25 Best Pizza Restaurants near Johnstown

“Wonderful experience at MOD Pizza! Great service and food was amazing!!!“

“Awesome food and great selection of beer“

“Went in looking to get a decently priced pizza and I was greeted as soon as I walked through the door. The staff were friendly and all seemed to be working well with each other. I ordered and had very little wait time for a nice fresh tasty pizza. I highly recommend Dominic’s pizza and you’ve gotta try the meat lovers.“

“Huge shout out to Domino’s. Saturday night my niece got married. The catering was beyond messed up. Barely enough food for 20 people when there were over 100 in attendance. One call to Domino’s, and an explanation of the situation, and we had around 40 pizzas delivered and all at an amazing price. Thank you Domino’s, you guys saved the day!“

“Stopped in on our way through the area and grabbed a couple slices and some cheesy bread to go. Food came out quickly and was fresh and delicious! The slices were large and foldable NY-style with lots of gooey cheese and that cheesy bread was nothing but gooey cheese and wonderfully crispy outside/fluffy inside crust. Highly recommend this place and wish I had gotten to try more!“

“This place is fantastic!! The best in windsor for pizza and all your favs !“

“First time trying Pelican Jo’s - very impressed. Started with delivery driver who was friendly and food got to Johnstown quicker than estimated time. Parmesan garlic wings were fantastic. Italian sub was best in area by a mile. Pepperoni Black olive calzone my wife ordered was delicious. So very pleased with our choice- recommend and will definitely try again“

“We ordered Mama Ruth’s for my softball team. They pizza was hot, fresh and tasty. We will definitely order from them again and will stop in when we are in the area.“

“Did the meat pizza and it is outstanding! Lots of meat and cheese! Great crust and friendly service!“

“This place is always the first place I think about after I get done with a baseball tournament in Windsor! The pizza is excellent, the pizza rolls are money, maybe a little bit pricey; but delicious. My favorite is the Italian Hot Melt with a side of aju sauce! Absolutely priceless! Customer service is perfect, and always makes me feel super welcome!“

“I love Pizza Vino! Such delicious food and excellent service! The atmosphere is also spot on! I would highly recommend coming here for a delicious and relaxing dinner. Great for date night or anytime! Amazing!!“

“Great Location, employees were friendly and service was fast. They have a crustless option for any of you KETO folks out there. I do miss the free cookie dough option after taking a survey though lol :)
Try the Gourmet Chicken & Garlic...you'll thank me later! Big Murphy Stuffed or the Cowboy are also solid choices.“

“Never had a bad pizza from PAPA Murphy’s“

“Disappointed with this first time order. Pizza was just barely cooked through. Huge crust with very thin dough base. Hardly any sauce (dry) Toppings were so so. Not much flavor, probably due to lack of sauce and cheese. Sticker shock like always these days. Sticker shock is worse when prices go up and product is skimpy. It's like two price hikes.“

“The three of us came to the hearth on a slow Saturday afternoon, atound 1pm. There was a decent amount of people at the bar and the dinning area was mostly empty. At first it took us 5 mins from sitting down to get a server to acknowledge us. I was disappointed by this but the feeling went away once our server came. Our server was friendly attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. We tried the $2 deviled eggs which I found over priced but the ingredients tasted fresh, but on the salty side. If you are sensitive to salt maybe try another appetizer.
I asked the server for a recommendation, this being our first time, he recommended the bacon and fig. Much like other reviews the cheese was lacking. The pizza crust was made well crunchy but not hard.
The kids pizza was huge and my little loved it. Overall after a rough start The Hearth's employees made the overall experience pleasant.“

“Very affordable happy hour 🍻“

“Jessica Saint is always a pleasure to see whenever we order papa John’s.. I know that if she is working I will get my pizza or whatever I order fast and it will be hot and fresh.. I hope EVERYONE who orders from this papa John’s gets to meet this amazing girl she’s so nice and friendly!!“

“This location always has outstanding turn around time and quality. I give it 5 stars because you simply can't go wrong with the quickness, convenience, and quality. I'll be it, there are more exciting pizza choices out there but not at this price point and not at this quickness.

My ONLY complaint about this particular Little Caesars is they do not and never have had ZapPaks in the little packets. Every other location I've been to carries them.

