35 Best Caterers near Wauwatosa

“We are beyond grateful for the incredible team at Gracious Events who brought our daughter’s wedding day to life with absolute perfection. From start to finish, they executed every detail of the day with absolute perfection. They handled everything—catering, florals, and event coordination, and did so with professionalism, creativity, and care. The communication throughout the planning process was exceptional. We had countless virtual meetings, a full menu tasting, and several on-location design meetings. Leading up to the big day, especially during the week of the wedding, the team was exceptional. We always felt informed, supported, and heard. Marija was an absolute dream to work with on florals and other design details. She listened so carefully to every detail we shared and brought our vision to life more beautifully than we could have imagined. The arrangements were breathtakingly stunning, fresh, and perfectly matched the style and atmosphere of the venue. Guests are still talking about how beautiful everything looked! As for the catering, it was flawless and also a highlight of the evening. The food was absolutely delicious, beautifully presented, and perfectly timed with the flow of the evening served right on time. Every member of the team was warm, attentive, and made us and our guests feel truly cared for. Guests raved about the delicious hors d'oeuvres, entree selections, and desserts! Bella was exceptional as our coordinator. Her communication throughout the planning process was spot on, and we felt completely supported every step of the way. She kept the rehearsal and wedding days running right on schedule and made sure no timeline detail was missed. Her communication with our vendors, wedding party, and families was clear, calm, and incredibly professional — every timeline was not only met but managed so smoothly that we were able to be fully present and enjoy the day without stress. It’s rare to find a company that excels in every aspect of a wedding, but Gracious Events truly did. Their attention to detail, impeccable organization, and warm, responsive communication made all the difference. They created a magical day for us to remember! We feel incredibly lucky to have had them as part of our daughter’s wedding day. Highly, highly recommend!“

“I have had catered lunches and grilled creations from Tall Guy a few times. Every time, the food was delicious.“

“I was part of a girls trip recently. we decided to buy some pot pies, Gouda, a couple quiches and dessert cakes from Larry's. Dale and Debbie were very helpful. All of us loved the pot pies! We tried 6 different flavors and they were all amazing. The flakiest crust! Breakfast was easy - just reheated the quiches. Gouda, crackers, chocolate and wine completed our menu. Thanks Larry's Market. If you haven't tried a pot pie or quiche yet, you should!“

“We had the best service with Saz's! From the first interaction with Katie, to picking our food at our tasting, to eating our meal at our Wedding - everything was perfect! Katie was so patient and accommodating with many of our dietary needs, both for the me (the bride) and for our guests. Not once did she make me feel bad and always made sure our questions were answered. At the wedding, the waitstaff was some of the best we've ever experienced. Everyone was so friendly, interacted with the guests, and helped in anyway they could. I have never experienced waitstaff like that at a wedding before and feel so grateful they were part of our day. I would recommend Saz's for ANY event you have!“

“We used Irene's for our wedding and the experience was great! They were reasonably priced, flexible, responsible, professional and the food was great! I would use them again in a heart beat“

“Brim Cafe and Catering is truly an all-star and gem of the Milwaukee Area. They have graciously donated to Children's Wisconsin's Miracle Marathon the past few years, and made sure dietary needs are met in a delicious and incredible way! The Mediterranean Catering menu is a true highlight, offering incredible flavor! Pair that with the incredible service Brim provides, and it turns into a match made in heaven! I cannot recommend enough!!“

“Absolutely phenomenal all the time! Genuine & amazing people!“

“The Saucy Swine catered my daughter’s wedding this weekend. The food was DIVINE! Great brisket and chicken, tangy sauces. The pickles were so fresh that I ate them as a cucumber salad! The delivery, set up, and takedown service was impeccable! All for a reasonable price! Thank you!“

“Timber’s catering was amazing start to finish. We knew at our tasting that they were the ones for us. They decorated and served an amazing buffet for our guests. Every guest told us how amazing the food was!“

“tried them a few times and have been impressed every time!“

“We had the pleasure of working with Maria and her team for our wedding, and we can’t rave enough about the incredible food and service! The spread she provided was nothing short of amazing. The skirt steak, al pastor, and soy chorizo (for our vegetarian and vegan guests) were to die for, and they were definitely the standouts of the meal. Our guests couldn’t stop talking about how delicious everything was, and many even asked if she had a restaurant where they could get more of her food!

The buffet line kept moving smoothly, and there was more than enough food for everyone. The Mexican rice, black beans, Mexican corn salad, and guacamole/salsa/chips were all fresh, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned. And the kids loved the mac n cheese.

Maria was a joy to work with from start to finish. The tasting process was fun and her communication was quick and responsive any time I sent her an email. She checked in with us before packing up, day-of, to make sure everything went well, which we really appreciated.

