Marcello's Pizza
$ • Pizza, Salad, Gluten-FreeAbout Marcello's Pizza
Customers' Favorites
Pesto and Spinach Pizza Slice
Pepperoni Sicilian Slice
Oven Baked Sandwiches
Pizza by the Slice
Garlic Bread
Whole Pizzas
Cheese Pizza
Pesto Pizza
Meat Combo
Still
Marcello's Pizza Reviews
214 ratings
Share your opinion about Marcello's Pizza
I love Marcello's Pizza in the Castro, just down the hill from where I live. Their pizza is delicious. I love the crust and marinara. My favorite toppings are mushrooms, artichoke hearts, and pepperoni. Sometimes I splurge and add pepperoncini. They also have a lot of other toppings. They deliver. I bake my own too. So, I am very picky. They make good pies - especially when the crust is kind of bubbly. I like to order a family size pie for left overs over a few days....read full review
The best pizza in town. Small sit down and go restaurant. They have Sicilian pizza (deep dish) and calzones.
I want to give this 5 stars but that's probably wouldn't be fair because this place brings back childhood memories so I don't know if that extra star is nostalgia or not. This pizza taste how pizza used to 20 years ago when we had actual delivery from the pizza place staff itself. I don't even know how yo explain it but pizza today seems very uniform regardless of where you get it from.
Hours
| Monday | 11:45AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 11:45AM - 11PM |
| Wednesday | 11:45AM - 12AM |
| Thursday | 11:45AM - 12AM |
| Friday | 11:45AM - 12AM |
| Saturday | 12:45 - 1AM 11:30AM - 12AM |
| Sunday | 12:30 - 1AM 11:45AM - 12AM |
Marcello's Pizza offers a classic New York-style pizza experience with a crust that balances tender and crunchy textures. The restaurant is known for its tasty meatball dish, and customers can enjoy a quick and affordable slice for around $5, featuring a chewy, bread-like dough and generous cheese toppings. While the pizza quality may be inconsistent at times, Marcello's remains a popular choice for a hot and fresh pizza on a cold day.
The restaurant has received positive reviews, with customers praising the nostalgic flavor of the pizza, which reminds them of the pizzas they enjoyed in the past. Customers also appreciate the variety of specialty pizza options, such as the Greek combo veggie special, and the friendly service. However, some customers have noted the limited payment options, as the restaurant only accepts cash.
Overall, Marcello's Pizza provides a traditional pizza experience with a focus on quality ingredients and a welcoming atmosphere, making it a reliable choice for pizza lovers in the area.