50 Best Italian Restaurants near Youngtown

“I have lost track of how many times we have been here since it opened. We have eaten the pizza, meatball appetizer with garlic bread, fish and chips, Caesar salad, garlic knots with marinara, plus a couple of the sandwiches. Everything has been delicious. Love this place.“

“Flora’s Salad was fresh, flavorful & great portion. The manager offered me a taste of their new upcoming kale-apple salad & it was fantastic!
The bakery has the best Italian Wedding cookies that I e had in a very long time! Great service in both restaurant & bakery!“

“We went to eat there last Saturday. Very good food, nice environment, friendly peoples and our server, Laura, over the top!!! Five stars!!. I can't wait to go again!!!“

“We just moved out to the area and the name caught us. The take out was quick. Zero hassles. Food was incredible. Will be a staple when we eat out. It was incredible. Chicken Masala was very good, although it had more of a sweet base than tasting the wine. Chicken Parm was great. Spaghetti and meatballs were very good. My daughter even loved the chicken tenders. Fries were VERY good. Bread was amazingly fresh. HIGH PRAISE TWISTED ITALIAN.“

“Our first visit...won't be our last, for sure! The best mussels this side of the Mississippi!!! Amazing, authentic bolognese...and the texture of the pasta, WOW!! Our waitress, Courtney, was outstanding...from carefully explaining specials to the attention she gave our party of 6 throughout dinner!💜“

“Like I told Ernesto today. It was a Complete pleasure eating at this establishment!“

“We had a surprise birthday dinner party for my husband and everything was terrific! Our server, Gina, handled about 25 people with efficiency, humor and grace. We all ordered off the menu and our meals were served promptly, hot and De-Lish! I would not hesitate to book my next party or just dinner at Lou's. By the way, I ordered the meatloaf special and it was perfect. Hubby had the fetticine with shrimp and loved it! Salads were fresh and crisp.“

“The food is delish and fresh. Friendly staff and quick service.“

“Assolutamente fantastico!! Never has there been an Italian restaurant that offered so many wonderful choices for just about any diet. Are you kidding me? Zoodles? Spaghetti Squash? This is also one of the few places left that still have angel hair pasta and they use deliciously perfect Roma tomatoes. No sugar added tomato sauce AND everything made in-house? Wow...that's about all I can say about this wonderful gem in the desert. Everything had taste bud pleasing flavor, portion sizes are perfect and at a very decent price. Not to mention service was perfect, immediate and very accommodating. Whether this was a lucky night for us, or the usual for this wonderful place, they have new fans that will back for more. There is a ton of variety to the menu which requires more visits to experience. Don't pass this place up! The only suggestion is the artichoke leaves could be a little more tender using the baby leaves only, however, they are delicious and worth a try.“

“This is my husband's favorite Italian restaurant...we decided to go to dinner tonight on Father's day. He's a fur dad...so it was just the two of us. When we walked in the lady, I don't know her name...I think she one of the owners...asked if we had a reservation. I said, No...I didn't even think about a reservation for today...but she fit us in and we had a wonderful dinner with great food, ice tea and service. THANK YOU PORTOFINO for fitting us in. It waa all delicious...I forgot to take a picture of our fried zucchini...very good too.“

“A few months ago, I ordered delivery from this location and I was mistakenly given the wrong order. This location went ABOVE AND BEYOND to fix this. By the time I noticed and gave them a call, an Olive Garden employee was already at my house with my correct order and told me to keep the incorrect one. They had already noticed the mistake a proactively fixed it. I love Olive Garden and this is a great one. Thank you!“

“The BEST spaghetti and meatballs I have ever had in any restaurant in the 21 yrs I’ve lived in AZ. I’m originally from NY and TRULY this was soooo good.😊 The tiramisu is the real deal! No kidding… can’t wait to try the rest of the menu. I had it delivered haven’t visited the restaurant YET.“

“We had such a lovely time. Food was amazing. We had the Godfather Pizza and Chicken Alfredo. Finished off with Canolli. So yummy. Service was excellent. We set on the patio. Perfect date spot.

