4 Best Pizza Restaurants in Grand Lake

“Traditional Italian style wood fired pizza in Grand Lake, Colorado! We loved the Firefly special, the Margarita, the Carnivore, and the Funghi pizzas we ordered. The gelato was also authentic and a refreshing treat for dessert! Owner Mark Consiglio makes the dough fresh in house and his lovely wife and children work in the restaurant! This is a truly special place-don’t miss out on your next trip to Grand Lake!!“

“Nothing special but pretty good pizza for a mountain town - we ordered a pepperoni pizza with green olives. Tasty red sauce, good cheese, and flavorful crust (even without honey). Buffalo wings were pretty standard but good. Prices were fair. Staff were friendly. Overall, recommend if you are searching for a pizza spot in Grand Lake.“

“Incredible staff, drinks and food. Group I was with all had a blast. Perfect place to chill. A must stop when your in Grand Lake“

“I had such a great experience with White Buffalo Pub & Pizza Co. I called ahead to ask about bringing my dog, and the woman on the phone was incredibly kind and accommodating. She let me know I could come in briefly to pay for my to-go order, which I really appreciated.
While I waited outside, she even brought out water for my dog, which was such a thoughtful touch.
And the pizza—absolutely amazing. I’ve never been a big fan of artichoke pizza, but theirs completely changed my mind. It was genuinely one of the best pizzas I’ve had.
I would definitely recommend this place to others and will absolutely be coming back!“