17 Best Sandwich Shops in Madison

“I cannot rave enough about “The Bomb” sandwich!! So delicious/flavorful! Yum! They are also very attentive and kind to their customers. Definitely earned this 5 ⭐️ review!!“

“I stepped out of rut (Original Deluxe) and ordered an Italian Calzone. Very different than any I’ve had (Oregon to Miami). You eat it like a sandwich. Plenty of meat, but desperately needed Ricotta, mushrooms and more onions. Well, back to the Original Deluxe.“

“🚨This is my go to Subway. The manager is so cool and professional. I have never came across an employee that was having a bad day. They seem to love working there. Rarely do I find a Subway with a 100 Health Score but this one had one. Everything is always so clean and bread and veggies are always fresh. Cookies are fresh too.“

“Last weekend, the manager at this location went out of his way to help me resolve an issue with placing an order in the app. He was incredibly attentive and welcoming, and I really appreciated that he recognized me as a regular. His level of customer service and hospitality truly made the experience stand out.“

“Chicken Salad Chick is a treasure, and you're gonna have to work REALLY hard to convince me otherwise. Their food is fresh and delicious, their serving sizes are generous, and their service is constantly delightful. These gals set a high bar for themselves, and constantly meet their challenge. The whole menu is solid, and several choices are superstars (the seasonal Maui Mama Melt is an excellent example. I have been several times and always leave happy and full!“

“I had such a great experience at Subway, and Mariah truly made it stand out! She was friendly, patient, attentive, and made sure everything was exactly how I wanted it. Her customer service was excellent, and you can tell she takes pride in making people feel welcome.“

“The best chicken salad in Huntsville. From the time I walked in to order the assistant manager was at terminal, she is very menu knowledgeable and pleasant. She recommended the Sassy Scotty for lunch. Absolutely amazing. Thanks again I will return soon.“

“Went this am on 2/3/2026, and let me tell you. The 3 ladies in there were So Professional, Courteous and Hospitable. While waiting for my 2 sandwiches, turkey sub and a chicken Khahunah, I was able to visibly see the cleanliness, attention to detail and making the Absolute Perfect sandwiches. The harmony was felt amongst them and the Absolute Flow is to be imitated by other restaurants. I will Absolutely go back. Thank you ladies. Wrong Store. Meant for 12008“

“They always make the bomb out of our sandwiches. The most consistent subway we’ve been to. But I’m leaving this review because when there was a creepy dude just squating in the corner outside for no reason - I asked the owner if he would watch me walk to my car and he personally walked me out to my car. Top tier dude.“

“Trell *sp., was so pleasant of a young man., great manners. And I saw him 1st hand have to save the day when someone took the wrong bag of food (I guess doordash) he made a couple jokes and got right on it to put the customer at ease. Also gave me a solid recommendation on the most meat sub the JJ..“

“Madison's best kept secret! Every time I go here, they are so incredibly nice. I can tell the owner really cares about customer service. The food is excellent and they don't skimp on ingredients. I ordered a cookie sandwich with my turkey original and they were both perfection!“

“I’ve been eating at Subways since the 80s. I don’t eat there much but have in many states and cities around the country. I’d challenge you to find a subway cleaner and more stocked. I was blown away when I walked in today to get a sandwich. I was the only customer in there at the time and the young woman on staff wasn’t playing on a phone or diddling her thumbs. She was cleaning. The pride of ownership was on full display. I’d definitely go back. Great job.“

“We ordered two trays online (1 toasted and 1 cold) thinking that “toasted” would be warm/steamed like in the restaurant. When I picked them up, the bread was toasted and then put in the cooler. When I explained what I had wanted, David was more than willing to accommodate me but told me I’d have to wait about 15 minutes. I totally understood that, but he insisted on giving me a gift card to make up for my wait. Cameron set about remaking the tray of subs using steamed meat and cheese! David and Cameron are two of the best!!! They kept apologizing about how long I had to wait. They were so quick to correct the order!“

“Phenomenal food! Great staff of young hard working students. Keep up the good work.“

“This subway is freaky fast and the workers engage with you like your family. The line was out the door and I was the last person in line. I looked down to check the time on my phone and the next thing I know I was eating my sub. They were beyond friendly and professional. I just wish the location wasn't so remote. My favorite artists are Carlos, Ced and Jordan! I don't know what their getting paid but I feel like their talents aren't being compensated enough. $⬆️“

“Love this firehouse! The employees have always been courteous and kind. I’ve never had someone be rude or have a bad tone here. They get my order right around 9/10 and if they don’t get it perfect it’s usually really close. Great team and gets my order done quick!“

“Came on 5/27/2026 and as ALWAYS they were exceptionally great! This the only place that can get my money when it comes to cheese steaks. Not only were they welcoming upon arrival (every single time), the store is always clean, even when they're busy and the cook is immaculate!!! They're all so sweet and I don't mind the wait IF I have to! IT'S WORTH EVERY SINGLE PENNY THAT I SPEND!!“