10 Best Italian Restaurants near Sutter

“Just had their awesome pizza the best I have ever had“

“Thank you, Dancing Tomato Caffé, for such an easy and enjoyable collaboration. We’re looking forward to working with you again soon!“

“Hands down the BEST date night ever! 🥰😍💙 Tender steak bites, potatoes, asparagus and minestrone soup for the win. Great ambiance and atmosphere. The vibe was right, the service was on point and the quality of food was 100. Both of our steaks were cooked to PERFECTION. 🥰🥰🥰He booked reservations without me knowing and suprised me on a date night out together at this restaurant that is known for their Italian food and steaks. Literally out of the places and steak houses we have been in and out of the state this place by far blew it out of the water! Highly recommend Pasquini's Fine Italian Food in Live Oak, California! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“We ate there tonight & several other nights! The food is always excellent, tonight we had bolengise, an baked beef ravioli! Awesome as always. The service is always like you're the only couple there, I have seen them go way above an beyond for customers. In this day of age with shortage of workers, you will never feel that at Marcellos. The owner is very present an social. Please support this business. It's very deserving of your business“

“Friendly staff. Stopped for takeout, we were pressed for time and they rushed our order. From arrival and placing order to exiting the parking lot, was only 15min. Extremely thankful to staff for going above and beyond to expedite our order so quickly. New to the area and look forward to many future visits. Thanks!!“

“We eat here at least once per week. This is definitely my go-to! The salmon piccata is the best by far I have ever had, the fish tacos are also great. Really can’t go wrong with anything on the menu, Fernando is a very talented chef.“

“If you’re in the Yuba City area and haven’t tried Celestino's Pizza, let me save you some time — just go. 🍕 We ordered two pizzas — one giant regular crust, and one gluten-free — and both were absolute perfection. The crust was cooked just right: crisp on the bottom, soft on the inside, and not too thick or too thin. That magical “just right” balance. The toppings? Loaded. Not skimpy. Not scattered. LOADED. Every bite had melty, gooey cheese and generous toppings that made it completely worth every calorie. And let’s talk about that gluten-free crust — because sometimes that can be hit or miss — but this one? Nailed it. Same crisp bottom, same cheesy goodness, same satisfying bite. This is officially our new favorite place to indulge in a calorie-consuming, totally-worth-it pizza night. Honestly, my life is better with this pizza in it. If loving this pizza is wrong, I don’t want to be right. 😄🍕“

“Great pizza and even better service! Was hosting a large gathering in town and was looking to find a place that I could order ahead. After some bad vibes calling some local competitors I gave Sylvio's a call and their customer service was great! (Note if you're ordering more than 10 pizzas you may need to call in instead of doing it all on their website). The manager Steve hooked me up for my 12 XL pizza order and even gave me an unprompted discount. The pizza was amazing, they put the sauce all the way to the edge and fold the edges up so it almost seems like stuffed crust pizza (without being the obnoxious kind some places make that ooze out the sides). The sourdough crust was amazing!! The Home Run special is my personal favorite if you like meat but we had some vegetarian eaters in our group that loved the Healthy Harvest and even the cheese pizza. Super awesome place, please give them a try over the chain pizza places in the area. I haven't been to the physical location but the service from there and delivery were fantastic. My new favorite pizza place in Yuba City!“

“I work near by and come in for lunch about twice a week and am always welcomed with warm smiles. The pizza is great and I have gotten to know the staff as well. Special shout out to Amanda and Kayla. They are so nice!“

“Great pizza and love the Dynamite bread sticks. So good!“