Vegetarian options: Literally a vegetarian pizza.“

“Got home after working a 14 hr day, I was starving an hangry! Tried to go to my usually place Pizza Hut(I know sorry for saying it on here) buttttttttt they were closed an it was 1030. Not happy, said heck with it I’ll order dominos. Placed order at 10:42 an at 11:05 it was at my door!!� honestly it was the best pizza I’ve had in a minute. I’ll deff be switching my business to this location. Friendly driver, very polite an the pizza was � Thanks guys“

“**WINDSOR DELIVERY is through DOORDASH!** I ordered through the website but the restaurant missed something (did not add meatballs we paid $7 for). When I called Roma a very rude girl answered and said nothing could be done, that it was DD’s fault Roma got the order wrong, then insisted she used to be a manager and knew there was nothing that could be done. Luckily an actual manager stepped in (I believe his name was Kyle) and contacted DoorDash and got us a refund for food we didn’t receive. Kudos to him for displaying empathy and helping resolve the matter. But it was absurd I had to insist 10 times to the first girl that I didn’t place my order through DD nor have the app on my phone nor know how to contact them directly (maybe that’s the reason she’s no longer a manager?). Regardless, the food we did get was very delicious and we appreciated all of Kyle’s help. But we’ll order takeout from now on.“

“Great local bar & grill! We stopped in for a bite and a drink after finishing business in the area! Chloe was our bartender, and she was amazing! Drinks were perfect. We had a salad and the Italian nachos! Great food and more than welcome could eat!
We'll definitely be back!“

“Loved it! First time, will retun.
Romas is right down the road so we decided what the hell let's give it a try.
So glad we did! We went on a Monday so it was 40% off pizza, which was awesome! We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, an order of garlic bread, husband ordered a 34oz beer, and we had two sodas on our tab (free refills on the soda.) Our total was $36 and some change! Wow! The price for all we got made me so happy I could've cried 😄 AND the food was good, that was the best part!
I'm tired of going out to eat and paying $50 plus for my family of 3 to eat just about anywhere, and the quality of food everywhere has gone down hill.
Roma's was pleasant for the atmosphere too nice, small and cozy feel.
All around 10/10 would recommend, will return. Asking ourselves why we've lived here for 2 years and just now tried this location, wasted my money everywhere else on pizza. No more.
Romas was amazing!“

“For those who drive by or order delivery from this Pizza Hut, you probably should stop in. They remodeled the interior a few years ago, and frankly it is a lot nicer than before. I like to order carry-out as they have a GREAT deal if you order online. We eat pizza from a number of places around Windsor, but I'll say that since I found that deal we 'gravitate' to 'the HUT'. The staff is consistently nice and talks with me as I pay for my order...though I will say I have not been in our Pizza Hut when it is crowded and loud since like 2015. Makes for a comfortable experience enjoying a Pizza in my opinion.“

“I ate at The Sand Bar last night. It's down in the basement of the main restaurant clubhouse (upstairs on the main level is their fine dining). The booths are like golf cart seats, and the ceiling is painted blue like the sky with wraparound accent lighting behind a little shelf that's recessed in the ceiling. The cheeseburger I got was a bit too dry, and the tots could've been sprinkled with seasoning. The Key Lime Pie was good but very sweet. The standout for me was the chicken taco! They put about as much chicken and cheese as would fit in it. I certainly feel like I got my money's worth. It tasted delicious. After the dry burger, the chicken was nicely seasoned and dripping with juice.
The sink in the men's room was broken, meaning they needed to reattach the faucet to the granite sink. Water still came out and I could wash my hands. They said someone else also let them know and that they'd put in a work order to get it fixed.
But the most unpleasant thing about the whole meal last night was the obnoxiously loud guy sitting at the bar dropping frequent f-bombs. Looking over at another family table of 4, they seemed to be a bit uncomfortable and glaring over at him. Look, I get it. People get loud, rowdy, and drunk at a bar. I'm not a member here, but I have worked at a few country clubs. Stuff like that might happen out on the golf course, but never in the restaurant in front of children and more elderly members. At the very least, I don't think it unreasonable for one of the bartenders or managers to have asked the guy to speak a little quieter so that the whole restaurant didn't have to hear his many conversation topics and vulgar language.“

“Cheesus crust! Best pizza any gal could ever devour!“