20 Best Sandwich Shops in Fayetteville

1 Hammontree's Grilled Cheese

4.5 Superb 457 Reviews

326 North West Avenue Suite 8, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Hammontree’s Grilled Cheese was definitely worth checking out! I ordered the Ozark Monte Cristo, and it was excellent. The combination of sweet and savory flavors worked really well together. At $13, I thought it was reasonably priced, especially considering the generous portion size. You definitely get your money’s worth. Overall, great food, good value, and a place I’d happily come back to!”

2 TJ's Sandwich Shop

4.4 Superb 293 Reviews

2992 North College Avenue, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“been here 2 different times both times food was good friendly people clean place”

3 Chicken Salad Chick

4.5 Superb 169 Reviews

352 East Joyce Boulevard Suite 5, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“This is the cutest place to take a friend to lunch. I ordered Lauryn’s Lemon Basil, Mac n cheese and a fruit cup. The meal came with a tiny Vanilla cookie. Staff is kind, and buss the tables. I saw staff cleaning. I like how you have to walk to the back of the restaurant to order, and then seat, as this layout prevents crowding. When I was eating I didn’t feel rushed, a rare feeling these days. Chicken Salad chick is a place where time slows down and you have the option to peacefully enjoy tasty chicken salad! Will be visiting again.”

4 Cheba Hut "Toasted" Subs

4.7 Superb 85 Reviews

1947 North College Avenue, Fayetteville

“Amazing food! Try those Sammies and Munchies!!”

5 Stone Mill Bread

4.2 Good 207 Reviews

2600 North Gregg Avenue, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Never eating fast food breakfast after trying this place. Great portions and prices plus the food is made with locally sourced fresh ingredients. yumm!!”

6 McAlister's Deli

4.1 Good 251 Reviews

4055 North Steele Boulevard, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Great place to eat at clean bathrooms clean place friendly people”

7 Jersey Mike's Subs

4.1 Good 121 Reviews

160 East Joyce Boulevard Suite 101, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I should have posted this earlier but life has been a bit hectic. On 12/1 my husband went in for an angiogram and the news wasn’t good. 3 veins were 90% blocked and his coronary artery was 99% blocked. They admitted him and did a 4 way bypass on 12/3. It was either the Friday or Saturday after that he didn’t care for the hospital food and requested Jersey Mike’s. I knew he wouldn’t eat much of it so no harm done and why not? Not to mention, I love Jersey Mike’s as well. The lady making our sandwiches asked what brought me in and when I told her what happened she said our order was taken care of and refused to let me pay for it. How great is that?! So grateful for the kindness that you showed and it will not be forgotten! God Bless!!”

8 Pickleman's Gourmet Cafe - Fayetteville, AR

4.0 Good 222 Reviews

410 West Dickson Street, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“great subs! never disappoint!”

9 Firehouse Subs Fayetteville

4.0 Good 196 Reviews

1364 East Augustine Lane Ste 2, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“This food was great! The people were friendly and I would totally go back!!! 😊”

10 Schlotzsky's Deli

3.9 Good 166 Reviews

2548 North College Avenue, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Spectacular Service, absolutely delicious sandwiches, Textures, and flavors are amazing. 10 years ago, I came into this very same shop and ordered a Pastrami on Black Russian Rye, with the works and cucumbers. From then on I would introduce anyone I was with to such a great mass of flavors. I return to this store 10 years later and they have pulled the rye bread out of the choices. I understand there is not much call for it with the younger generations. I compensated with sourdough which is every bit as amazing, or as I like to say, "Ahhhhmazing!" I had the opportunity to speak with an incredible and extremely professional person at the counter named Matthew. An outstanding employee to say the least. Very courteous and polite. The other gentleman in the back was a large man. He was speedy and pleasant as well as quickly accomodating as Matthew. I could not have asked for better service nor personalities. Outstanding. A pure pleasure to have met such fine people. I will gladly return. I will not wait 10 years to do so either. Thank you very much for the fine work gentlemen. Sincerely, C. Redline NRP”