Parking: Parking is available west of the restaurant but the lot is pretty tight. Street parking may be a better option for larger vehicles, when available.“

“tried it for the first time tonight, very nice staff with good recommendations. the good was great, will certainly be back to try more!“

“A quarter pounder hamburger $36.50 that can't be right must be a misprint for one hamburger and 1950 for a hamburger that's got to be another misprint“

“Sunday dinner was spectacular! Restrooms were clean and stocked well. The hostess was very polite and courteous making sure we sat in a Booth as requested. It was quite busy but we received the best service. Our server was on point! She was there whenever we needed her and didn't forget a thing. Amazing service and quality of food is superb. 💯🤩“

“Our first visit...won't be our last, for sure! The best mussels this side of the Mississippi!!! Amazing, authentic bolognese...and the texture of the pasta, WOW!! Our waitress, Courtney, was outstanding...from carefully explaining specials to the attention she gave our party of 6 throughout dinner!💜“

“My husband & I have been to Olive Garden Glendale many times in the past and always enjoyed the food, the ambiance, and the employees. This time we came to celebrate our 23rd anniversary and we were greeted by our server, Kiah. Best server ever! She was so attentive, very friendly, very professional, and really added to our experience. We laughed together - but she was also respectful of our celebration, and gave my husband & I space to enjoy the food and each other. Next time we come, we will certainly ask to be seated in her area. At the end of our meal, DJ, the General Manager, came by our table to make sure that we enjoyed the food. We sure did - but we also raved about Kiah. DJ was wonderful!, very friendly and appreciative. Thank you Kiah and DJ - you made us feel like royalty. Highly recommend Olive Garden Glendale. When you arrive, ask for Kiah! She will make certain that your experience is awesome.“

“Love this place, new favorite“

“Paulie’s is amazing the food, family, and fun! I will say the front desk hostess area is confusing and disorganized. My brother and mother love the food!“

“Normally I get the chicken marsala but I tried the filet as I have not had steak in a long time....bit too much seasonings for me. Will definitely go back to my regular. Service is always great too“

“Excellent!!! Love the outdoor dining option! Best Tiramisu!“

“short waiting line, great service , super food variety & delicious food....💥“

“We came to this location for the first time. My mom is looking to purchase a home in the area so we needed a food break and wanted to check out the shopping area. Ash was our server and everything was amazing. Super attentive and quick. My kids absolutely love Olive Garden so it’s great when we have an excellent experience.“

“Food is delicious! Service fast! Great server!“

“I've been here a few times now. Overall, I don't love it but I do like it and will keep occasionally going. Costs decent money, sometimes have to wait for no obvious reason, and I don't know what the system is but EVERY time I've been there the staff seemed confused. The 1st couple times no one knew whether we were being served or not, the last couple times it took fewer people to determine whether we were being served or not. But the food is good (I say as a non-Italian), and they've been nice. The last 2 times I remember going I got a calzone which was fairly big and good and had a decent amount of filling and was not doughy and an eggplant parmesan that I wish had a less minuscule piece of eggplant (or 2) but tasted really good. My friend got the Valducci (I think it was) twice and one of those times O M G it was a garlic farm, it overpowered the smell of my food from across the table. It was actually befitting of the stereotypes of French people. When Sharpe said to let them get close and hold your fire until you can smell the garlic (at distance on a battlefield over the burnt powder smoke in the air) he meant something like that dish. WOOOO!“

“Edel was phenomenal with the service. He was checking up on us constantly and making sure that our drinks were full and we always had enough breadsticks. He even offered to refill my soup which I didn’t know you could do. He was also very patient with us and he deserves employee of the month.“

“I did not eat inside but where i do order online I am always given quick and convenient service. I’ve gotten the Chicago deep dish many times but this most recent visit was by far the best. They had put light sauce as I ordered and the seasoning they used to top the pizza was a 10/10 it tasted so much better than every other time I’ve ordered the same pizza.I would definitely get it again.“

“First timer here !! My family and I just picked up our first order. and it was so delicious!!! The pizza was perfect, my family liked the bacon pizza the most but I enjoyed the pepperoni. The wings are delicious !!! We have found our new favorite pizza shop.. I almost forgot the staff is so kind. The restaurant is super clean and welcoming.“

“Just started going to Richie’s and I’ve had amazing service from these young ladies Mary and Hollie.“

