16 Best Italian Restaurants in Pueblo

“Olive Garden is Olive Garden. They get you in quick. Give you some fresh salad and some hot breadsticks with garlic salt, and you get an Italian entrée. It’s pretty much the same everywhere you go, but they do have a rotating menu that keeps it fresh.“

“First visit to Pass Key. Food is delicious!“

“Amazing dish! My GF and I were just discussing what we could eat, and she out the blue, going ? cottage! I'm in my big rig right, and I haven't even looked into the location and space, yet she was adamant that I could get in there with no problem! The staff were very good in mannerism, the service was expert, and the dishes we purchased was a fulfilling lunch close to dinner“

“A great place to go to increase your joy this holiday season. Most of the trees have lights on them bringing beauty to each visitor. On Friday through Sunday boat rides are available for a fee. The rides are calming very lifting of ones Christmas spirit. The ride is about 15 minutes so not too long for kids. I didn't have an Sea sickness or problems riding. A good group activity. When I attended there was a choir singing Christmas carols which made things more festive. The welcome center sells beverages and snacks. Coco was available.“

“Great value, large portions, fast service. They literally have the best spaghetti and meatballs I have ever had... Not to mention the freshly baked roll that comes with! I've never had a reason not to come back.

Thank you, Collette's Catering!“

“Love this place it has been in our family for years I would really hate to lose them they have the best burgers in Pueblo because they use real hamburger for thier burgers and everything but the bread is home made her and the staff are all friendly and it's always clean and full of hungry people. Best place for parties as well as bring your whole family and enjoy a very nice place to eat real food for a good price.“

“Best pizza in Pueblo, by far! Plus amazing customer service!“

“Food was great, service was great, but $3.50 each for a cup of water?? Yea we won’t be back.“

“Great family owned restaurant with a relaxed atmosphere. This is a local favorite restaurant. Great spot for a big family dinner or date night. I reccomend the cannoli! We’ve also reserved the upstairs for a private party and numerous meetings. The staff is friendly and professional!“

“Got to Gus' Place an hour early, tuff to gauge it just right when you drive 11+ hrs to get here?! History is made right here...thanks Pueblo & Gus' Place!“

“We always have such a great time especially love the Spaghetti Special on Sunday. I want to give huge praise to our sever Nicholas! He always serves us on Sundays and he’s such a great nice guy and we love that he’s our server on Sundays! He’s beyond professional and keeps us entertained during our dinner.“

“just ordered a door dash order through them. made it a meal for an extra 5$ and all I got was a drink did not not receive my pizza. rip off to get food here“

“My husband and I stopped in for lunch and it was amazing the customer service was great and extremely child friendly would definitely recommend this place and will be returning“

“This is one of those places I always order the same thing, and it's always great. My go-to 10"pizza with alfredo sauce, chicken, roasted red potatoes, chilies, and gorgonzola. Side of marinara sauce (for dipping the crust at the edge of the pizza.) So good!!“

“Great food and friendly service“

“If you're in Pueblo and craving pizza, look no further—Toni & Guys is hands down the best in town!
Their delicious, chewy-crisp crust is the perfect foundation for generous toppings that will leave you satisfied and coming back for more!
Trust me, I’ve tried every pizza joint in Pueblo, and nothing compares to the mouthwatering creations here!
Plus, it’s the perfect spot to enjoy a slice (or two) alongside a cold beer. Don’t even think about going anywhere else—this is the pizza experience you’ve been dreaming of!“