50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Youngtown

“I have lost track of how many times we have been here since it opened. We have eaten the pizza, meatball appetizer with garlic bread, fish and chips, Caesar salad, garlic knots with marinara, plus a couple of the sandwiches. Everything has been delicious. Love this place.“

“Great place. Love Little Deb!“

“Pizza is yummy and sandwich’s are delicious! You will feel like family when you are there. Thank you for supporting Liberty Lions.“

“Great New York style pizza.Best in the valley.“

“Amazing pizza and great service! The crust was perfectly crispy, the toppings were fresh, and the flavors were on point. The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the atmosphere was clean and comfortable. Definitely a place I’ll be coming back to!!!! 👍🏼“

“This was our first time ordering from Papa Murphy's and we'll definitely be back. We ordered the cowboy pizza minus the olives and it was made correctly and on time. When I walked in I wasn't sure where to pick up the pizza, but the staff helped direct me to the right place. It was really busy since it was Christmas Eve but staff was welcoming and helpful. The pizza was delicious too!!“

“I was just here a couple days ago on a Tuesday night service was amazing food was amazing
Me and my sons got gelato and they wanted to try a bunch of different flavors the young man behind the counter was extremely nice respectful and wanted to help us as much as we could he also got us are food and came back and checked on us a few times very much will be coming back!!!“

“Great food and friendly faces“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5-Star Review
Mike’s Market is one of those true hidden gems that you almost don’t want to tell people about but it’s just too good not to share. From the moment I walked in, the vibe was welcoming and friendly, the kind of place where you can tell they genuinely care about their customers 😊👏
We ordered the garlic cheese pizza, and wow… absolutely incredible 🍕🧄🧀 The crust was perfectly cooked, not too thick and not too thin, with just the right balance of crunch and softness. The garlic flavor was bold but not overpowering, the cheese was melty and generous, and every slice tasted fresh and made with care. A large pizza easily fed four adults, and everyone was full and happy, which says a lot about the portion size and value.
What really stood out, besides the food, was how super nice and accommodating the staff was. Friendly service like that makes you want to come back again and again. This place is close to a friend’s house, and after this experience, it’s officially going to be a regular stop. If you’re anywhere near Peoria and want amazing pizza, great portions, fair prices, and awesome people, do yourself a favor and check this place out. You won’t regret it 😄🔥🍕“

“Truly Chicago tavern style.“

“These boys at Luckys’s pizza in surprise were so precious! they made sure my food was all there, interacted with Ellyott and were so polite and adorable!!! Food was delicious but the customer service is why i’ll return 😍“

“Awesome job on the meatball sandwich! Great, friendly fast service!“

“The Calzone is excellent. We ate there three times in the span of a couple of weeks while in AZ“

“This is not a sit down restaurant but just a pickup shop. I had hone in just wanting a slice or two but they only did full pies. I was ok with getting a large pie (leftovers!). The pizza was great but I was just not crazy about them tavern cutting it instaed of the traditional slices.“

“Great option in the Central Valley! Just moved to Glendale from N Phoenix and wanted a closer option. This definitely hit the spot! Quick delivery via third party delivery service and the pizza was awesome! Thanks Lucky’s!“

“Friendly staff and great food. Did not expect such large salads and took home half of a medium pizza.“

“NY supreme is so good, so good !! ! best in the west ! Must try 🍕 in PHX!!“

“Professional, clean and good tasting food. Great for a quick lunch or nice dinner, definitely recommend.“

“been coming here for years love the pizza 🍕 great pizza wings and more“

“Great food & friendly staff … we went after it was featured on Good Morning Arizona TV program“

“Our pizza was great! I was thrilled to see a dairy free option for my lactose intolerant little man and the dairy free cheese was actually good!!! My daughter who usually claims she doesnt Like Papa Murphys said this location makes way better pizza than the one on 59th that closed! The employee was very friendly and my order was ready when I arrived! We are so happy this location is still open and still somewhat close to us, and worth the drive!“

“Ordered pizza and wings last week and STILL thinking about it! You KNOW when it’s good cheese!!! 🧀 My son and I were truly WOW’d, SOOO good!!! Do yourself a favor and get the garlic crust!! Keep up the great work!!! 🍕🥰“

“we have been out here in AZ for 16 years from Chicago. there is no other pizza we choose Deno's is the place. Never scrimps. Great sausage, only thin crust no other crust choices , thin crust cut in squares, the real way. their beef sandwiches are great ,piled high with lots of beef get more gravy on the side. Fries, ex excellent.. they are the real deal. have small dining area tables, go up and order your food they bring to you. self serve soda, you can also byob here. been going here many years , down home real chi pizza. no other crust offered here,they only make the thin crust piled high . eat in or pick up. not sure if door dash or others . this is the local treasure.“

“was like a real East Coast pizza.“

“Wowwww 🤩 i haven't had a deep dish this good in a long time! My friend told me about this place and i am sooo excited that she was right about the buttery crispy crust on the 4 corner pizza 😋😋 i took photos of the side and bottom so you can see how delicious it is and come here to try it for yourself 😎❤️ the cinnamon bread was sooo good too 😋😋❤️ the staff were friendly and helpful 😎❤️ i only gave 4 stars because we thought this was a dine in place but its not its a take out place 👎 they have some seating outside but we really wanted to enjoy indoor seating . So just remember, delicious food but take out only .“

