Cataldo's Pizzeria
$ • Pizza, VegetarianAbout Cataldo's Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
Chilli Verde Pizza and Breadsticks
The New York City
Cataldo's Salad
Antipasto Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Specialty Pizza
Medium Calzone
Chicken Wings
Fried Chicken
Garlic Butter
Cataldo's Pizzeria Reviews
186 ratings
Share your opinion about Cataldo's Pizzeria
good good pizza the best
Cataldo's is my go-to. I love NY style and their butter herb crust stands out from other pizza places. The cheesy bread sticks are also yummy. Yes, the wait times are long during busy hours, but keep that in mind ahead of time and it'll be worth the wait.
My partner ordered us delivery for last week; I often request it as a treat for a hard day which I was having. He added a cannoli to the order as a surprise for me. The cannoli was missing from the order when it all arrived,...read full review
My partner ordered us delivery for last week; I often request it as a treat for a hard day which I was having. He added a cannoli to the order as a surprise for me. The cannoli was missing from the order when it all arrived,...read full review
Still loving this place, it's food, and their staff. Extra kudos to Izzy. I do, however, wish they still had a pool table.
Hours
| Monday | 4 - 8PM |
| Tuesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 11AM - 9PM |
Cataldo's Pizzeria offers the best pizza in town, loved by both kids and adults. Customers praise the Chicken with mushrooms, Pepperoni, and meatballs dishes. While some were disappointed with the Cannoli, the delicious food and excellent service make it a top choice for families. The accommodating staff ensures a pleasant dining experience. Despite occasional mix-ups in orders, the dedication to customer satisfaction shines through at Cataldo's. The food is absolutely delicious, with the Paisano Pizza Sub being a standout menu item. Customers also enjoy the mozzarella sticks and the giant pizza, which is perfect for parties. Cataldo's is a hidden gem that deserves the high praise it has received.