“Fantastic pizza and awesome staff. Highly recommend.“

“This is not commentary on the food itself, but an issue that customers need to be aware of when ordering delivery. Many restaurants are doing this, and this is yet another...do NOT try to tip the delivery driver through them. They subcontract the services of people like Door Dash, and when a tip is added to the order the delivery driver will never see a dime. The restaurant KEEPS those tips. I always tip in cash myself, because multiple restaurant chains are doing this to drivers that end up making as low as $2.50 in TOTAL for bringing even a large entire catering order to someone. This exact scenario occurred with an order from this location.“

“Awesome job on the meatball sandwich! Great, friendly fast service!“

“Stayed at the Wigman and wanted a pizza. It was awesome! I would highly recommend“

“Down from IL for my graduation. Too bad I didn’t get pics of the pizza and wings, but damn it was so good! And when we came in for pickup, everyone was so nice to us and greeted us. Good food, great people, and service. Amazing job to this pizza joint. If I lived here this would be my spot!“

“Food and service was on point, the gentleman help us was very helpful and polite. Pizza and garlic cheese bread was delicious. 😋😋😋“

“First time here. Food was delicious!!! Will definitely be back!“

“I had one of their bowls where you got to choose the ingredients and it was amazing. I had the portobello mushrooms, the assorted mushrooms and the broccoli that was shredded instead of noodles. And also had the pasta marinara which was very good as well. Love the bread.“

“AMAZING pizza!! Everything was spot on and service was great!! Definitely my place to go.“

“I recently visited Glendale for a concert and ended up at Barro’s pizza. I was pleasantly surprised how good the food was. The cashier recommended a thin crust and the pizza was perfect!!! We had some medium wings that had the exact amount of sauce I look for. The chicken was nice and crispy, and the best part, I could tell the food was fresh. I would go again when in the area.“

“Professional, clean and good tasting food. Great for a quick lunch or nice dinner, definitely recommend.“

“Pizza specials are great for lunch. I love Barros pizza ?. This is from the sub sandwiches, to the pizza lunch specials pizza, salad and a drink, to the amazing whole pizzas it's a favorite. I'll get photos next time. Staff was friendly.“

“One of my favorite Barros..... One thing that sucks is don't get there an hour and half before they close some nights its packed and they shut down sections of the store and will NOT let people eat in there they seem more worried on getting the store closed tight on the money“

“great waitress, food and neighborhood atmosphere“

“Went there on our second date and been there many times since. This place I recommend them to everyone.“

“Went again today, new server Zeb waited on us, exceptional human being. Did a great job, made one minor error and CLAIMED IT, didn’t try to blame anyone else and totally the kind of person you want waiting on you and working for your business! Three cheers for integrity in the year 2025, who’d a thunk it?!!? Thanks again Zeb for taking care of us, see you guys again soon!

Awesome family owned (and staffed) pizza and pasta with exceptional service, great food and reasonable prices! Have never left there disappointed, but always taking some of my food home, because the portions are great and well worth reheating the next day!“

“We've picked up Spaghetti, Meatballs (which are a very good size!) and Garlic bread (for 4) several times since they opened. Very tasty and extremely convenient when you're trying to decide what to do for dinner... Staff service as excellent!“

“It is the quintessential neighborhood Italian Bistro! The owners are awesome and the food get's the MAMA's HOUSE" badge! service is always friendly!“

“Our party of 18 people dined at this establishment last night. The food was exceptional, and the service was even better. Thank you to Mary and Clayton for the excellent service. Thank you to the hostess and manager for accommodating our party on short notice. What a great meal and experience! Highly recommended.“

“Venturing into Streets of NY Pizza at 67th Ave and Deer Valley was an absolute delight! From the moment I stepped in, the warmth and attentiveness of the staff made me feel right at home and I am not even from New York!!!

Each dish we ordered was a delicious treat that spoke to the authentic New York-style pizza experience, with the New York Combo Pizza and Baked New York Chicken Wings stealing the show with their robust flavors and fresh, high-quality ingredients.

I loves all the pizzas!!!

It’s rare to find a place that hits the mark on both ambiance and culinary excellence, but Streets of NY Pizza does just that. It’s clear this spot holds the secret recipe to not just great food, but a fantastic dining experience. I’m already looking forward to my next visit!“