14 Best Italian Restaurants in Fort Collins

RARE Italian Italian • $$$
101 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Chesse Plate with Meats Home Made Mozzarella
Blistered Campari Tomato & Burrata
Chili-Glazed Brussels Sprouts
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Chocolate Hazelnut Torte
Brasato & Kale Risotto
Special 48oz Tomahawk
Braised Beef Ravioli
The Classic Lasagna
Apple Arugula Salad

“7-day a week Happy Hour from 4 pm to 6 pm -- Woo Hoo! Get there early as there are only around 10 seats at the bar but this Happy Hour is so outstanding you want to work your way through all the items -- how about a Margherita Pizza for $7! Or a Dry-Aged Cheeseburger Platter with Fries for $12! Or Truffle Fries as a great snack with a cocktail for $5! And on top of that last night (11-14-22) I had the best Prosciutto I've had in years as part of an Antipasti and if I'd gotten that alone it would have been just $5!!! The place is lovely and the staff are all very gracious and hospitable -- this Happy Hour gets my 5 stars!!!“

4.5 Superb146 Reviews
Nick's Restaurant And Bar Italian • $$
1100 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Brussels Sprouts Caesar Salad
Garlic Bread with Marinara
Nick’S Famous Burger
Bucatini Carbonara GF
Local Sausage Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Chicken Parmesan
Fried Mozzarella
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“Awesome service, pet friendly in outdoor seating area, and the Local Sausage Pizza was fabulous. Thanks Luke and Andrea.“

4 Good137 Reviews
Oregano's Italian • $
4235 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Linguini
El Diablo Shrimp Pasta
Kick-Butt Garlic Bread
The Big Beefstro Salad
Fried Zucchini Sticks
Julius Caesar Salad
Oregano’S Favorite
Italian Flag Lasagna
Garlic Cheese Bread
Boom Dip Appetizer

“Thank heavens we celebrated our 36 year anniversary at Oregano's yesterday! Jeffrey was fantastic by making us feel super special! Let's not forget how delicious the chicken Parm and pizza were as well! We love this place for the service, food and ambiance!! 5 stars always!!“

4.6 Superb220 Reviews
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Italian • $
3905 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Alfredo Fettuccine Alfredo Tossed with Sautéed Shrimp
Never Ending Dipping Sauces for Breadsticks
Unlimited Soup Salad & Breadsticks
Chocolate Lasagna Dessert Cake
Salad with Italian Dressing
Soup Salad and Breadsticks
Chicken & Shrimp Carbonara
Chocolate Brownie Lasagna
Chicken and Gnocchi Soup
Salad and Bread Sticks

“I don't usually comment on big chains, but without saying a word about it, Maddy convinced me otherwise.

The food exceeded my expectations, and I didn't even get pasta. The salmon was super-tasty and tender, the garlicked broccoli done to perfection. The dinner companions, all of whom actually did get pasta, thoroughly enjoyed their dishes. I don't eat much bread, but I found myself snarfing down those tasty breadsticks.

The service. Ah, yes. Here we go. Maddy was perfect, and I don't say that lightly. She was at the table quickly after we sat down. She checked on us often enough that we knew we were being cared for, but stayed away enough to let us have uninterrupted time together. She brought a refill for me before I had my glass finished.

Maddy had a constant genuine smile and beamed a positive attitude every second she was at our table, including while unloading a dinner plate tray that was bigger than she was. When I threw out lightly snarky humor, she was quick with a friendly and funny rejoinder.

I wish we could clone Maddy for every restaurant in the country. Seriously, I'm old, and I have never had better or more enjoyable service at a restaurant.

Thank you, Olive Garden. It was a surprisingly great experience with food quality, price, and service, and I just might have to come back.“

4.4 Superb241 Reviews
Domenic's Bistro and Wine Bar Italian • $$
931 E Harmony Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Beef Carpaccio with White Truffle Oil Parmigiano
White Lightning Pizza
Mediterranean Salad
Domenic's Ahi Tuna
Chicken Franchaise
Chocolate Souffle
Domenic's Risotto
Sausage Bolognese
Pesto Pappardelle
Shrimp & Grits

“I enjoyed my visit. The wait staff was friendly and helpful. The Bar was a favorite followed by the pizza I ordered. My orders from the bar were prompt and flavorful. The bartender or should I say mixologist created drinks that wowed the pallet and ensured I will return.“