11 Subway

3.7 Good 119 Reviews

2000 North Crossover Road, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“John made me a meatball sub today. He went above and beyond to make sure I was happy with my order. Wow was it delicious. The provolone cheese was melted perfectly over the meatballs. He also looked very professional and made every one of my needs met. Not to mention he is a very good looking worker. I will definitely be returning for that meat ball sub soon”

12 Subway

3.7 Good 153 Reviews

1680 North College Avenue Suite 7, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I have a crazy schedule and so I have stopped at this college location at all times of day and night. I just want to say that the 2 ladies I meet during the day I wish I got their names but they are super, the young lady Millie ( sorry if I misspelled your name) but she is such a joy! Such a positive person and just a delight to come in to after a long day! And Jared also has a great attitude!!! Props to this team and my food is always fresh and delicious!!!”

13 Subway

3.5 Good 51 Reviews

616 Garland Ave Suites 352 & 353, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“I frequently visit this Subway location because I work right down the street. I am always so impressed with how friendly, fast, and clean this location is. I always order using the app, and the staff remembers my order (and even remembers the flavor of cookie I get on occasion). Today, I ordered a sandwich for my boyfriend as well, who has multiple allergies, and the staff handed me my order letting me know they were extra careful in preparing the sandwich after they saw the note I put. I highly recommend this Subway over any other location in Fayetteville!”

14 Jimmy John's

3.6 Good 113 Reviews

3379 North College Avenue, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“Thank you JJ's of Fayetteville for the samples. #4 Turkey is delicious!”

15 Subway

3.5 Good 110 Reviews

121 West Township Street Suite 19 & 20, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“5/5 Stars – Great service from Dakota! Dakota was working the counter today and totally made my visit. Friendly greeting, listened carefully to my order, suggested a solid combo, and built a perfect sub—great portions, neat, toasted just right. He stayed upbeat and efficient even with a line, double-checked everything, and asked about sauces on the side. The sandwich was delicious, and his positive attitude made it even better. Dakota’s a standout—polite, fast, and clearly cares about the job. I’ll definitely be back when he’s working. Thanks, Dakota—you’re awesome! 🚀”

16 Firehouse Subs Fayetteville West

3.4 Good 219 Reviews

2612 M.L.K. Jr Boulevard, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“😀outstanding service hip atmosphere tasting menus”

17 Subway

3.2 Average 133 Reviews

1100-1250 M.L.K. Jr Boulevard, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Literally the cleanest Subway I have been in. While I was there one of the employees started cleaning when there were no orders to take! Super impressed with the care of their environment!Everything was clean, veggies were fresh, and the store was pretty big for ample seating. Service was amazing, and it was so nice to see a neat orderly sandwich shop. I could tell they cared about what they were making and the customer giving the order. Very convenient and close to all the athletic venues at University of Arkansas. Parents if you are there for a summer camp, swim meet, running competitions, this is a great spot to get something easy and head back to your kiddos!”

18 Jimmy John's

3.0 Average 116 Reviews

518 West Dickson Street, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery
• Drive-Through

“This place is a GODSEND!! I just came through with my niece for the first time and we hadn’t eaten here before. While having an extensive conversation with the employees about the menu, they were very patient, willing to answer all of my questions, and prepared to make any changes to the order to accommodate my financial needs. After it was all said and done, I was trying to figure out my online bank account and was having a hard time. After seeing my struggle, the employees offered to give us the food for free! It was truly and embarrassing moment, but that they were very understanding of my predicament. Without them, my niece and I would have been very hungry and helpless! PLEASE GIVE THESE PEOPLE A RAISE!! ????”

19 Loafin Joes

3.2 Average 217 Reviews

201 West Mountain Street, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We eat here about once a week, and it never disappoints! The food is consistently good, and the Smoke Joe is especially delicious. The chips are usually really good too! 😋 It has such a laid-back, relaxed atmosphere, and it’s just one of those places where you know you’re going to get a good meal every time. Definitely one of our favorite spots!”

20 Subway

3.1 Average 167 Reviews

3245 West Wedington Drive, Fayetteville

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“josephine and rian were the absolute best people i’ve ever had in the food industry! she definitely made my entire night in her personality to her making sure I got all I needed! If you ever want an absolute break from life and have a good laugh and convo and a great sandwich with the best sanitation and the sandwiches made with love, go see my girls!”