50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Mystic

“Mystic Pizza has by far, some of the best pizza I've ever eaten. the staff was great and very friendly. Ask for Alex, she was wonderful.“

“went to pick up a pizza a few weekends ago. i swear to god, the guy behind the counter must have been a magician because i watch him check out FOUR different pick up orders at the same time. i had to wait a bit for my order, but they were obviously insanely busy so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ i asked counter guy his name bc i wanted to include it in this review, but i've since forgotten (maybe nick?). regardless, 11/10“

“📅 09.16.25 WRITTEN REVIEW Big Al’s Reel Reviews - EP.163 🍕 Mango’s Wood-Fired Pizza Co. 💎 'Big Al's 💎 Gem Spot' Old Mystic Village, CT This afternoon I pulled up to the Village of Mystic straight from BMW of Warwick in my new BMW M850i Gran Coupe to see if Mango’s could raise the B.A.R.R... because I was hungry. And they absolutely did. In fact, this spot just became a Big Al’s 💎 Gem Spot. Here’s how it all went down: 1️⃣ Wood-Fired Wings (Buffalo) - $15.95 BOMB! 💣 Eight perfectly wood-fired wings- crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, with buffalo sauce that hits just right. The blue cheese dressing deserves its own shoutout 💣😎 2️⃣ Oma’s Real Meatball Sandwich- $17.50 BOMB! 💣 These wood-roasted, hand-rolled meatballs were full of flavor and smothered in rich pomodoro sauce, tucked inside toasted rustic bread with melted provolone and parmesan. It comes with potato chips and a fresh crunchy pickle. 3️⃣ Small Mango’s Mozzarella Pie- ½ Mozzarella/Funky Monkey- $19.95 💣 DOUBLE BOMB! The cheese half? The best cheese pizza I’ve had on this side of the Thames River, perfect crust, flawless sauce-to-cheese ratio. The Funky Monkey half? 💣💣 DOUBLE BOMB! The heat level was spot-on and the flavor combo was straight 🔥. Verdict: Mango’s brought the flavor, the service (big shoutout to my server Jessica, who was mad cool 😎 🙌🏾), and the vibes. This is officially a Big Al’s Gem Spot, and one I’ll be coming back to again. ☝🏾❤️ - Big Al Mayo “See you on the Rebound, Peace✌🏾out”“

“Hands down some of the best food around, the pizza is perfect. Our new favorite place! We will be back!“

“Everything I've had at Nanas has been excellent! my favs are the drinks, risotto balls, pizza and hot donuts! The staff is the best!“

“The service was great, drinks were delicious and the pork chop….perfection!“

“So glad we found this hidden gem ! Staff was super friendly, and quick. Red onion burger was probably thee best burger I've ever had ! French fries were super crispy and delish!! Hubby got a chicken parm grinder and cheesy fries. So much food we took a doggie bag to go. Pies and cakes looked super yummy. Friend got a small pizza and it was just loaded with so much meat !! Great food, excellent prices. If we are ever back in the area we will certainly visit again !!“

“Best Eggplant Grinder I have ever had. I had it on the sesame roll. I totally recommend.“

“I got the Fish and Chips last night 09/03/2024. Everything was cooked perfectly and the portions were quite big. I usually don’t get to have seafood because I moved down south near Asheville, NC but this place made one of my favorite meals (that I don’t get to have too often anymore) perfectly even the fries were cooked perfectly. Thank you very much!!“

“Would love to have ordered dinner, but can barely see the photo of the menu due to the angle. Please put a regular menu list on website…thanks“

“Great pizza, friendly service, 2 NY Slice Pizza Slices and a drink for 8 bucks, you can't beat that. Best Pizza Around!“

“Have been a customer of Golden Pizza for over 20 years. It's hard to see that it's even there if you don't know it. They are great people, and the food is delicious. They always have special's on the board and great soup!“

“The pizza and wings are phenomenal!!!!“

“Been coming here for years. The margherita pizza is my favorite. Definitely worth the hour drive ❤️“

“Great eats highly recommend“

“Always good food , kids enjoy the grinders , fish and fries , chicken tenders“

“Amazing people, wonderful food. They make you feel like family“

“Everything about this place screams family! Their interaction from beginning to end was amazeballs! The food is so damn good. The decor is refreshing and friendly with some awesome collectibles. The owner Demitri is so friendly. He made us feel at home. We drove an hour and a half to see what the hype was about this place and we’re glad we did. Thanks for literally everything!“

“Best pizza I have had. The staff was amazing, pizza even better. Highly recommend The Rolling Tomato.“

“My first time here. Walked in and was greeted by several friendly ppl. Ordered a grilled cheese with tomatoes and fries (extra crispy pls). Took my order home and proceeded to eat it. Let me tell you something- that grilled cheese was DELICIOUS. It had been made with thick bread, nice and buttery with the perfect crunch when you take a bite ? grilled
to perfection! To boot, the fries where cooked perfectly! I’m looking forward to trying out the other food!“

“Ordered delivery on a taco pizza, pepperoni pizza, onion rings and a lb. of chicken tenders. Everything was made with fresh ingredients and tasted delicious. Delivery was fast. Highly recommend!“

“Hilltop is like going to your grandma's kitchen each time. The food is so amazing. Anytime I want some good home cooking that I don't want to cook,hilltop is where I go. The soupy pizza is one that dave portnoy would give a 10 to without question. The French onion soup is my favorite,especially on a rainy day! The staff is like family and it's always a welcoming atmosphere“

“Outstanding food, service, atmosphere. Pricing was well worth the huge portions. First time visit. Would definitely return. Five stars.“

