10 Best Bakeries near New Hartford

“Was cruising, looking to buy eggs from local farms and saw this place on the way. We bought the strawberry rhubarb pie… the best thing I’ve ever eaten! My family devoured this pie within 2 days and I’m so sad because I ate the last slice! Instructions were precise! I will definitely buy more!!!“

“Everything is baked with love and tastes like love“

“I have been going to this Bakery for the better part of 15 years. I moved out of state and to this day every time I come home for the holidays I make it a point to order the Rum cake. It is hands down the best Rum cake I have ever had. The pastries are always phenomenal and the place is so nostalgic. It still is pretty vintage looking inside and has never changed and never needs to. Reminds me of my childhood. It has always been the same sweet woman behind the counter all this time and I think her husband works in the back. I love this place so much and it feels like home to me. It’s one thing in our town that has remained the same. I hope you all know how much this town appreciates you guys. My other favorites from here are the cookies. The breads filled with jam. Cannolis, Neapolitan & the Bavarian creme filled cake with coconut on top.“

“Love the unique varieties of bagels and they are so fresh and delicious! Will definitely go back!! Great coffee, too ❤️“

“literally the BEST cookies I've ever had. the smores cookies are to DIE for so gooey and sweet 😋“

“I make fried bread often and this bread is so similar to my recipe I almost can’t tell a difference! So much easier when you buy precooked! I love it! It will be a regular in a small cafe I am currently negotiating to purchase!“

“Ordered some cinnamon rolls and brownies this weekend and they were AMAZING. Transaction was seamless, and we got a very fast response to our inquiry. Brownies are rich and fudgy, and the cinnamon rolls were some of the best I've ever had. We will definitely order again!“

“It’s always very clean and stocked. Some of the workers are great and others don’t seem very friendly. I’ve never had a bad experience while at BJ’s. I have been going and shopping here for over 7 years now and will continue to!“

“This is just a great place I went on Saturday 5/22 to pick up and order realized I had the wrong date and they filled it anyway I was so please and shocked that there are still good people in this world thank you again so much and it was for my Dad's 84th bday which he enjoyed them a lot!! I actually cried when I got back into the car
Thank you again
Elissa
❤️🙏🏻“

“The shops and bakery cases are beautiful. The desserts are stunning and always taste amazing. I ordered a pre-designed cake and macarons for my son's birthday everyone loved the cake and said the macarons were the best they've ever had. It's also a great place to stop in for a treat“