19 Best American Restaurants in Eureka

“So glad they are open for dinner again! They have tasty food, wonderful staff, and an awesome manger/owner!“

“excellent service excellent food amazing hospitality and atmosphere is awesome“

“Super clean, which is a rarity these days! Also, wonderful breakfast, fast and friendly service. Love it here!“

“What a night! On vacation in Eureka, we asked a local at the dog park for a dining recommendation. Our server was Jake, and he performed quite well. Old Town Eureka was prepped for the Christmas walk, parking was free, and it was unseasonably warm.

Polenta crostini.

Arancini stuffed with butternut squash risotto.

Brussels sprouts.

Wood-fired hen with fingerling potatoes.
Grilled steelhead with lobster risotto.

Chocolate torte with s’mores topping.

My lady enjoyed the prosecco, and I the Lagunitas IPN/A.“

“We got a take-away pizza and salad from here while passing through town. Both were top tier! Pizza had the classic wood-fired oven char, and the toppings and flavor were as good as it gets! I’d count myself (for whatever that is worth haha) into the pizza connoisseur bucket, and I’m telling you, this pizza is about as good as you’ll find. The house salad also was the right blend of greens and other veggies, with a tasty house dressing.

Don’t skip this place! Again, top tier.“

“The service and food were both excellent this evening! I was especially looking forward to a good ribeye steak, unfortunately due to a shipment mixup there were no ribeye. However, they upgraded my dinner to a mouth-watering filet at no charge. Needless to say, I was not disappointed! We also got the rack of lamb and the table-side ceaser salad. Everything was excellent, and I can't wait to come here again!“

“Best banana split around, and I had 3 in the week we visited.
We didn't eat any other foods so thats the reason for 4 stars instead of 5. Its an old drive in restaurant and half the seating is outside with no shade. There are a few small tables and a countertop bar inside but there's no AC so it can be hot. I enjoyed looking at the model car collection in the windows while we waited for our ice cream.“

“What an amazing experience top notch food and service“

“Eureka’s Ultimate BBQ Experience – Shamus T Bones Sets the Standard for Unforgettable Dining on the Redwood coast. If you’re searching for the heart and soul of Eureka’s culinary scene, look no further than Shamus T Bones. This legendary eatery is more than just a restaurant; it’s a destination where flavor, atmosphere, and local charm collide in the most spectacular way possible. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Shamus T Bones is a must-visit, and here’s why. **A BBQ Paradise:** From the moment you step inside, the rich, smoky aroma of slow-cooked meats hits you like a warm embrace. Shamus T Bones is all about delivering the kind of BBQ that dreams are made of—think tender, fall-off-the-bone ribs, succulent brisket, and pulled pork so flavorful it almost melts in your mouth. Their house-made BBQ sauces add the perfect finishing touch, whether you prefer sweet, tangy, or spicy. And let’s not forget the legendary tri-tip, grilled to perfection and bursting with that authentic, smoky flavor that keeps you coming back for more. **More Than Just Meat:** While Shamus T Bones is a carnivore’s paradise, vegetarians won’t feel left out. Their menu includes hearty salads, delicious veggie burgers, and sides that are as satisfying as they are tasty. The grilled vegetables, loaded baked potatoes, and crispy onion rings are just a few of the options that make this spot accessible and enjoyable for everyone. **The Atmosphere:** Step into Shamus T Bones, and you’re greeted by a space that’s as warm and inviting as it is unique. Rustic wood, dim lighting, and the flicker of an open hearth create a cozy vibe that’s perfect for any occasion, whether it’s a casual night out or a special celebration. The expansive windows offer panoramic views of the surrounding landscape, adding to the restaurant’s charm and making every meal feel like a mini-getaway. **Service With a Smile:** The staff at Shamus T Bones are true professionals. They’re knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive, ensuring that your dining experience is top-notch from start to finish. Whether you need a recommendation, have dietary restrictions, or just want to chat about the best dishes, they’re more than happy to make your visit unforgettable. **Family-Friendly Fun:** Bringing the kids? Shamus T Bones has you covered. The restaurant is incredibly family-friendly, offering a kids’ menu packed with tasty options that little ones will love. The relaxed atmosphere means parents can unwind while the kids enjoy their meals—and maybe even sneak in a game of cornhole outside. **Accessibility Matters:** Shamus T Bones is fully wheelchair accessible, making it an inclusive dining option for everyone. The spacious layout ensures that all guests can move around comfortably, and the staff is always on hand to assist with any special needs. **An Unforgettable Experience:** In a town that’s known for its natural beauty and laid-back vibe, Shamus T Bones stands out as a culinary landmark. It’s the kind of place where you create memories over shared plates of incredible food, where the atmosphere is just as much a part of the experience as the meal itself. Whether you’re here for a quick bite or a leisurely dinner, Shamus T Bones delivers in every way possible. If you haven’t experienced Shamus T Bones yet, you’re missing out on one of Eureka’s true treasures. Come for the BBQ, stay for the atmosphere, and leave with a satisfied appetite and a smile on your face. This is more than just dining—it’s an experience you’ll be talking about long after the last bite. Check out Redwood Reef 707“

“This place is amazing’ I highly recommend it!“

“great experience right from the door. hostess was friendly, server was attentive, and the food was tasty. would recommend.“

“the quality of the locally sourced food is impressive. I am lucky enough to work at Cafe Nooners. I have never experienced a more positive work environment nor felt as welcome as I have here since day one. There's good reason this Cafe has been so successful for so long. The tri-tip sandwich is my favorite, but I find I enjoy their vegan dishes almost as much. Try the chocolate chip cookies made fresh from scratch!“

“Lamb Shanks, Dungeness Crab Benedict.“

“Had an excellent time at the Applebees. Our server, William, was extremely attentive and kind even on a busy night when other guests seem to be giving him a hard time for little to no reason! How crazy. The food was well done and brought extremely fast. I’d recommend this establishment to anybody and highly recommend Will as your server if you get a chance!“

“Never leave reviews but boy the food here was amazing. Travelling from Australia and the beers have to be the best I’ve had in the states. Shouts to my boy Marco who was killing it with his service, give my man a raise or something because he works his a** off. Much love“

“Great view“

“I love eating here. The cost and portions are great. The lunch specials are a really good deal. I've tried so many things on the menu now that I'm not going to list everything that I love, because its everything I've tried. Can't pick a favorite item. Today we had a big order and when we got home we were missing an item. we went back and they were apologetic and nice. they even through in an extra item as an apology without us even having to ask. That's good business!“

“I just can’t get enough Cadillac burrito. Minus cream cheese. Extra jalapeño, coleslaw and spicy Kansas bbq.“

“This place was just exactly what I needed after getting off the road after 26 hours. The bacon temptation omelette was sublime. My partner loved her steak.

I get it. It's IHOP not a five star Michelin restaurant. But they do what they do and they do it incredibly well.

Also the staff were super friendly to us as out-of-towners. Special thank you to Julie!!

If you're coming off the highway and need a place for a better-than-decent breakfast, give this location a shot.“