“I had written a sour review for this store after I got a pizza that had looked to have been dropped at least once. On that I know it was likely DoorDash. The store was busy so I sent an email. They responded by offering me two free pizzas. I live alone so I just took one, and unlike when dominos or Pizza Hut replace an order papa John’s did NOT charge me a delivery fee or tip. So papa John’s replaced my pizza for free free. Not $10-$15 ‘free’ like the other places. After being disappointed with the last pizza, the one they sent for free was some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Thank you papa John’s and special thanks to Anthony for making everything right.“
“I have not had Papa John's pizza in a decade or so. We saw the tv commercial for the new garlic stuffed crust pizza and opted to give it a try. Ordering was extremely easy from their website. We ordered pick up as the store is only five minutes away from the house. It was ready in 15 minutes and waiting for us when we arrived. The young woman that gave us our order was professional and very pleasant. I found the price to be a tad on the expensive side. The building was clean and well organized. The parking lot was clean and well maintained. My wife really enjoyed the pizzas we ordered but I was a tad less impressed. I found it a tad doughy and couldn't take the "garlic" that looked so extreme on tv. The garlic dipping sauce was good but the buttery flavor backed up on you pretty fast. All in all it was a solid 4 experience. I'm not sure I'd choose to order again as I've found other local pizza shops to be more to my liking. Your mileage may vary.“