“Salt and pepper shakers were sticky and nasty to touch. Food is good otherwise. They need waitresses or waiters. Not the dude with a hoodie on all the time.“

“Excellent pizza, one of the best in town!“

“Just ate here for the first time today. Excellent pizza. Even got $10 off for joining their rewards program. Definitely recommend 👍“

“This is the best Italian food you will find in Rhode Island. Never rushed, great portion size, unreal flavor. Longos never disappoints“

“The food was delicious and was made in a timely manner I ordered a BBQ chicken pizza and it was delicious“

“great food great customer service“

“My son Zak and I had lunch here today. This was our first time and it won't be our last. I had heard so much about this place I just had to check it out. It was a quiet afternoon and not too busy. Our server was also the bartender, service was fast, friendly and pleasant. The menu is HUGE as is the specials board and their favorites. I started out with a huge bowl of delicious steamers. They came with a bowl of what I believe to be broth to rinse the steamers in and another bowl of melted butter to dip those delicious steamers in. Next I ordered the fried whole belly clams. Out came a mountain of deliciousness that was NOT over fried. They were tender and sweet and oh so good. They came with another mountain of thick French fries and creamy tartar sauce. My son Zak ordered the Shepard's pie. He got a ginormous plate of good looking Shepard's pie with three thick slices of Italian bread. We both totally enjoyed our meals but there was so much that we were both too full to finish. So we both took home a good amount of yummy leftovers. We will definitely return to try more of their interesting menu items. I'm definitely interested in trying the soupy pizza.🍕“

“Great food and prices fresh food.😃“

“So friendly and family oriented. Great music plus games“

“Ninos provides amazing food and customer service. We are regulars when it comes to their pizza, grinders and pasta. Last night they catered for our gender reveal party and we had assorted pizzas, a 3 foot long steak and cheese grinder, garlic knots and focaccia bread. Everything was great and our guests really enjoyed the food!“

“Pre-ordered my 4 medium pizzas at 9 am for a 5:45 pm pickup for my mother's 80th birthday celebration. Had to wait an additional 15 minutes because they weren't ready and they said they messed up an order. Due to this, they offered to add an additional cheese pizza at no charge.
Kitchen and prep station looked clean.
Parking area is a bit tight if you have an SUV.“

“Ate there recently and had a great meal! And our server Lisa was so sweet and the service was perfect.“

“So good � the food is so good & it’s like home made healthy quality not like fast food quality �“

“Real good!“

“Catering plans for my daughter's birthday party fell apart the DAY BEFORE the party. Tony and the Pizza Lady bailed us out and provided great food (at a great price) with less than 24 hours to deliver. Amazing. I am impressed, grateful, and fully endorsing Pizza Lady as your next caterer (or movie-night Pizza Party).“

“01.03.25 Can you find Healing at The Recovery Room in the ❤️City of New London, CT❤️ This place earned two 💣💣!! My Hunger was healed and tamed at The Recovery Room Restaurant located at: 445 Ocean Ave. New London, CT ❤️ 'Big Al's Reel Reviews' Keeping it Real to Reel! ☝🏾❤️ -Big Al Mayo“

“Ordered a couple pizzas and enjoyed a beer at the bar while waiting. Staff was great, and the pizza is the best. Will go back often!“

“1st time ever ordering here. Ordered a house special for take out. Order was ready when they said it would be, absolutely delicious, prices are pretty good too. Didn't eat there but appeared clean overall. Am definitely ordering again?“

“Karen and team catered an event for us over the weekend. The process was seamless. The food was terrific. They mapped everything out for us based on the expected crowd size. They even delivered, including plates and silverware. Highly recommended.“

“Had lunch here for the first time on a Wednesday afternoon and really loved the vibe of the place. Enjoyed the Pesto Grilled Cheese sandwich, Yacht Club Diet Cola and a hot sourdough doughnut for a sweet treat. Everything was fresh, delicious and just great. Courtney, our waitress, was just perfect all the way around.“

“Finally! We've dreamed about this experience for years! It was amazing!!!! The scallops are life changing!
I had the 3 course with wine pairing.
The Wellington was everything I hoped for.
The sticky Toffee Pudding gave the warm and fuzzies. The wine perfectly paired with each course.
This was the best experience. Thank you, Kyle for taking a minute to talk to me. The whole experience was amazing. 10/10..“

“My husband and I live in Chesterfield VA (Rich)
Every year we come up to CT and have to come to our favorite Pizza place. I get spaghetti w extra meatballs and cheese. My husband always a grinder. The best is the rice pudding. Omgoodness the very best. We love the owner. He always has a big hug and the whole staff is wonderful. We always have a cooler full from Midway Pizza.
Bob & Tammy“

“They’re plenty of good things to say about Fireside. The service, the food, even the music! Fireside easily became one of my favorite places to dine at. It’s such a beautiful establishment with amazing owners. Even the servers are amazing. The days i’ve been I was served by 2 amazing ladies. Patricia and Chloe. Extraordinary servers and their patience was amazing. Truly a great experience all around. The food is exactly what you’d want. In my opinion the crisp is the New Haven staple. Great restaurant.“

“Great service. Love the app.“

“I used to go here all the time. I used to pay 10 bucks or less for 2 slices and a soda, but now I paid 15 bucks for 2 slices of pizza and 2 sodas. Yikes! Good pizza, just now pricey. I think the soda costs more than the slices. No soda for me next time. I'm not a huge fan of crust (it's bland), but that's my personal opinion. NY style, and I love ny style.“

“The food is great and my family and I go at least once a week. All so the people that work there are great to. Love that place.“

“The Pequot is a very special place and Ian is a great manager“