6 Best Italian Restaurants in Estes Park

Antonio's Real New York Pizza Pizza • $
1560 Big Thompson Ave, Estes Park

Customers` Favorites

Calzone with Ricotta and Mozzarella
White Garlic Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Godfather Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
NY Style Pizza
Personal Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
The Godfather
Meatball Sub

“Service was a bit slow on Easter but everyone was so nice. Delicious pizza and garlic bread. They do NOT take allergen requests because of cross contamination concerns, but they will do non-allergen related substitutions (we just don't like the taste of cheese so ordered a cheeseless pizza). The robot servers were really good, wow, no mistakes and very fun and reminded us of our time in Japan. Super cute place that decks out for holidays (even their menus and plates were Easter colors and everyone wore hats or ears) and just a super nice vibe. Good prices and especially drink prices were impressive (Moscow mule can for 8, strong). Very happy. Was it the best pizza? No, not at all. But it was very good.“

4.4 Superb311 Reviews
Sweet Basilico Cafe Italian • $
430 Prospect Village Dr, Estes Park

Customers` Favorites

Ravioli Mushroom Marsala
Spaghetti Carbonara
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Marco Polo
Mushroom Ravioli
Caprese Salad
Garlic Bread
Fettuccine
Meat Sauce
Tiramisu

“What a homey experience at a family-owned business! We had the Especially Kaitlyn, the Chicken Alfredo Lasagna, and the Tiramisu and all dishes tasted wonderful and home-cooked. The server and the owner were also very kind and the menu has details on dietary restrictions. Highly recommend!“

4.4 Superb103 Reviews
Big Horn Restaurant Family • $
401 W Elkhorn Ave, Estes Park

Customers` Favorites

Green Pork Chili Breakfast Burrito
Fried Steak and Hashbrowns
Blueberry Stuffed Pancake
No 5 Country Fried Steak
Elk Burger with Fries
Chicken Fried Steak
Philly Cheese Steak
Biscuits and Gravy
Soup and Salad Bar
Homemade Chips

“Everything about this place is good, the service is so friendly, the food is delicious and big portions you will have leftovers. We ate here 2 times on our trip and it was great both times. We had nachos, spaghetti, brisket sandwich, chicken fried steak, and the pork green chili it was all awesome! We will be back anytime we come to Estes!“

4 Good182 Reviews
Mother's Cafe Italian • $
1480 Golf Course Rd, Estes Park

“Our server was bar none the best! The scenery here is beautiful! I enjoyed my eggs. Leo’s steak seemed frozen, but we couldn’t complain bc it was just beautiful & she was so kind. Maybe just a bad day for the cook? I would still try them again.“

3.7 Good31 Reviews
Mama Rose's Restaurant Italian • $$
338 E Elkhorn Ave, Estes Park

Customers` Favorites

Seafood Baked Pasta
Baked Seafood Pasta
Chicken Saltimbocca
Vegetarian Lasagna
Fettucine Alfredo
Fried Mozzarella
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Zucchini
Caprese Salad
Garlic Bread

“We have been to Mama Rose's a few times over the years. Our last visit was the week before Christmas 2023. We had been a bit disappointed with our meals in Estes Park on this trip (as restaurants can be a bit off their game this time of year). But we were very pleased with our meal at Mama Rose's.We started off with a Caprese for an appetizer -- we are not normally not fans of black pepper, but the cracked black pepper was added at just the right amount to make this very tasty, and the basil leaves were very fresh -- we were almost fighting over the last couple of tomatoes and cheese. My wife and I often share our meals, and this was no different as we shared a lasagna and a fettucine with tomato cream sauce (with meatballs added) -- we absolutely loved both of them. Unfortunately, our son did not like the fettucine with pesto sauce (we should have remembered this from the past). But our server (I wish I could remember her name, but she said she had been there for 9 years we think) was so wonderful and brought him a dish of the fettucine with tomato cream sauce (with a sausage) -- as he tried ours and loved it. She took off the charge for the pesto dish (without us even asking her to do so).My son and I shared an order of cannoli for dessert, as my wife was too full to have any. This was a wonderful meal, and a great final dinner of our trip. We will definitely be back next time we visit Estes Park!“

3.8 Good181 Reviews
The Sandwich Mafia Sandwich Shop • $
100 Cleave St, Estes Park

Customers` Favorites

Slice of Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Chicken Pesto
Cheese Pizza
Ham Sandwich
Cheesy Bread
Uncle Tony
French Dip
Meatballs
Toasted

“When we walked in there was no line and right away we were greeted. You order your food fast casual and they bring it to you once you pay. The place has an upper level with tables that you can eat at and there are some condiments on the side. The place is cool with different pictures of mafia mobs. We got the pesto sandwich and the French dip and the pesto sandwich was our favorite!“

3.7 Good106 Reviews
Loading...
map Map