“Your kids will love the pizza here! Great outside patio and amazing, kind employees. My hands were getting full with my little one, they came out to the patio and set up our food while I took care of mommy duties!! Thank you all your the best 🩶“

“I love Pizza Hut and it’s always so clean and welcoming whenever I visit one. I always appreciate having a place to sit even if the restaurant is smaller. Highly recommend visiting this one! They have a very diverse group of workers 🏳️‍🌈:)“

“Stayed at the Wigman and wanted a pizza. It was awesome! I would highly recommend“

“Great food the pizza was some of the best I’ve had in a long time customer service was great everybody was super friendly and helpful! Shout out To Brother Naim for the upgrade anf great conversation I’ll definitely be a repeat customer.. on another note this restaurant has no pork on the menu!“

“Pizza Star is the best .“

“Fantastic pizza and awesome staff. Highly recommend.“

“They served my husband and I are food and it was about another 30 minutes before we got our granddaughter's Pizza and of course she was irritable for a 3-year-old not to be able to eat and she didn't want anything else but her pizza that she picked out so it was not a good experience“

“This is not commentary on the food itself, but an issue that customers need to be aware of when ordering delivery. Many restaurants are doing this, and this is yet another...do NOT try to tip the delivery driver through them. They subcontract the services of people like Door Dash, and when a tip is added to the order the delivery driver will never see a dime. The restaurant KEEPS those tips. I always tip in cash myself, because multiple restaurant chains are doing this to drivers that end up making as low as $2.50 in TOTAL for bringing even a large entire catering order to someone. This exact scenario occurred with an order from this location.“

“In my opinion this might be the best location for consistency, in all the years I have come to this establishment they have always been excellent in service and food quality. I truly have nothing negative to say about this location. Keep it up guy's.“

“Our Cowboy Pizza was really good.
But, I had to go to Estrella to get it.We live near Millenium High. Our Avondale location was closed by the owner. Our call to order was auto fwd to Estrella. This is a big difference in time spent to do business with Papa Murphy's. Don't see a second effort anytime soon.“

“We live nearby, so we go to Barro's on McDowell in Goodyear quite often. Both, my husband and I love their pizza, and I usually order wings . I can't consume a full order of wings, so I take the rest home. Lately the wings have been VERY dry . They are NOT as good as they used to be. Are they pre-cooked nowadays ? They taste even worse the next day when I try to reheat them (not in the microwave). :(“

“Love this place! I take friends and family here when they come to town and want an amazing experience and great pizza 🙌“

“Best Gluten-free pizza I’ve had! I’m from the Chicago area and was visiting my sister in AZ, so we had the opportunity to try “Old Chicago” last Friday evening. There was a 35 minute wait. Totally worth the wait! We were seated within the time frame designated. All the staff were friendly and Brandy and Patti were awesome servers! Very personable and attentive. Our table split a big chicken salad, then enjoyed the Tavern Thin Pizza and I had the GF pizza. It really was the best GF crust I’ve had. We did end up taking most of the pizza home to enjoy the next day. Food was great, as was the atmosphere. Very clean. It’s understandable why there is a crowd. Would love to come back here!“

“Great team!! Excellent service“

“We are new to Surprise and spent some time trying different pizza places around town. And this place has the best thin crust (east coast style) hands down. Crust, sauce and toppings are fresh and delicious. Definitely worth checking out!“

“Very good pizza, the wings are outstanding and the sauce is amazing, and when you ask for extra sauce on wings they actually give you it. Staff is very friendly and always greet you when you visit. I highly recommend this place.“

“Food was yummy, portions were generous. Great service by Andy!“

“I stopped in while I was in the area for Sunday Breakfast. What a great decision. Great food. Waitress, Shandra, was very knowledgeable, fun and efficient. I’ll definitely be returning!“

“Great place to get a slice of pizza, salad and chicken wings with a few $$. The staffs are super friendly, the place is clean, there are plenty of chairs to sit.“

“Best decision I’ve made today. I was out by Surprise and wanted pizza. Pizza is a safe food during this pregnancy. So glad I came here. The BEST pizza crust ever. Everything was made to order and fresh. Atmosphere is chill and low key. If I’m ever in this area again I am stopping in for sure.“

“I had the thin crust cheese pizza yesterday. It was excellent, as well as the service. Thank You Florencias.“

“Food and service was on point, the gentleman help us was very helpful and polite. Pizza and garlic cheese bread was delicious. 😋😋😋“

“Love coming here its such a lively place. People talking and having a great time. It can get a little loud at times. They have trivia night which is super fun.food never disappoints and the service is super great. Even though the waitresses have so much going on they always circle around to make sure we are still doing good.“

“You all did it, great job. You can taste the food quality, pizza ingredients are obviously top quality and fresh, the wings slide right off the bone, perfect. Wish we would have tried this place years ago, you really gotta get your name out there. All I'm saying is, Tailgaters lost a customer today, for good. Tailgaters service is rude, ignores you, and doesn't care; food is mediocre at best. Uncle Sams, fast, friendly, delicious. You just got a new regular.“

“I love this place!“