8 Best Bakeries near New Hartford

“Was cruising, looking to buy eggs from local farms and saw this place on the way. We bought the strawberry rhubarb pie… the best thing I’ve ever eaten! My family devoured this pie within 2 days and I’m so sad because I ate the last slice! Instructions were precise! I will definitely buy more!!!“

“I love these bagels! They are not your average bagels, which makes them sooo much better, and much more satisfying on the stomach.“

“Five star coffee, food, service, prices, five star overall. Plenty of seating, and parking!“

“Excellent treats and such fun decor“

“I had such a great experience at Crumbl! The service was absolutely excellent from start to finish. The staff were friendly, efficient, and really made me feel welcome. I especially want to shout out Teresa — she was amazing! She greeted me with such a warm smile, helped me pick out the best cookies, and made sure everything was perfect. You can tell she really cares about the customers and loves what she does.“

“I have been going to this Bakery for the better part of 15 years. I moved out of state and to this day every time I come home for the holidays I make it a point to order the Rum cake. It is hands down the best Rum cake I have ever had. The pastries are always phenomenal and the place is so nostalgic. It still is pretty vintage looking inside and has never changed and never needs to. Reminds me of my childhood. It has always been the same sweet woman behind the counter all this time and I think her husband works in the back. I love this place so much and it feels like home to me. It’s one thing in our town that has remained the same. I hope you all know how much this town appreciates you guys. My other favorites from here are the cookies. The breads filled with jam. Cannolis, Neapolitan & the Bavarian creme filled cake with coconut on top.“

“Cake Gypsy has been around since 2009 and was founded by Deanna Damen. They're known for their custom cakes and approximately 50 different flavors of cupcakes. They also offer vegan and gluten free options.

I've been to both the Avon and Canton locations. Both great and had so many delicious cupcakes. This one in Canton offered cannolis, candies, chocolate covered oreos, and of course cupcakes.

Once you walked in, you have to fill out a form letting them know what kind of cupcakes you want. There were a handful of tables and customer service was good. I chose 6 different cupcakes to share with my family and it was all fantastic.

They are closing this Saturday November 8th, 2025 and I'm really sad to see them go.“

“I make fried bread often and this bread is so similar to my recipe I almost can’t tell a difference! So much easier when you buy precooked! I love it! It will be a regular in a small cafe I am currently negotiating to purchase!“