If you're looking for amazing food and a caterer who truly cares about making your event special, look no further than Maria and her team. She's a true Milwaukee gem, and we couldn’t recommend her enough. Thank you, Maria, for helping make our wedding day so unforgettable!“

“Wonderful atmosphere and delicious food. The wait staff was very friendly and accommodating. We will definitely be coming back and it was great place to take our grown daughter for her birthday.“

“Excellent customer service and the price was reasonable! The food was delicious and hot and delivered on time. I have no complaints. I will be using this catering service again and give recommendations. The guests were very pleased with their food. Excellent job Cash and Carry you met all my expectations!“

“10/10 Recommend Apple Spice!!! I have used Apple Spice weekly for the last 2 months. Their menu is so large and I haven’t ordered the same thing twice …. Yet! Their food is fresh and delicious! Their staff is friendly, on time, and very professional! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟“

“These things are amazing. Four bucks is not bad at all. The only thing is it’s a long way from Rochester Minnesota to West Elias Wisconsin so I’ll just pay the $10 shipping but I will go there someday promise“

“Fabulous Catering Service! I used Savory for a breakfast/lunch 2 day event in NY and due to the pandemic I was unable to fly there so had to do everything via email/text as I was in MN. The number of attendees kept changing and Alexis and her team were so amazing with updating the food and drinks and bringing more items over at the last minute. If you ever need TOP NOTCH catering that handle everything with WHITE GLOVE TREATMENT and so Courteous, you need to contact Savory!!“

“This place is awesome!! the owner is so sweet and I hope his cat is doing good!! Food and atmosphere was awesome. we traveled from racine just to visit this place and it was worth it!“

“We ordered dessert from Bishop’s Sweets for our 6th Annual Paintings for Pediatrics Gala, and they were an absolute hit! Our guests devoured every bite—many came back for seconds (and even thirds!). The treats were as beautiful as they were delicious, and the quality and flavor were incredible. Chef Shane was a pleasure to work with. We gave him a budget and he created the perfect dessert assortment that fit our event beautifully. Thank you to the Bishop’s Sweets team for helping make our event extra special. We’ll definitely be back for future events! 💛“

“Excelente servicio y trato“

“Bev makes it just like granny did, excellent quality, Wisconsin portions; all my guests are completely satisfied. Thank you Bev!“

“Delicious! 😋 The food was fresh, had amazing flavor and displayed beautifully.“

“My first time having the food. It was delicious and seasoned to perfection!“

“Ordered food for the first time from their service. Just to check. Oh my god...so pleasantly surprised. Such authentic and excellent tasting Pakistani food. Will definitely order again and other items. Loved them ! Keep up your consistency !!

P.S : Their serving size is amazing ! Plus they add complimentary items too !! So good !!!“

“A one stop outlet for all the meat lovers over the north western hemisphere. Not only for the meat but the store fulfils all the daily needs of an individual. Service people are too friendly and are present right at your service. Do visit once when driving past west hampton.“

“good food Nice price and decent service definitely going back“

“Food and staff is amazing. Definitely recommend carne con papas.“

“Nadi plates is incredible!! Nadia, Zachary and their team did a fantastic job with our wedding at Mercantile Hall. We had 116 guests and everything was cooked perfectly! Our guests were raving about how good the food was. We had filets and steak for our entree. They are a family run business and are so passionate about what they do. We could not have picked a more perfect caterer to do our wedding. I highly recommend them!! Thank you so much for everything!!

-Cayla & Brian

*photos from Corrina Nicole Photography“

“My husband and I had our wedding at South Second on Saturday and I can't say enough about the service from start to finish! Michelle was excellent to work with. She was very friendly, accommodating, and prompt with responses, including days she may not have been in the office. We worked with Katie on the day of our wedding and she was just as wonderful! Very friendly, accommodating, and efficient. We had our ceremony and reception at South Second and opted to have the guests sit at their tables during the ceremony with a few rows of chairs that lined the aisle for the ceremony. All of the service staff was just as friendly as Katie and Michelle. There was one gesture that says a lot to me as a venue and how much they really do cater to their customer and make sure they are having an spectacular time. Right as we were seated for dinner, the chef brought out a gorgeous board that contained 2 servings of all our appetizers that were served during cocktail hour. Such a small gesture, but so meaningful. The bartenders were amazing the whole night. Making sure to serve guests as quickly as possible, including remember some guests drink choices, which again, is such a small thing, but goes a long way. We received so many compliments on how gorgeous the venue was, how delicious the food was, and how kind and accommodating the staff were. I would recommend South Second to anyone who asked! Thank you for all you did for us, we had a perfect day and your services were a big part of making that possible.“

“We hosted our 6/7/2024 wedding rehearsal dinner at Indulge Event Venue. The space was perfect for our 25 person group for cocktails and buffet dinner. This venue allows for a more intimate, private event feel with high-quality service. We opted for their Italian catering menu and everything was delicious. We’d recommend for your next event!“

“Great food and atmosphere“

“just had Philly cheesesteak so good“

“Yvonne was our server, and the hostess and she was hustling. This is a really cool place where they are acrually teaching various aspects of running a restaurant i believe specifically to minorities.Food was great- jerk eggrolls, catfish, and my wife had a pulled pork bowl. Food was great, the whole experience was enjoyable!“

“Marco Pollo Cluck truck was a huge hit at my daughter’s graduation party! The food was amazing. Thank you for suggesting the smaller potions. My guests loved being able to try multiple different items. And those funnel cake fries, there are no words for how delicious those were! Couldn’t have been better. Thank you Marco Pollo I will recommend you to anyone looking for a food truck for s party.“

“2 weeks ago a young gentleman came to our workplace to drop of menus of your business. So we thought we'd give you a try. We had the seafood cheesesteak..it was excellent! The bread was soft and the sandwich as a whole had really good flavor. We definitely will be coming back..don't take that off the menu!!“