21 Best Italian Restaurants in Madison

“Always amazing here. Food , atmosphere, staff, and great cocktails to boot.“

“Y'all.…. this place is out of this world!! Everything from the wine, appetizers, entrée desserts and coffee are just phenomenal!! Do not pass this place up! I love the line of this chef… The way the music goes, that’s the we dance! And that’s exactly what this place is all about. Everyone loves this place! Tony Bennet and famous athletes from all over - including Reggie Bush!“

“Great experience…everything from the ambiance to the waitstaff to the drinks, appetizers, entree, desserts and coffee were amazing!“

“Good food and nice place!“

“I've been going to Ginos for years! Best sandwiches in Madison! I'm just sorry they aren't open more! Love, love, LOVE them!!!“

“After 29 years of living near Madison, we finally went for dinner last night. Everything was delicious- mocktail, bruschetta, both pasta dishes (mushroom truffle & sausage rigatoni), as well as the light, fluffy desserts (butterscotch pudding & cheesecake with rhubarb/strawberry compote). Super happy our waiter, James, sent us home with an extra baguette & recommended making French toast - which we did today! We’ll be back with friends and recommending to others!“

“I got the woodsman pizza which tasted delicious, a little oily for me. The service was fast, efficient and the hostess welcome us kindly. Because it’s was a weekday they were not busy at all. Definitely a place I would go back, I like the atmosphere too, inside it has a red decor and with the candles looks cool. Also the price is great!“

“We have been to Nonno's at least 4 times in the past few years! This restaurant is the absolute best Italian food our family has ever had. The service is top notch! Our son Sean loves going here and always orders the Chicken Alfredo with lots and lots of cheese. I always order Spaghetti Bolognese which never disappoints!! Thank you to our waiter and the staff for your wonderful hospitality and service.“

“The pizza is amazing. Staff are great! I love the atmosphere!“

“Two of their standard items can be made vegan - neither are vegan by default so just ask. Totally worth it, pick up some sourdough while you are there.“

“My granddaughter and I was touring downtown Madison about two weeks ago, we came across D’Vino as we walked. The special for the day was crab cake and green fried tomatoes, of course we went in to order. The food was amazing. My granddaughter love the atmosphere of the restaurant and so did I .She order a pizza that was the best she ever had. The food was so good, even the water was great. We will be back!“

“Christina G at the Olive Garden on Mineral Point Road in Madison WI was exceptional in getting us set up to accommodate a friend's gluten allergy on 9/20/26. Really appreciated the attention to details. Also want to point out the great job the person who initially helped us at the to-go counter did - I'm sorry I didn't remember her name...“

“Food was amazing and service was excellent!! Fresh and authentic homemade food.“

“We had heard some mixed reviews but dinner last night was perfect! The food was all done exceptionally well and service was fantastic. First time and had a great time. Looking forward to coming back and trying some new things! Salmon and broccolini tasted perfect and my dining partner enjoyed their steak and mashed potatoes. Thank you for the wonderful meal and the servers for being so lovely.“

“Danika is the most incredible server I've ever had at any restaurant including high end restaurants. She is attentive and warm during interactions. Made excellent personal recommendations, explained why, touched on their own personal experience. For the salad, provided a cold plate. For the bread sticks, made sure to grab some unexpectedly hot out of the oven, even though I hadn't ordered yet - for that extra touch. Before they first introduced themselves they were a little busy and let me know they'd be right with me after they returned from the kitchen. They also made sure to check on me during each course and communicated their availability if I needed anything.

Please provide this person all the raises and hours. They've hit on every part of a perfect experience.“

“Bunky’s is simply amazing! They catered our wedding 12 years ago. Authentic Mediterranean food, expertly prepared, with superb customer service... highly recommend!“

“I have to tell you this: some of the best pizza that I've had, I have to say, is even better than Salvatore's tomato pies. They're good, don't get me wrong, but the crust on these pizzas is amazing. The sauce is amazing.

Another thing: if they were to move to Kansas, specifically Kansas City, Wichita, Kansas, and Topeka, they would dominate Domino's, Papa John's, Little Caesars, and Pizza Hut. They would take them all out of business.

When I go home to Kansas, it's definitely going to be a disappointment when I go back to that pizza. I'm going to always think of Rocco's.“

“Mama Mia!!! This place is awesome!! I went in for lunch on a Saturday and received a warm greeting from their General Manager,Leo. They were able to seat me quickly and I was immediately welcomed by Carley. Carley has a great personality and took great care of me! The food and atmosphere all wonderful! I will definitely be back!“

“Beyond Fantastic Pizza. This was the ultimate! 5 Kazllion Chefs Kiss. Whoever prepared our pizza, literally breathed life into, REVIVED the original Gilman Street Rocky Rococo great taste, flavor, texture - experience. Took me back to that first taste of Rockys that surprised, confused and delighted our taste-buds simultaneously. Was Deleriously Delicious with a baked in hug. Outstanding culinary skill,.Best of the Absolute BEST!!!“

“The service was the best. Araceli was amazing server , help us with everything we need , the best GF menu I had so far .. I recommend this place very clean classy .. Barb the manager came and checked on us to make sure we had everything we needed .. very happy and I’m definitely going to be back soon“

“Always excellent pizza and sandwiches. we've never been disappointed. fun staff, Aubrey is very fun and an excellent waitperson. we love her! best pizza in Madison. highly recommended!“