4.2 Good71 Reviews
Gelato & aMore Gelato • $
1720 W Mulberry St Suite A1, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmigiana with Spaghetti
Cold Italian Deli Sandwich
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
Chicago Italian Hot Beef
Italian Sausage Sandwich
Veggie Breakfast Pizza
Italian Beef Sandwich
Italian Meatball Sub
Anisette Cheesecake
Italian Wedding Soup

“Came here for boiled peanuts cause I heard they have those, wound up getting spinach cannoli and the best gelato ever. The owner was also here and was super welcoming and passionate about his restaurant. We will absolutely be back. 😄“

4.7 Superb117 Reviews
La piadina - Italian Flatbread Sandwiches Pizza • $
234 N College Ave Unit B3, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Piadina with Prosciutto Stracchino and Arugula
Garlic Piadina Bread
Meatball
Daniele

“Excellent food, great staff. La Piadina is top drawer.“

4.8 Superb56 Reviews
Cozzola's Pizza Pizza • $
1112 Oakridge Dr #114, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Half and Half Hawaiian and Meat Eater
GF the Meat Eater Pizza 12
Barbecue Chicken Classic
12 Garlic Bread
Pesto Change-O
Hannah's Pizza
Montgomery Pass
Mama's Garden
The Omnivore
Big Veggie

“Cozzola's is my FAVORITE pizza in Fort Collins! Their crust is perfect, not too thin and not too thick. It's chewy and reheats well. I LOVE that they have cream cheese as a topping and they are generous with it, unlike a Krazy place that I know. The pizza is always ready when they say it will be. Yes, it costs a little bit more than some places, but I think it's a good value for the quality. Love it!

Parking: There are reserved spots for Cozzola's.“

4.7 Superb43 Reviews
Carrabba's Italian Grill Italian • $$
1212 Oakridge Dr, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Mama Mandola's Sicilian Chicken Soup
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Strawberry Cheesecake
Cannoli Cake for Two
Fettuccine Carrabba
Fettuccine Alfredo
Johnny Rocco Salad
Fried Mozzarella
Pollo Rosa Maria
Sautéed Spinach

“food and service was great and thank you!!!“

3.6 Good98 Reviews
JJ's Wood Fired Pizza Pizza • $
4015 S Taft Hill Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Kids Cheese or Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread Dippers
Meatball Appetizer
BBQ Chicken Pizza
Gluten Free Crust
Margherita Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Hawaiian Pizza
Lasagna Pizza
Caesar Salad

“#HiddenGemFoCo# definitely the best pizza in town for me and my family .“

4.2 Good112 Reviews
Panhandler's Pizza - Fort Collins, CO Pizza • $
2721 S College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

California Artichoke Pizza
Chicago-Style Sausage Pizza
Combo Pizza by the Slice
The Lovehandler Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Cheese Garlic Bread
Original Pan-Style
Slice of the Day
Pepperoni Slice
Deluxe Combo

“been going for 40 years and I've always loved the place. no better pizza around.“

4.2 Good115 Reviews
Beau Jo's Fort Collins Pizza • $
205 N College Ave, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

The Pizza Skillet LLB Pizza Pricing
Cherry Beau Jo's Dessert Cobbler
Cauliflower Crust Pizza
Sky Hawk Mountain Pizza
Cranberry Walnut Salad
Aiden's Street Pizza
Garlic Cheese Bread
Gluten Free Pizza
Margherita Pizza
The Motherlode

“Only tried the mountain crust pizza but it was really good 💯“

4.2 Good218 Reviews
Mama Roni's Pizza Pizza • $
4733 S Timberline Rd, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Pesto Spinach Calzone
House Salad
Pizza Rolls

“Delicious pizza at a great price, not a long wait for food.“

3.7 Good50 Reviews
Pulcinella Pizzeria & Wine Bar Pizza • $
1119 W Drake Rd C12, Fort Collins

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pizza Slice
Large King Pizza
Caprese Salad
Diavola Pizza
King Calzone
Meatball Sub
Veggie Pizza
Pizza Rolls
Margherita
Four Cheese

“Pulcinella has always been a family favorite for delicious Italian-style pizza and a great glass of wine. Leno and the team are wonderful—always welcoming, helpful, and kind. Mary, the owner, is simply incredible; her warmth and hospitality shine through every time. I especially enjoy when she’s behind the bar, sharing stories of her amazing time in Italy and just being a joy to talk with. Pulcinella will always be a top choice for pizza in Fort Collins!“

3.7 Good89 Reviews

You May Also Like