly.“