30 Best Pizza Restaurants near Carmel By The Sea

“Top 3 pizzas of our lives (including Rome and Florence). They make the ingredients in-house and you can tell.

You can also tell how happy their staff must be because it shows in the service and how they interact with you with warmth and affection.

Get their burrata pizza. You can taste the freakin milk.“

“Always amazing. Great food and service. 👏🏼 my favorite“

“Delicious pizza & drinks.“

“Mini combo was Yummy!“

“Great service, great ambiance, great food!“

“Love the BLTA. Need a quick lunch or snack? This is the place. Only reasonable prices in Carmel.“

“Huuuge thank you to my server Molly. You never know what people are going through & your kindness was on point. This world needs more people like you. Even though I ate alone, (on my lunch break), you made me feel welcomed and comfortable. Your positive attitude and smile will take you far in life, keep up the good work. May God continue to bless you always. The food was amazing and the atmosphere was great. I can't wait to go back and take my family. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We had a great meal last night and wonderful service with Bryan! Our lasagna and pizza were fantastic.“

“Awesomeness overload great pies“

“We always have a pizza at Gianni's whenever we're in town! Love the veggie pizza and breadsticks😍“

“We have been going to Heirloom Pizza a few times a year for a while now and have always enjoyed great food and good service. This was until last night. The food was still delicious and the server was good. That was the limit of a good experience. The hostess had a look that we were bothering her by wanting to eat there. We arrived about 7pm and they were busy, but it only took about 10 minutes to be seated. We ordered fairly quickly and then waited for over 50 minutes to have an appetizer to reach our table and another 25 minutes for our main dish. By the time we received our appetizer the restaurant had only 5-6 tables with people still sitting. We understand that it takes a little longer for a deep dish pizza, but well over an hour in unacceptable. In the 50 minutes we saw no less than a dozen or so orders go out the door for pickup orders. I understand they sell pizza and there is likely a large amount of business that doesn't come an stay to eat, but we felt forgotten. If we choose to go back, maybe we should order before arriving.“

“I love their Combo pizza. 🍕 Great food and service. Keith is the best.“

“Lots of dishes with different mushrooms 😄“

“This is honestly the best pizza in Monterey, everything’s really balanced and it’s worth the price. I got the curry veggie pizza, it’s the perfect blend of Indian food and pizza! I don’t know how to explain to you in words how good this is. It put my faith back in pizza.

Dietary restrictions: The curry veggie is vegetarian, I didn’t ask if the cheese was vegan.“

“Don’t let the outside fool you… it’s a charming little Italian feel inside with the sweetest hospitality (young woman with butterfly tattoo/hat was extremely caring about her job and the customers).we were going to order “to go” but it was so quaint inside we decided to stay. The best part was the food! The calzone was the perfect texture of cooked dough, thick cheese, perfect sauce and overall just melted in my mouth with goodness! Also got a fresh salad and a barbecue chicken flatbread which were just as rave worthy! It was nice to step away from the busy Cannery Row vibe to enjoy a great meal experience. Wishing I was a local to enjoy never ending chances at good Italian food!“

“Take out best pizza 🍕 trust me 🇮🇹“

“If you’re looking for a pizza spot that absolutely knocks it out of the park, this is it. From the moment we walked in, the staff was incredibly friendly, welcoming, and genuinely excited to help us pick out what to try. You can tell they really care about their customers and their food.
The menu had so many amazing sounding options that we couldn’t decide… so we didn’t, we ordered three different pizzas and I’m so glad we did! Every single one was fantastic.

The Sophia was a dream if you love white sauce pizza — creamy, flavorful, and perfectly balanced without being too heavy. The Golden State was one of the most unique pizzas I’ve had in the best way possible. Every bite had something interesting going on and who knew pizza and potatoes just work so well together.
But the absolute star for me was the special “La Bomba.” WOW. The Calabrian chili gave it the perfect kick and depth of flavor. It was bold, a little spicy, and completely addictive. I would honestly come back time and time again just for that pizza alone.
They have a unique crust was perfectly cooked crispy on the outside, soft and chewy inside — and you can tell they use high quality ingredients. Everything tasted fresh and thoughtfully put together, not just thrown on a pie.
The place itself has a great vibe, good service, and the staff makes the whole experience feel welcoming and fun. Whether you’re dining in with friends or grabbing a pizza to go, this place checks every box: great service, creative menu, amazing flavor, and pizza you’ll be thinking about long after you leave.
Already looking forward to our next visit! 🍕🔥“

