What are you looking for?

Italian Restaurants in Madison

4.6 - 402 votes

Hours: 5:30 - 9PM

116 King St, Madison
(608) 285-9021

Papa Johns Pizza

There were a handful of other tables, but overall it was less than half full while we were there. We had to wait awhile to get menus, drinks and to order... More reviews

4.8 - 155 votes

Hours: 11AM - 2:30PM

222 W Washington Ave Ste 30, Madison
(608) 467-8108

Papa Johns Pizza

Casetta never disappoints! Such a great weekday lunch spot, we've tried so many of their sandwiches over time! They always have fun specials in addi... More reviews

4.5 - 364 votes

Hours: 5 - 10PM

15 N Butler St, Madison
(608) 250-6330

Papa Johns Pizza

Y'all.…. this place is out of this world!! Everything from the wine, appetizers, entrée desserts and coffee are just phenomenal... More reviews

4.6 - 207 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

2004 Atwood Ave, Madison
(608) 709-1316

Papa Johns Pizza

My family has been recommending this place for a while and I finally went and tried it. The atmosphere is amazing, the food is divine, and the staff care... More reviews

4.7 - 105 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

2903 University Ave, Madison
(608) 498-4995

Papa Johns Pizza

We ventured off the interstate to find this place. It was good. Probably not worth the trek from the interstate. Was very clean with friendly staff. ... More reviews

4.5 - 202 votes

Hours: 4 - 9PM

912 E Johnson St, Madison
(608) 238-6040

Papa Johns Pizza

This is so amazing !!!!! I have only got from there a few times because I live like an hour or two away but it is sooo SOOO AMAZING! More reviews

4.4 - 243 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

704 S Whitney Way, Madison
(608) 661-9254

Papa Johns Pizza

Fantastic food! We ate there while we were in town for an event. The waiter was very friendly, and did a great job waiting on our table. I got the fettuc... More reviews

4.4 - 208 votes

Hours: 4:30 - 8:30PM

2500 University Ave, Madison
(608) 238-1922

Papa Johns Pizza

This place is no joke. The food was delicious. I'll be honest and say that it did take a bit to get service once we were sat. But one look of discom... More reviews



4.3 - 531 votes

Hours: 4 - 10PM

122 W Mifflin St, Madison
(608) 284-9378

Papa Johns Pizza

Felt rushed when waitress pushed for drink and app order before we had even opened menu which was followed by very long delays between courses. Meatballs... More reviews

4.4 - 175 votes

Hours: 9AM - 5PM

4606 Verona Rd, Madison
(608) 273-1981

Papa Johns Pizza

My first stops at Gino's were over 23 years ago. It was excellent then, and it still is today. It's a fair bit harder to get to with the new ro... More reviews

View on map