Restaurants near New Preston

“I have been coming to The Owl restaurant for over four years and every time I go I'm reminded of why it's amazing. Ryan and his wonderful staff always create an amazing experience for customers, whether it's their first time visiting or 100th. Definitely a great spot in New Preston, CT as well.”

“So many great options, friendly staff, beautiful location!”

“Great burgers! Friendly service”

“This is the best Italian restaurant we’ve eaten in here or in Italy! The food is presented artistically and the taste is subtly complex and delicious!”

“This was such a nice dinner. My wife and I were celebrating our birthday and we couldn't ask for a better night. The food was spectacular, the ambience was relaxing, and service was impeccable. The chef came out and walked us through a couple dishes and really made the night for us. What a great guy! I couldn't recommend this place higher.”

“AMAZING. Should be Michelin star!”

“A wonderful globally inspired menu that is outstanding. Everything we had tonight was delicious and amazing! Super friendly staff and great service. Highly recommend a visit.”

“If you need a kick in the pants, get the Awakening blend! It helps me stay focused and fights off the brain fog.”

“Wife and I went out to dinner and as usual food was on point. Base menu is always good and they always have a seasonal menu of great options. I tried the smoked old fashion and it was a home run. They put on the whole show and smoked the drink right at the table. Definitely not a disappointment. They always have seasonal drinks and come up and ask how they were. Lots of care in the food and drinks they put on the menu.”

“I loved it for my first time”

“It’s my first time ordering pizza from there and picked it up. She said 35 minutes. Got there in 35 minutes. It was ready. Excellent pizza. I will be going back.”

“A trip to downtown New Milford isn’t complete without a trip to Jesse’s! 😋”

“First time customer and I’m hooked! Excellent staff, menu, and location. If you are in the area and don’t stop in, you are missing out!”

“First off, it’s lovely! So inviting when you walk in. Got a great cappuccino! Pastries looked so yummy! Very friendly staff! I’ll definitely be back:)”

“Had the best birthday spending the morning here! Live the vibe and everything about it! Will definitely be back!”

“Why clean the milkshake machine 15m before close? Isn’t equipment supposed to be cleaned after close? My family came in, and at 7:44 we asked if we could have 4 milkshakes, and they said “sorry the milkshake machine has been cleaned we don’t do them 15m before close.” … I do find that a bit silly especially during peak season, when it takes minutes to clean a milkshake machine.

Ice cream itself is always amazing, I guess I’ll have to come order my milkshakes 20m before close.”

“Simply the best!!! You’re missing out, if you don’t just go and try their breads for yourself. Enjoy!”

“exactly how a coffee shop should be”

“Mark Robinson and his team are conclusive and their ability to direct you into which area you can develop is key. They have a keen intuition for where the market is headed and when to makes profits. they are worth listening to. Try the consultation! And never go low in your portfolio even when the Market is in dip or pump.”

“All items were delicious / quite large servings - even had leftovers which were great. Highly recommend”

“Their rotating dairy free flavor is vegan (except for their honey flavored one) and they also have a rotating sorbet flavor. Very delicious! Updated from previous review on 2026-08-01”

“Others come and go but not Theo! Solid home cooked foods that keep you coming back for more!”

“This place is a diamond in the rough…. The Gibson sauce is to die for. I really really enjoyed our dinner ….. it’s my new favorite pizza place in CT - wow wow wow 10 stars - I’m in love !!!”

“Best burritos , any kind - make you full! Pulled pork meal delicious too!! We have always been happy w/everything we’ve ordered every time!”

“We just ordered your cheese pizza. It was superb! The pie itself and the crust were tasty. Thank you for coming to New Milford!!”

“Tried for the first time this weekend. Great food, great people!! Got Chicken Parm, Chicken Francese, Lasagna, and bread…all fantastic! Even gave me a free piece of ricotta pie…delicious. Highly recommend!”

“Yoko Kitchen consistently has delicious sushi and meals. Everyone who works there is kind and attentive. I highly recommend going if you haven't yet!”

“Great food & atmosphere !! what can i say ????”

“Amazing food, always fresh, large portions and friendly atmosphere.”

“Discovering Villarina's was simply delicious! Voted the best pasta and tomato sauce EVER by my 2 picky eaters, who completely devoured last night's dinner!! We will never cook store box pasta again 🙌 THANK YOU”