“Beautiful restaurant absolutely wonderful service, wait time wasn't too bad and the food was soooo amazing and filling !! a must try if you're in the area“

“I stopped in around 9 PM and had a great experience. The owner was professional, and they honored the Entertainment coupon without any issues. I loved the atmosphere; it’s a perfect mix of pizza parlor and sports bar. It was clean, comfortable, and ideal for hanging out with friends, catching a game, and enjoying a drink. The separate 21+ bar area was a nice touch, and they even had a play area for kids. Of all the Mountain Mike’s I’ve visited, this location stood out as one of the best. Five stars!“

“Attention Mod pizza lovers, this is the same concept where they build a pizza in front of you, but the crust is even better because it is structured and yummy. Immediately upon stepping in, we were greeted with multiple hellos and welcome in’s- that always makes an experience better from the start! After they had put my pizza in the oven, I realized I hadn’t added the crushed garlic and I briefly mentioned it to my boyfriend next to me. The employee heard me and immediately offered to add it and insisted on it which was so kind. As for the pizza, it was delicious- I had a vegetarian pizza, the roasted broccoli topping is the best. The bathrooms were impeccable which made for an overall great experience (p.s. to the girls: there is no mirror!). One of the best parts was the design of the place, as well as the atmosphere. The tall ceiling and windows made the space roomy and “fresh”. The chill indie beachy guitar music made us feel like we were relaxing by the beach as we watched the sun set through the large windows. As for the seating, there are many option. My favorite were the booth tables because there was a comfy back rest (pictured) and were clean. Shout out to the 7pm crew for being friendly, hardworking, and overall great workers!“

“Best pizza we’ve had hands down. Family owned, cooked fresh, and it just hits better than anything. We make a point to come here when we’re in Monterey and I’d encourage everyone to do the same!!!“

“We enjoyed a delicious lunch. Everyone enjoyed their food and the restaurant has a nice ambiance.“

“MidiCi is absolutely fantastic. We got two pizzas and the meatball appetizer. Everything was great. The only reason we didn't finish the pizzas there was because we didn't want to look like pigs. You will not be disappointed coming here!“

“I go for the lunch buffet. The salad bar is well maintained and they have a good daily selection of pizza, though they seem to go with a lot of �.“

“Enjoyed the company, food, and atmosphere 😊“

“I always love stopping at California Pizza Kitchen in Monterey whenever I’m in the area. Their Hawaiian pizza is absolutely amazing—the crust is perfect, and the ingredients are always fresh and delicious. They also have a wide selection of drinks, and their pastas and salads are just as incredible.

One of my favorite things is their lunch special—pizza and a salad combo. It’s such a great deal and never disappoints. The service is truly wonderful; everyone is so friendly and welcoming. Daniella, Amelia, and the busser Juan are absolutely amazing and always make you feel right at home.

I would highly recommend California Pizza Kitchen in Monterey to anyone looking for great food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere. 🍕✨“

“This was such a pleasant experience. My son and I have gone to a different Mountain Mike's that's closer to our house. But this location is so much brighter, cleaner, and more open. The salad bar and pizza buffet areas are clean and plentiful. No question this will be our go-to location from now on!“

“Great way to start a retirement in this beautiful setting! Great wine and food- the views equally as amazing!“

“Warm, down to earth, atmosphere. A hidden gem. Love their pizzas' Great for big parties of people or to pop in by yourself. I have always had wonderful, attentive, and authentic service. The food is plentiful and good! Ask for Rima, she will take care of you!“

“Generally quite good. Atmosphere was pleasant and relaxing. Service was quick and accurate.I had the meatball sandwich with sweet potato fries for lunch. Lots of favorable meatballs, cheese and the marinara sauce was interesting without being too hot as many are now. Sweet Potato fries were not overcooked or over salted.

Almost empty for lunch but I expect that they bring in a good dinner crowd with all of the beer selections. I did not try any.

Only two negatives. The iced tea was off. It had a heavy taste as if the water had too many minerals. And the prices are just a bit too high. There are meals as good in the same area for less.

But I will go back. The pleasant, relaxing almost empty atmosphere will sometimes be worth the extra money!“